I would have the same general feeling (but I'd also trust Athena more than me since she's been here a lot longer!)
Related: I heard the same thing about Pembroke, but they're listed as a category B. I'm not sure if that means that it's still less popular than, e.g., Trinity Hall, or that the admissions statistics BGS uses are a couple of years old and Pembroke somehow recently soared in popularity. Any ideas?