The Student Room Group

Astro physics Spectral class question!!! HELP!!!

IMG_3752.jpg

I'm really confused by the question. Surely the smaller star ought to be hotter, but the mark scheme says it belongs to class G, WTF??? :mad::mad:

Please help!:smile::smile:
Reply 1
The cooler star should be the larger... Your explanation is poor though and in a 5 mark question you might only get 1 mark for giving the right answer with a bad explanation.
Imo you should have been talking about apparent magnitude (not power) luminosity, temperature, diameter and cross sectional area of the stars and distance to observer (same for both in a distant binary obviously)

the question is a chance for you to show off what you understand about what affects the amount of light coming out of a star.

since
it's a real example you can look it up to confirm the accepted sizes of the stars in herc 95
Reply 2
It's 5 marks for the whole thing, I think you're just forgetting that it works the other way round, with lower magnitudes meaning the star is brighter (i didn't read the question properly though).

Quick Reply

Latest