The Student Room Group

I'm torn between medicine and dentistry!

Scroll to see replies

Original post by cptKernow
On call, night shifts etc. Same deal as junior docs to start with. I was talking to some SH1 dentists in a hospital and one had been up for 20 hours. Also, they are expected to stitch up the heads / faces of the drunks on Fri/Sat night as hospital dentistry covers this.

The other drawback to hospital is the surgical work is mostly extractions, particularly wisdom teeth and kids. This will limit your ability to get back into general practice after a while.
On the plus side, there is a lot of variety in the clinics, including beyond the mouth


I've done some shadowing in a hospital, but I only got to shadow dental students. I didn't get to see the ''real'' hospital side to dentistry.
Original post by rowdy-rathore
Why are the hours awful?


because they won't be 9-5 ? as you'll have lates , weekends and on-calls as an OMF Dentalist/Doctorist ...
Original post by Vian
Isn't it almost exactly the same with medicine? As in staying in the same hospital/surgery once you get comfortable and perhaps having to move to other parts of the country if you're unlucky? If you get bored of the same surgery you could always apply somewhere else. Most of the dentists I know work in two practices anyway.


hardly , the way most training is structured will see you move between F1 and F2,(one 'big' hospital, one 'small' hospital) you may have move again for core training, and have three or four different hospitals during core training) and as a 'proper' registrar will move around the region you are doing your higher training in ...
Reply 83
Original post by zippyRN
hardly , the way most training is structured will see you move between F1 and F2,(one 'big' hospital, one 'small' hospital) you may have move again for core training, and have three or four different hospitals during core training) and as a 'proper' registrar will move around the region you are doing your higher training in ...


I meant when you've finished training and you have greater choice on where you can work.
Reply 84
I'm actually considering medicine now. Just because there's so many specialties and so many paths to go through. I really like the appeal of A&E too as it's fast-paced and diverse (except on Friday and Saturday nights of course!)


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 85
Original post by anthonyfl
I'm actually considering medicine now. Just because there's so many specialties and so many paths to go through. I really like the appeal of A&E too as it's fast-paced and diverse (except on Friday and Saturday nights of course!)


NO!! Don't go over to the dark side, the cake is a lie!

Anyway, medicine is definitely an interesting choice so I'm sure you'll enjoy it. Better get cracking on that work experience then!
Reply 86
Original post by Vian
NO!! Don't go over to the dark side, the cake is a lie!

Anyway, medicine is definitely an interesting choice so I'm sure you'll enjoy it. Better get cracking on that work experience then!


Don't say that haha! My opinion changes too quickly. It actually worries me! It's like medicine and dentistry alternate weeks in my mind!

Anyway, I'm going to do work experience for both as I'm sure it will help me come to a sensible, well thought decision. (and a lot of work experience I'm planning to do - volunteering, St Andrew's ambulance [same as St John's ambulance except for Scotland] etc. is applicable to both, so it's not wasted)







This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Original post by anthonyfl
Don't say that haha! My opinion changes too quickly. It actually worries me! It's like medicine and dentistry alternate weeks in my mind!

Anyway, I'm going to do work experience for both as I'm sure it will help me come to a sensible, well thought decision. (and a lot of work experience I'm planning to do - volunteering, St Andrew's ambulance [same as St John's ambulance except for Scotland] etc. is applicable to both, so it's not wasted)


i'd suggest you check out what your local Red Cross offers as 'St Andrew's First Aid' as they now brand themselves is a pale imitation of SJA and what the better BRC localities offer, have StAFA started doing moving and handling and gasses courses yet ? disregarding the fact StAFA don't operate ambulances or as far as i am aware have Cycle responders ...
Reply 88
My opinion (which is probably warped by the fact whenever I go to a dentist it seems to be a quick look in the mouth and out the door again and have never actually seen what they 'do')

Being a doctor is more exciting than being a dentist simply because there is more variety. Also you don't see many different and unusual things as a dentist, and if it does it's usually referred to a hospital for a doctor to look at.
(edited 11 years ago)
Reply 89
Become a Dentist in my opinion, better hours :smile: cosmetic work sounds fun too.

Become a Doctor of Teeth
Reply 90
Original post by Melo -
My opinion (which is probably warped by the fact whenever I go to a dentist it seems to be a quick look in the mouth and out the door again and have never actually seen what they 'do')

Being a doctor is more exciting than being a dentist simply because there is more variety. Also you don't see many different and unusual things as a dentist, and if it does it's usually referred to a hospital for a doctor to look at.


People really need to think what a doctor actually is. Most people seem to think GP - this is a specialisation and does not by any stretch of the imagination account for the majority of jobs.

To progress you need to specialise - i.e. reduce the variety. Unless you want to work harder for less money for the rest of your career that is. I suppose the advantage over dentistry is you have more specialities to choose from.
However, do not imagine that you can get into any speciality you fancy. The competition on some can be intense and may involve having to up sticks and move frequently.
Reply 91
Original post by cptKernow
People really need to think what a doctor actually is. Most people seem to think GP - this is a specialisation and does not by any stretch of the imagination account for the majority of jobs.

To progress you need to specialise - i.e. reduce the variety. Unless you want to work harder for less money for the rest of your career that is. I suppose the advantage over dentistry is you have more specialities to choose from.
However, do not imagine that you can get into any speciality you fancy. The competition on some can be intense and may involve having to up sticks and move frequently.


I know doctors specialise, but there are fields they can specialise into which still have much more variety than dentistry. Emergency medicine for example
Reply 92
Original post by Melo -
Being a doctor is more exciting than being a dentist simply because there is more variety. Also you don't see many different and unusual things as a dentist, and if it does it's usually referred to a hospital for a doctor to look at.

If its complicated, they'd usually be referred to a hospital for further dental treatment or Oral Surgery. If it's a uniquely medical problem patients would be advised to see a doctor, though I don't think they'd be referred.

I know a dentist who thought her patient may have cancer (not oral) and advised them to see a GP, though that was the extent of it.
Reply 93
There is a fair bit of variety. Consider what is included in terms of physiology covered and treatment; soft tissue, muscle, bone / joints, teeth, microbiology, materials science, x-rays, oral and systemic disease and on top of that you have a diverse selection of patients who aren't all in because they looked it up on the internet and think they have cancer!
Reply 94
Original post by cptKernow
There is a fair bit of variety. Consider what is included in terms of physiology covered and treatment; soft tissue, muscle, bone / joints, teeth, microbiology, materials science, x-rays, oral and systemic disease and on top of that you have a diverse selection of patients who aren't all in because they looked it up on the internet and think they have cancer!


Exactly! And I think a hospital would be the type of working environment I would prefer.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 95
Original post by anthonyfl
Hi everyone

I have a genuine like for teeth and have wanted to become a dentist for a while. I would love to give people great smiles, I especially like the cosmetic aspect.

However, I also have a strong interest in medicine. I have watched junior doctors on the BBC and a documentary on the sick kids in Great Ormond Street Hospital and I'd love to work in an environment like that.

I don't fancy being stuck in the same room with someone all week though, I prefer the hospital working environment. Managing my own practice for dentistry also appeals to me though.

I'm going for 10 months work experience, four hours a week at a private cosmetic dentist and one week in a hospital. Hopefully this will help me decide as I feel the time has come where I need to Persue one of these careers with 100% enthusiasm.

I'm not in it for the money either!


So you'll be ok if the Government decides not to pay you and instead put your wages towards easing the NHS's debts?

If only all clinicians thought that way.

LOL
medicine would be far more interesting and a more fun career (although I think it'll be more difficult and intense studying load).
Reply 97
Original post by Soft Cat
So you'll be ok if the Government decides not to pay you and instead put your wages towards easing the NHS's debts?

If only all clinicians thought that way.

LOL


There's no need for that. I intended to imply that money does not bother me, as both dentists and doctors can and do lead very comfortable lifestyles. Never did I suggest I would plan on working for free!


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 98
Original post by cgraham15
medicine would be far more interesting and a more fun career (although I think it'll be more difficult and intense studying load).


That's wrong, dental and medical degrees are both of equal difficulty. Intact I here first and second year of both are very similar.

Although I agree it would be more interesting :smile:

This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Original post by anthonyfl
That's wrong, dental and medical degrees are both of equal difficulty. Intact I here first and second year of both are very similar.

Although I agree it would be more interesting :smile:

This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


ah okay, its just sometimes entry requirments are less :colondollar: but yeah if you're smart enough to do either of them then its medicine you definately want to go for (unless you're set on dentistry, but if not and you can't pick just go for medicine!). :smile:

Quick Reply

Latest