I read the first little bit and got confused.
I think you should be able to make up your own mind. You clearly don't seem attached to the idea of Islam, so why force it upon yourself when you can make your own decisions? I could maybe understand their conviction to make you marry a muslim or carry on following the faith if they themselves were devout muslims, but they're not, so why are they picking and choosing and then reflecting this into pressure on you?
If you want to, do it, I'll tell you now, it's your life. Not theirs.
I welcome the muslim neg brigade, sorry if this offended any of you.