Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Welcome to the Oxbridge forums: where prospective and current students can discuss anything about Oxford and Cambridge.
Closed Thread
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
All-new Posting Guide! READ!   calcium878
 
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 10:21 #1 
swallows swallows is offline
Adored and Respected Member
Thread Starter
swallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the rough
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 465
Default Postgrad at Oxbridge
 
Does anyone have a vague idea what the competition is like for postgrad courses at Oxbridge? My situation is quite likely to be the following: AAAA at A level and a First class BA from Warwick University. I've heard both that competition for places is less intense AND alternately more intense so I'm slightly confuzzled...Also, does anyone know if, like at undergrad, it is important to look at college acceptance rates for various subjects so as to pick one with the best chance of acceptance: ie, for English undergrad, Somerville Oxford had 1 in 2 acceptance, whereas others had nearer 1 in 5. Cheers.
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 10:34 #2 
zoraster's Avatar
zoraster zoraster is offline Male
Benevolent Member
zoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to behold
United States
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Los Angeles, California
Posts: 838
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to zoraster
 
from what i've gathered from oxford, you're admitted first to the university and then to a college (reverse from undergrad). So in other words, if you get into the university, you're sure of a spot somewhere at a college. The reason for selecting a college with an eye toward acceptance rates is if you want to have a greater chance of going to a particular type of college rather than to gain admissions period full stop.

For example, if your main desire is to go to a central college that also has undergrads, you may want to pick the lowest ratio of those colleges so as to try and avoid templeton.

But at least the way I understand it, you don't increase your chances at all of admission into the university by selecting an undersubscribed college.
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 15:33 #3 
JustaGuy JustaGuy is offline
Exalted Member
JustaGuy will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 265
 
If you look at the acceptance rates for postgrad courses, they are in general, under 20%. In my year for my course, the acceptance rate was slightly under 13%.

I am not sure about college acceptance rate at postgrad level, but the way I understand it is you are now *gauranteed* a college place if you have been admitted by a department. It does not seem to matter much (at least to me) which college you get admitted to since your supervisors could be anyone from any college. (My two supervisors were from two different colleges, none of which was from my college)

Most colleges' grad accommodation are not on-site either, so if being central is a concern to you, then I would apply to those colleges where their grad accommoation is in central oxford (eg. Merton, Balliol etc).

Oh, and I *thought* Templeton only admits MBA students?
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 15:54 #4 
Wrangler Wrangler is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Wrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud of
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Rhyl
Posts: 921
 
Originally Posted by swallows
My situation is quite likely to be the following: AAAA at A level and a First class BA from Warwick University.
I'm lost. If you're only expecting those grades, it leads me to think you haven't actually attained them yet. And if you haven't even got A-Levels yet, I think looking at Postgrad courses might be jumping the gun a bit!

If I've got it all totally wrong - I do apologise!

To answer your question - I think it depends on lots of factors; the biggest, I would have thought, would be which subject area you want to study in.
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 16:03 #5 
shiny shiny is offline
TSR Demigod
shiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant futureshiny has a brilliant future
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 7,188
 
Originally Posted by swallows
Does anyone have a vague idea what the competition is like for postgrad courses at Oxbridge? My situation is quite likely to be the following: AAAA at A level and a First class BA from Warwick University. I've heard both that competition for places is less intense AND alternately more intense so I'm slightly confuzzled...Also, does anyone know if, like at undergrad, it is important to look at college acceptance rates for various subjects so as to pick one with the best chance of acceptance: ie, for English undergrad, Somerville Oxford had 1 in 2 acceptance, whereas others had nearer 1 in 5. Cheers.
If you want funding then expect the worse!
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 16:06 #6 
kalen's Avatar
kalen kalen is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
kalen is a jewel in the roughkalen is a jewel in the roughkalen is a jewel in the roughkalen is a jewel in the rough
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Oxford
Posts: 938
 
Originally Posted by JustaGuy
Oh, and I *thought* Templeton only admits MBA students?

Yes, I think it does...as does Nuffield, I think...Where the hell is Templeton anyway?? (said the Wolfsonian...)
 
Old 17-10-2005: 17th October 2005 16:21 #7 
RxB's Avatar
RxB RxB is offline
Overlord in Training
PS Helper
RxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud ofRxB has much to be proud of
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Cambridge/Oxford
Posts: 2,163
 
Nuffield is a social sciences college - it's also got the most amazing library in the history of time if OLIS is to be believed

Templeton is miles away
Old 18-10-2005: 18th October 2005 09:07 #8 
swallows swallows is offline
Adored and Respected Member
Thread Starter
swallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the roughswallows is a jewel in the rough
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 465
 
I'm lost. If you're only expecting those grades, it leads me to think you haven't actually attained them yet. And if you haven't even got A-Levels yet, I think looking at Postgrad courses might be jumping the gun a bit!

You are indeed wrong. I have my A levels and am a Third year at uni, and judging by my 2nd year results I should get a First, unless something goes drastically wrong.
Old 18-10-2005: 18th October 2005 18:27 #9 
Wrangler Wrangler is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Wrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud ofWrangler has much to be proud of
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Rhyl
Posts: 921
 
Originally Posted by swallows
You are indeed wrong. I have my A levels and am a Third year at uni, and judging by my 2nd year results I should get a First, unless something goes drastically wrong.
Ah - it all makes sense now.
Old 18-10-2005: 18th October 2005 21:12 #10 
hungry_hog hungry_hog is offline
Exalted Member
hungry_hog has a spectacular aura abouthungry_hog has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 320
 
You A-level grades are pretty irrelevant

It's about the area of research and the PhD supervisor you pick and the competition within that field, both for places and funding.
My offer was conditional on getting a first, but lots of people don't have them. In fact, met a couple of people with 2:1s from Hertfordshire, but this was for Chem, which has lots of places for PhD students, and thus a broader range of backgrounds.

Once you get into the Uni a place at a college is a certainty. Whether you get the college you want is another thing, and to be honest a bit of a lottery and there i no college interview as such. I put down Emma and Catz, and got into Emma.

If you put down somewhere like Trinity (Cam), which is well internationally well known, the chances of getting into that college are much smaller than (say) Fitz. Some people choose their supervisor's college.

Another point - nothing to stop you applying to both Oxford and Cambridge (unlike undergrad)
Old 21-10-2005: 21st October 2005 01:24 #11 
Cexy's Avatar
Cexy Cexy is offline
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Cexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond reputeCexy has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Ducks
Posts: 1,735
 
What subject do you want to study?

As you'll have a BA, I'll assume it's a humanities subject. Finding a supervisor is the most important thing, as far as I can tell. It's more important to find someone doing really good work in an area close to the one you want to work in, than to try to find someone doing mediocre work in exactly what you want to be doing.
Old 25-10-2005: 25th October 2005 16:28 #12 
fleur-de-lis's Avatar
fleur-de-lis fleur-de-lis is offline Female
Overlord in Training
fleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant futurefleur-de-lis has a brilliant future
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Tabland
Posts: 2,276
My Societies
 
Originally Posted by JustaGuy

I am not sure about college acceptance rate at postgrad level, but the way I understand it is you are now *gauranteed* a college place if you have been admitted by a department. It does not seem to matter much (at least to me) which college you get admitted to since your supervisors could be anyone from any college. (My two supervisors were from two different colleges, none of which was from my college)

Most colleges' grad accommodation are not on-site either, so if being central is a concern to you, then I would apply to those colleges where their grad accommoation is in central oxford (eg. Merton, Balliol etc).

Oh, and I *thought* Templeton only admits MBA students?

Templeton is only for MBA students.

I am sure that this must have been mentioned in the posts above, but usually, you are first admitted by the department and then your dossier is forwarded to the college of your choice. Whether or not they decide to accept you, is another question. But inevitably, there would be some college which would be willing to give you admission.

And yes, most of the grad accommodations are not on site... but usually are at a distance under 3-4 kms from the city centre. Keble used to have on site accommodation but I believe that this has been moved to the Acland Site in Banbury Rd. I have heard that Jesus provides on site accommodation though... needless to say, graduate colleges such as Wolfson, Green, St Anthonys etc provide accommodation on site itself.
Old 27-10-2005: 27th October 2005 15:34 #13 
youngone youngone is offline
Full Member
youngone will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 99
 
just a question

for humanities subjects (like english) if you want to apply for a research postgrad in oxford, how do you go about finding a supervisor? do you just submit your application and hope for the best? or do you actively seek one out beforehand?
Old 28-10-2005: 28th October 2005 05:37 #14 
JustaGuy JustaGuy is offline
Exalted Member
JustaGuy will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 265
 
Originally Posted by kalen
Yes, I think it does...as does Nuffield, I think...Where the hell is Templeton anyway?? (said the Wolfsonian...)

LOL erm Wolfson is not exactly very central either, and many people have no idea where Wolfson is!
--------------
Originally Posted by youngone
just a question

for humanities subjects (like english) if you want to apply for a research postgrad in oxford, how do you go about finding a supervisor? do you just submit your application and hope for the best? or do you actively seek one out beforehand?

Approach potential supervisors with similar (or closely related) research interests as you and find out if they are willing to be your supervisors *should* you get admitted by the university department. You'll need to have some research topic (that you intend to pursue) in mind before you approach them.
Old 28-10-2005: 28th October 2005 09:25 #15 
zoraster's Avatar
zoraster zoraster is offline Male
Benevolent Member
zoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to beholdzoraster is a splendid one to behold
United States
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Los Angeles, California
Posts: 838
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to zoraster
 
Originally Posted by JustaGuy
LOL erm Wolfson is not exactly very central either, and many people have no idea where Wolfson is!
--------------


Approach potential supervisors with similar (or closely related) research interests as you and find out if they are willing to be your supervisors *should* you get admitted by the university department. You'll need to have some research topic (that you intend to pursue) in mind before you approach them.
it's like a weird academic mating ritual.
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search