How would you explain this paradox?

Discuss the merits and deficiencies of political theories and philosophical questions.

Announcements Posted on
Please change your TSR password 23-05-2013
Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera 20-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. Username_valid's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 258
    How would you explain this paradox?


    The Achilles would obviously overtake the Tortoise but how would you solve the paradox?
  2. Giant's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 330
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    Because Achilles runs faster - he doesn't just move a few millimetres when he takes a stride

    Edit: The top comment on the video (on Youtube) pretty much sums up the nature of the paradox. He keeps moving closer and closer and closer to the tortoise until he passes the tortoise.
    Last edited by Giant; 25-06-2012 at 22:54.
  3. SneakyDoug's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 472
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    I know this doesn't answer your question but the guy who is narrating sounds like David Mitchell.
  4. Jelkin's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: The Shire
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    (Original post by SneakyDoug)
    I know this doesn't answer your question but the guy who is narrating sounds like David Mitchell.
    I'm pretty sure it IS David Mitchell!

    Maybe because in a second the tortoise effectively doesn't move a single step whereas Achilles does? I'm still not answering the paradox really though, as you could still put the same question to two continuously steadily moving forces.
  5. Username_valid's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 258
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    (Original post by SneakyDoug)
    I know this doesn't answer your question but the guy who is narrating sounds like David Mitchell.
    I just presumed it was David Mitchell, who is the narrator?
  6. miser's Avatar
    • Section Moderator
    • Green Mod
    • Location: Weston-super-Mare
    • Posts: 5,352
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    The paradox requires an infinite number of available points to be occupied between Achilles and the tortoise. Since there isn't an infinite precision in the placement of atoms, the gap becomes smaller and smaller, until the distance between Achilles and the tortoise is actually zero.
  7. Stevo112's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,535
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    I don't get the "paradox" :confused:


    Just model both of them as particles with constant acceleration (zero), a different starting distance, and different speeds :rolleyes: In such an instance there is a critical distance value where the position of both particles are equal.
  8. james22's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,989
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    Because although the distance reduces to 0, so does the time so in a finite length of time, a finite distance will have been travelled.
  9. birdsong1's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Location: Chicago
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    The conclusion that he will "never" catch the tortoise uses an implicit assumption, that infinitely many events cannot happen in a finite amount of time. This is wrong.

    The "catching up series" is just one example of an infinite set of events that can happen in finite time. A more trivial example is: {t = 0.9, t = 0.99, t = 0.999, t = 0.9999, ...}

    (Assuming no quanta, of course, as with quanta, there really are only a finite number of steps.)
  10. SpiggyTopes's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: , Location, Location
    • Posts: 1,402
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    If that happened, it would only be up to a certain distance and they could never reach the end of the track.
  11. smd4std's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 467
    • Warning points: 12
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    they don't keep a constant velocity.
  12. tallen90's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 434
    Re: How would you explain this paradox?
    Basically you're saying that the distance between Achilles and the tortoise gets "exponentially smaller", which is fine in Mathematics but obviously doesn't occur in the real world (which the video pretty much states; there's no paradox here).
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.