Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  This forum is for the discussion of postgraduate study and courses.
Reply
Useful Resources:
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
All-new Posting Guide! READ!   calcium878
 
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 12:21 #1 
illusion_of_casablanca illusion_of_casablanca is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
illusion_of_casablanca will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Berkley
Posts: 17
Default MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
If you're attempting to get onto an MA course for English or History at somewhere like, say, York, Oxford, Cambridge, UCL or Sussex, how much does the 'prestige factor' of your undergraduate course university matter? & how likely is it that you will get postgraduate funding with a 2:1?

Say you went to a lower tier university such as UEA or Cardiff, what are your chances of getting onto an MA with a higher tier university if you get a 1st or a 2:1?

Thanks a lot :-)
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 12:28 #2 
DJDJ DJDJ is offline
Adored and Respected Member
DJDJ will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2006
Location: London
Posts: 555
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
how you can say UEA and Cardiff are in the same league is beyond me.
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 12:30 #3 
illusion_of_casablanca illusion_of_casablanca is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
illusion_of_casablanca will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Berkley
Posts: 17
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Originally Posted by DJDJ
how you can say UEA and Cardiff are in the same league is beyond me.
Which would you say was higher?
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 13:59 #4 
poltroon's Avatar
poltroon poltroon is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
poltroon has a spectacular aura aboutpoltroon has a spectacular aura aboutpoltroon has a spectacular aura about
Seychelles
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Here.
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
I'd guess UEA. Anyway, have a look at the individual university requirements as for grade requirements, but it is well known that it is possible to make a jump from a lower tier university to a higher one in the course of starting postgraduate education. Oh and if you got a First, that would help, loads.
 
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 14:19 #5 
illusion_of_casablanca illusion_of_casablanca is offline
New Member
Thread Starter
illusion_of_casablanca will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Berkley
Posts: 17
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Originally Posted by poltroon
I'd guess UEA. Anyway, have a look at the individual university requirements as for grade requirements, but it is well known that it is possible to make a jump from a lower tier university to a higher one in the course of starting postgraduate education. Oh and if you got a First, that would help, loads.
Ah ok, thanks. Well am hoping to get a First as I absolutely love my subject and have always excelled at it in the past. Just hoping my newly acquired university (I ended up having to use Clearing) won't disadvantage me
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 16:01 #6 
DJDJ DJDJ is offline
Adored and Respected Member
DJDJ will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2006
Location: London
Posts: 555
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
university of east anglia better than cardiff? no way, cardiff is the best uni in wales and one of the best in the uk.
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 20:23 #7 
Alan Smithee Alan Smithee is offline
Banned
Alan Smithee is infamous around these partsAlan Smithee is infamous around these partsAlan Smithee is infamous around these parts
Scotland
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 3,867
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Look at UEA in the ratings.

And to the OP, it depends on your references, your performance compared to other students, and for Oxbridge, your written work.
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 22:09 #8 
Turdburger's Avatar
Turdburger Turdburger is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Turdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond repute
Northumbria
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Oxford
Posts: 4,029
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to Turdburger
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
cardiff -- it may be the best in wales, but it sure isnt the best in the uk. Although UEA and Cardiff are both fairly good.

English at Cardiff is quite good though i admit, though any of:

Durham,
Oxbridge,
UCL,
York (in that order) are way better, Warwick and Nottingham too are better, and there may be more....
 
Old 30-09-2006: 30th September 2006 23:23 #9 
DJDJ DJDJ is offline
Adored and Respected Member
DJDJ will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2006
Location: London
Posts: 555
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
^ no **** sherlock, who said it was the best in the uk? i said it was one of the best.

UEA is crap.
Old 01-10-2006: 1st October 2006 08:42 #10 
Alan Smithee Alan Smithee is offline
Banned
Alan Smithee is infamous around these partsAlan Smithee is infamous around these partsAlan Smithee is infamous around these parts
Scotland
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 3,867
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
UEA is 23rd in the Times Table, Cardiff is 16th.
UEA is 19th in the Sunday Times Table, Cardiff is 22nd.

So obviously, there is barely any difference if you go by that.
Old 01-10-2006: 1st October 2006 09:14 #11 
Roll-The-Dice-And-Win's Avatar
Roll-The-Dice-And-Win Roll-The-Dice-And-Win is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Roll-The-Dice-And-Win has a spectacular aura aboutRoll-The-Dice-And-Win has a spectacular aura about
Netherlands
Join Date: May 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 1,034
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Originally Posted by Heartbreaker
cardiff -- it may be the best in wales, but it sure isnt the best in the uk. Although UEA and Cardiff are both fairly good.

English at Cardiff is quite good though i admit, though any of:

Durham,
Oxbridge,
UCL,
York (in that order) are way better, Warwick and Nottingham too are better, and there may be more....

Umm....I think you are biased there, if you look at the rankings it ussualy is:

Oxbridge > LSE/Imperial > Warwick/UCL > Durham/York/Nottingham
Old 01-10-2006: 1st October 2006 10:24 #12 
The Boosh's Avatar
The Boosh The Boosh is offline
TSR Demigod
The Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: ^-)
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
any uk uni in the top 30 is fine
Old 03-10-2006: 3rd October 2006 21:24 #13 
Pink Lady's Avatar
Pink Lady Pink Lady is offline
Exalted Member
Pink Lady has a spectacular aura aboutPink Lady has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Somewhere a bit cold
Posts: 266
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Cardiff is seriously not "lower tier." As has been pointed out, it averages around top 20, which is higher than Sussex (though that's good too), and places higher than universities such as Exeter- apparently full of 'Oxbridge rejects,' according to rumour. It's not in the most prestigious league of top 8-Ox/LSE etc as named above, but it is not exactly bad either.

It annoys me when people who go to equivalent universities, such as Newcastle (mid teens to top 20 placing in league table) say it's only 'fairly good', yet their university is no better, and often worse-placed. Is it because it is in Wales that people think it's worse than it is? It annoys me. If it were number 88 in the tables I'd be fine with it, but it's misplaced criticism- Cardiff's in the Russell group, along with all the usual suspects...to me it's like saying Birmingham's a rubbish uni, which obviously isn't the case.

Sorry, rant over.
 
Old 03-10-2006: 3rd October 2006 22:47 #14 
The Boosh's Avatar
The Boosh The Boosh is offline
TSR Demigod
The Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own goodThe Boosh  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: ^-)
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
well said pink lady.

in defence of my uni though, exeter is 18th, cardiff is 22nd in the sunday times (not that it means anything). i dont know about cardiff, but exeter is generally a straight A grade uni. also, the russell group is a group of big universities rather than being an elite list. york, st andrews, durham, exeter, sussex, bath, lancaster, loughborough and plenty others are not in the russell group but in the 1994 group. being in the russell group doesnt mean a university is automatically better than others. which you probably know anway.
Old 03-10-2006: 3rd October 2006 22:50 #15 
arkbar's Avatar
arkbar arkbar is offline
Banned From The End Of The World
arkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their earsarkbar has reputation coming out of their ears
Join Date: Mar 2005
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Exeter, Cardiff and UEA are much of a muchness in academic rankings.
(and before you say anything, Durham's not a whole lot better)
 
Old 04-10-2006: 4th October 2006 01:35 #16 
Phranky Phranky is offline
Junior Member
Phranky will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Loughborough
Posts: 57
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Of course there's a chance, but you have to be bloody good to get into the top Universities. I plan on applying for entry into [the new] MSt Film Aesthetics in 2008 at Oxford (the poor saps couldn't even bring themselves to call it Film Studies, which I guess is too working class for them), and I have an excellent history of success in Media and Film courses which will help me in the future. However, I view a first class degree as the minimum entry requirement into the top 10 Uni's; I'm trying to fit in as much volunteer work and work experience into my remaining 2 years as I can. It'll look better on the application form than just a first class degree.

I still can't get over the fact they actually have a Film related degree at Oxford... I hope the fact that it's a new course will play into my hands, Oxford have such a relative lack of experience in the subject area compared to other lower tier universities (who seem to excel in it).
Old 08-10-2006: 8th October 2006 15:02 #17 
Jerby's Avatar
Jerby Jerby is offline Male
Benevolent Member
Jerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud ofJerby has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Bristol, UK
Posts: 715
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Perhaps that's because they're the only ones that do it? Just an idea.
Old 10-10-2006: 10th October 2006 17:33 #18 
Pink Lady's Avatar
Pink Lady Pink Lady is offline
Exalted Member
Pink Lady has a spectacular aura aboutPink Lady has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Somewhere a bit cold
Posts: 266
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
The Boosh- sorry, I wasn't slagging off Exeter at all, I was trying to say that it was roughly the same as Cardiff but had a better reputation among people. In one league it was higher than Ex., that was where I got that from, but saying that, I am aware that on many other league tables it is higher than Cardiff!
 
Old 10-10-2006: 10th October 2006 18:16 #19 
Turdburger's Avatar
Turdburger Turdburger is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Turdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond reputeTurdburger has a reputation beyond repute
Northumbria
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Oxford
Posts: 4,029
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to Turdburger
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Umm....I think you are biased there, if you look at the rankings it ussualy is:

Oxbridge > LSE/Imperial > Warwick/UCL > Durham/York/Nottingham

Um yes I am biased , but you seem to have forgot that this is english that we are talking about, not LSE nor Imperial do an english course... Durham or Oxbridge is the place to go for english, and that isnt just me saying that.

A bit OT, but Phranky, I really hope you get into Oxford!
 

Last edited by Turdburger : 10-10-2006 at 18:18.

Old 11-10-2006: 11th October 2006 12:58 #20 
ChemistBoy's Avatar
ChemistBoy ChemistBoy is offline Male
TSR Legend
ChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own goodChemistBoy  has too much reputation for their own good
Lancashire
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Versailles, Paris
Posts: 14,400
My Societies
Default Re: MA - chances from lower tier uni
 
Originally Posted by Phranky
I still can't get over the fact they actually have a Film related degree at Oxford... I hope the fact that it's a new course will play into my hands, Oxford have such a relative lack of experience in the subject area compared to other lower tier universities (who seem to excel in it).

I thought this would be a very big disincentive to study at Oxford in this case. I hope you are prepared for the inevitable raft of problems that students encounter when they are embarking on a new course.
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search