The Student Room Group

C1 June 2015 'normal' question

"Point P lies on the curve.
The normal to the curve at P is parallel to the line 2y + x = 0
Find the x coordinate of P."

I get that the gradient of the line is -1/2 but surely the gradient of the normal should be -1/2 as well if it is parallel to this line?

I really don't understand the wording of the question. The mark scheme says that the gradient you should use is 2 (which I would understand why in any other case) but the question says the normal is parallel to that line so the gradient of the normal should be the same i.e -1/2!?
If the gradient was to be 2 then you'd be using the tangent at P but how would you know in the exam to use the tangent if the question hadn't said to?
Reply 1
What question?
'The curve' isn't very specific...
In the question, you're given the f'(x) function. The f'(x) gives you the gradient of the tangent to a point. If you know the gradient of the normal is -1/2, then you know that the tangent gradient is 2. You can then solve 2=f'(x)
Reply 4
Original post by jessyjellytot14
"Point P lies on the curve.
The normal to the curve at P is parallel to the line 2y + x = 0
Find the x coordinate of P."

I get that the gradient of the line is -1/2 but surely the gradient of the normal should be -1/2 as well if it is parallel to this line?

I really don't understand the wording of the question. The mark scheme says that the gradient you should use is 2 (which I would understand why in any other case) but the question says the normal is parallel to that line so the gradient of the normal should be the same i.e -1/2!?
If the gradient was to be 2 then you'd be using the tangent at P but how would you know in the exam to use the tangent if the question hadn't said to?


You really need to include the full question next time, I wouldn't have known what you were asking had I not already answered this very question previously.

The derivative of a function, dydx\frac{dy}{dx} gives you the gradient of the tangent at the point xx on the curve yy by definition.

So, for example: the curve y=x2y=x^2 has gradient function/derivative dydx=2x\frac{dy}{dx} = 2x. That, is the gradient of the tangent at any point xx is 2x2x. The gradient of the tangent to the curve at x=3x=3 is 2(3)=62(3) = 6; this is the gradient of the tangent to the curve.

Secondly:

The normal and tangent at a point on a curve are mutually perpendicular to one another.

Hence their gradients satisfy mNmT=1m_N m_T = -1.

So, wrapping all this up:

If you are given or you found the gradient of the normal to that point, you then want to find the gradient of the tangent at that point using the perpendicularity argument. This then lets you say that dydx=mT=1mN\frac{dy}{dx} = m_T = -\frac{1}{m_N} at the point PP.

It is incorrect to say that dydx=mN\frac{dy}{dx} = m_N at P, as dy/dx does not measure the gradient of the normal, it measures the gradient of the tangent. So if you want to find P, you need to use the gradient of the tangent.
The way I intepret what you have written would lead me to think that the gradient of the normal would be -1/2 aswell.
Reply 6
Original post by Bern Herkins
The way I intepret what you have written would lead me to think that the gradient of the normal would be -1/2 aswell.


That's because the gradient of the normal is -1/2, there are no two interpretations of it.
Original post by Zacken
You really need to include the full question next time, I wouldn't have known what you were asking had I not already answered this very question previously.

The derivative of a function, dydx\frac{dy}{dx} gives you the gradient of the tangent at the point xx on the curve yy by definition.

So, for example: the curve y=x2y=x^2 has gradient function/derivative dydx=2x\frac{dy}{dx} = 2x. That, is the gradient of the tangent at any point xx is 2x2x. The gradient of the tangent to the curve at x=3x=3 is 2(3)=62(3) = 6; this is the gradient of the tangent to the curve.

Secondly:

The normal and tangent at a point on a curve are mutually perpendicular to one another.

Hence their gradients satisfy mNmT=1m_N m_T = -1.

So, wrapping all this up:

If you are given or you found the gradient of the normal to that point, you then want to find the gradient of the tangent at that point using the perpendicularity argument. This then lets you say that dydx=mT=1mN\frac{dy}{dx} = m_T = -\frac{1}{m_N} at the point PP.

It is incorrect to say that dydx=mN\frac{dy}{dx} = m_N at P, as dy/dx does not measure the gradient of the normal, it measures the gradient of the tangent. So if you want to find P, you need to use the gradient of the tangent.


Oh okay so basically to find the x coordinate of a point on a curve you always equate dy/dx to the gradient of the tangent at that point?
Reply 8
Original post by jessyjellytot14
Oh okay so basically to find the x coordinate of a point on a curve you always equate dy/dx to the gradient of the tangent at that point?


Yes.
Original post by jessyjellytot14
Oh okay so basically to find the x coordinate of a point on a curve you always equate dy/dx to the gradient of the tangent at that point?


Sometimes tangents may involve use of the discriminant
Original post by IrrationalRoot
'The curve' isn't very specific...


I didn't include the rest of the question because I know how to solve it, but i didn't know which gradient to use.. and the part of the question I included is all you need to work that out.
Original post by Xenon17
Sometimes tangents may involve use of the discriminant


Equal roots?
Original post by jessyjellytot14
Equal roots?


Yep

Quick Reply

Latest