From what I've learnt about Abrahamic religion, you are not supposed to judge others on their choices. You are also not supposed to actively sanction people who do not follow your religion in any way - only god can.
These points are why I don't understand the common behavior of Abrahamic theologians of actively condemning and prohibiting certain choices of other people. These include the choice of being open about your homosexuality and practicing it; abortion; and even simpler things like pre-marital sex and consumption of alcohol. This is a very short list but were the only things that came to mind.
Actively chastising and prohibiting these acts; and punishing their successful undertaking is an encroachment of free will. Free will is a cornerstone of their religion, along with divine retribution in the afterlife.
Doesn't punishing and/or actively and outwardly condemning such things take away from your god's right of doing so himself on judgment day? If they can't practice their free will, won't their trials and tribulations in the afterlife be unjust? Doesn't encroaching free will imply an intention of impersonating god (the cardinal sin - in Islam at least)?