Ex-Muslims, Why did you leave Islam?

This is quite interesting. So, terrorist groups who have their own interpretation, are they islamically right in doing so? (Prominent scholars condemn them but you said religion is up for interpretation)

I repeat again there are no authentic hadith in favour of mutah. End.

Whats you point with all this apostate killing thing when the required conditions are met, what are you trying to prove?

Hmmm, interesting. Well of course they're being fed ********, first off by all of their 'scholars' who haven't even gone through primary education.
So, it's up to well educated interpretation. Or humane interpretation at least.

Faith, by definition, is belief without evidence. The very fact that you seek evidence would be frowned upon. Are you saying that the Qu' ran is out of date and needs updating or something? If that is what you imply then it is blasphemous as, as I've said, it is written by a perfect being who is thus omniscient, do you see how His nature causes problems for Himself? The fact that He is omniscient means that He would have provided sufficient information when He did first contact humanity through Muhammad (pbuh) on the night of power.


Posted from TSR Mobile

Humane? So, a Muslim could believe that hell doesn't exist because it's inhumane?

No hate btw but respect other peoples beliefs rather than assuming they left based on lack of knowledge. I know you didn't mean to but thats a very arrogant way of looking at things.

True grasp on what Islam is?
I used to love the deen when it about brotherhood, helping out people (Muslims and non Muslims alike). However, the more I learnt about it, the worse it became.

Seriously, forget all the Aisha and other cliches used to discredit Islam. Look at the permissibility of concubines instead, does this come from the perfect creator? I remember watching a 3 hour lecture about that (slavery in Islam) and a lot of things were justified with "it was better than what others at the time would have done". He even had the cheek to say slavery ended partly because of Islam (lololol).

The idea that Muslims are the only ones that go to jannah is also absurd, considering less than a quarter of the world are Muslim. Tbf, some scholars say that if people don't know about the deen or have a limited understanding of the deen they will be judged "fairly"... But it also say whoever dies upon shirk will go to hell. What happens if someone dies upon shirk and doesn't know about Islam? Allah only seems just if you're a Muslim.

Every religious person believes they're 100% right, and Muslims are the same. That's why I don't feel the need to allign myself with a religion (unless I'm given undoubtable proof which I'm yet to come across)

Well, no, I'm saying that as time changes, the meaning of a verse can be revealed or it can apply for a different context.

Fair enough, this is very similar to the idea of dominion in Christianity, initially people interpreted it as we can do whatever and now it's evolved into stewardship, that we must care for God's creation. I have no further complaints, right now.

Yeah I guess.
What if hell... was a metaphor.

No hate btw but respect other peoples beliefs rather than assuming they left based on lack of knowledge. I know you didn't mean to but thats a very arrogant way of looking at things.

You know when you grow up and stop believing in the tooth fairy or Santa.

Same thing, there comes a time where you have to let your imaginary friends go.

I don't think an all powerful omnipotent diety who left a piece of literature for the rest of mankind would talk in riddles.

It really is a unique way of looking at it though!

Faith, by definition, is belief without evidence. The very fact that you seek evidence would be frowned upon. Are you saying that the Qu' ran is out of date and needs updating or something? If that is what you imply then it is blasphemous as, as I've said, it is written by a perfect being who is thus omniscient, do you see how His nature causes problems for Himself? The fact that He is omniscient means that He would have provided sufficient information when He did first contact humanity through Muhammad (pbuh) on the night of power.


Posted from TSR Mobile

But some of the quran is quite strongly metaphorical.
So I reckon, maybe hell would be a metaphor.
AN EXTENDED METAPHOR MAN, wish me luck on my english exam D:

But some of the quran is quite strongly metaphorical.
So I reckon, maybe hell would be a metaphor.
AN EXTENDED METAPHOR MAN, wish me luck on my english exam D:

Yeah I guess.
What if hell... was a metaphor.

Believing in something without evidence seems pretty idiotic to me.

I dont know if youre a muslim or not, but dont say ifs and buts when its stated clearly hell is a phyiscal thing in which people will be punished, it isnt a metaphor and there is great detail about this, however before anyone starts to say how evil and how its full of hate, jannah or paradise is mentioned far more often in the quran than hellfire.

Dont know why youre talking about heaven and hell asif its predisposed and something thats never going to change, yes fate is written so many times but a dua is very powerful and if someone wanted to live longer allah could change the time for his death, we all have free will.