Scroll to see replies
Spoiler
•
Edward was, and Mary wasn't
•
Mary was, and Edward wasn't
1.
Edward effectively implements the Act of Treason and the repeal of the 6 Articles in 1547 which is further than his father Henry VIII ever dared to go, and was not directly challenged. Haigh: Edward "broke decisively with the past.
2.
Edward surrounded himself with Puritan advisers and was determinedly Puritan - nobody could prevent him with continuing with the Edwardian Reformation in spite of the fact he was 15. Made Coverdale (translator of the Bible into English) his chaplain and Cranmer his archbishop. Duffy describes the 1547 Injunctions as "a charter for revolution".
3.
Mary turned public opinion against her with her treatment of heretics. 284 burnt at the stake, with Cranmer's burning after recanting considered particularly barbaric in 1566. Elton: "Her Catholic beliefs were both unpopular and undisguised."
1.
Mary's ascension to the throne after Northumberland's devise "the only successful Tudor rebellion" (Guy). She was unchallenged on entry into London and even those such as the Earl of Oxford who declared for Mary after his household servants demanded so were soon convinced by the Marian regime's efficient continuation of her coronation and legitimisation of her rule by Parliament in 1553 and her rather simplistic undoing of everything Edward had done through the Act of Repeal. Most of court remained Catholic in sentiment. Haigh: "continuing consolidation of Catholic strength" even towards the end of her reign.
2.
Edward faced two rebellions which were largely motivated by religion whereas Mary faced one which was largely motivated by foreign policy. This demonstrates how unpopular Edward's Reformation was. Only 32% of people leave money to the Church in 1547 in comparison to Henrician 70% in 1540.
3.
Local implementation of Edward's reformation was more difficult than the Marian counterpart. Marian reversion was "natural" (Haigh) whereas Edward's took more effort to implement through the Church wardens and even after this there were still high levels of recusancy as people did not enjoy the plain services. "The great majority of English peoples did not want the Reformation of Edward" - Hutton
•
Edward was, and Mary wasn't
•
Mary was, and Edward wasn't
1.
Edward effectively implements the Act of Treason and the repeal of the 6 Articles in 1547 which is further than his father Henry VIII ever dared to go, and was not directly challenged. Haigh: Edward "broke decisively with the past.
2.
Edward surrounded himself with Puritan advisers and was determinedly Puritan - nobody could prevent him with continuing with the Edwardian Reformation in spite of the fact he was 15. Made Coverdale (translator of the Bible into English) his chaplain and Cranmer his archbishop. Duffy describes the 1547 Injunctions as "a charter for revolution".
3.
Mary turned public opinion against her with her treatment of heretics. 284 burnt at the stake, with Cranmer's burning after recanting considered particularly barbaric in 1566. Elton: "Her Catholic beliefs were both unpopular and undisguised."
1.
Mary's ascension to the throne after Northumberland's devise "the only successful Tudor rebellion" (Guy). She was unchallenged on entry into London and even those such as the Earl of Oxford who declared for Mary after his household servants demanded so were soon convinced by the Marian regime's efficient continuation of her coronation and legitimisation of her rule by Parliament in 1553 and her rather simplistic undoing of everything Edward had done through the Act of Repeal. Most of court remained Catholic in sentiment. Haigh: "continuing consolidation of Catholic strength" even towards the end of her reign.
2.
Edward faced two rebellions which were largely motivated by religion whereas Mary faced one which was largely motivated by foreign policy. This demonstrates how unpopular Edward's Reformation was. Only 32% of people leave money to the Church in 1547 in comparison to Henrician 70% in 1540.
3.
Local implementation of Edward's reformation was more difficult than the Marian counterpart. Marian reversion was "natural" (Haigh) whereas Edward's took more effort to implement through the Church wardens and even after this there were still high levels of recusancy as people did not enjoy the plain services. "The great majority of English peoples did not want the Reformation of Edward" - Hutton
•
Edward was, and Mary wasn't
•
Mary was, and Edward wasn't
1.
Edward effectively implements the Act of Treason and the repeal of the 6 Articles in 1547 which is further than his father Henry VIII ever dared to go, and was not directly challenged. Haigh: Edward "broke decisively with the past.
2.
Edward surrounded himself with Puritan advisers and was determinedly Puritan - nobody could prevent him with continuing with the Edwardian Reformation in spite of the fact he was 15. Made Coverdale (translator of the Bible into English) his chaplain and Cranmer his archbishop. Duffy describes the 1547 Injunctions as "a charter for revolution".
3.
Mary turned public opinion against her with her treatment of heretics. 284 burnt at the stake, with Cranmer's burning after recanting considered particularly barbaric in 1566. Elton: "Her Catholic beliefs were both unpopular and undisguised."
1.
Mary's ascension to the throne after Northumberland's devise "the only successful Tudor rebellion" (Guy). She was unchallenged on entry into London and even those such as the Earl of Oxford who declared for Mary after his household servants demanded so were soon convinced by the Marian regime's efficient continuation of her coronation and legitimisation of her rule by Parliament in 1553 and her rather simplistic undoing of everything Edward had done through the Act of Repeal. Most of court remained Catholic in sentiment. Haigh: "continuing consolidation of Catholic strength" even towards the end of her reign.
2.
Edward faced two rebellions which were largely motivated by religion whereas Mary faced one which was largely motivated by foreign policy. This demonstrates how unpopular Edward's Reformation was. Only 32% of people leave money to the Church in 1547 in comparison to Henrician 70% in 1540.
3.
Local implementation of Edward's reformation was more difficult than the Marian counterpart. Marian reversion was "natural" (Haigh) whereas Edward's took more effort to implement through the Church wardens and even after this there were still high levels of recusancy as people did not enjoy the plain services. "The great majority of English peoples did not want the Reformation of Edward" - Hutton
Last reply 1 day ago
Edexcel A Level History Paper 2 (9HI0 2A-2H) - 7th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 day ago
AQA A Level History Paper 1 (7042/1A-1L) - 23rd May 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 day ago
AQA A Level History Paper 2 (7042/2A-2T) - 7th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 days ago
Edexcel GCSE HISTORY PAPER 1 (1HI0 10-13) - 15th MAY [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 days ago
Edexcel A Level History Paper 1 (9HI0 1A-1H) - 23rd May 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 week ago
OCR A-Level HISTORY PAPER 3 (Y301-Y321) - 23rd MAY [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 weeks ago
History Edexcel A level Britain Transformed and USA Conformity and ChallengeLast reply 3 months ago
AQA A-level History USA: Making of a Superpower (7042/1K) - 24 May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 months ago
AQA A Level History - Making of Modern Britain(2S) Exam Chat - 9th June 2023Last reply 1 day ago
Edexcel A Level History Paper 2 (9HI0 2A-2H) - 7th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 day ago
AQA A Level History Paper 1 (7042/1A-1L) - 23rd May 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 day ago
AQA A Level History Paper 2 (7042/2A-2T) - 7th June 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 days ago
Edexcel GCSE HISTORY PAPER 1 (1HI0 10-13) - 15th MAY [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 days ago
Edexcel A Level History Paper 1 (9HI0 1A-1H) - 23rd May 2024 [Exam Chat]Last reply 1 week ago
OCR A-Level HISTORY PAPER 3 (Y301-Y321) - 23rd MAY [Exam Chat]Last reply 2 weeks ago
History Edexcel A level Britain Transformed and USA Conformity and ChallengeLast reply 3 months ago
AQA A-level History USA: Making of a Superpower (7042/1K) - 24 May 2023 [Exam Chat]Last reply 3 months ago
AQA A Level History - Making of Modern Britain(2S) Exam Chat - 9th June 2023