The Student Room Group
Uni students - Complete our survey >>
Uni students - Complete our survey >>
Uni students - Complete our survey >>

Is size 8/10 chubby for someone who is 5"3?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Jebedee
Ah you're one of those "only real women have rolls" types. In that case I'd rather be scorned than adorned by your type.


For the millionth time, even if you are short, if you are size 8 you are not anywhere close to overweight and you are not going to have "rolls" of fat! My BMI is actually pretty close to underweight! And I'll say this one more time for the benefit of both you and Madeline since you both seem incapable of understanding it: I do not have rolls of fat, I do not have a muffin top, I do have a thigh gap, I do not have cellulite or stretch marks and I am not overweight but even if any of those things did apply to me or to anyone else there is no excuse for this kind of behaviour from you!
Original post by Jebedee
Thanks, if I am in the near future undecided on the intent of my words. I'll get in touch with you to decide for me again.

So attractive women are only in porn now? I wonder where they get their inspiration from...


Sorry but you do not need to have an enormous thigh gap and abs in order to be remotely attractive! This is really getting ridiculous now!
Original post by Anonymous
Are they? I have to admit, I don't have a clue how men's sizes work!


Relative to other girls how big are you?

I'm a large, about 5 foot 10 and stocky
Original post by Anonymous
Sorry but you do not need to have an enormous thigh gap and abs in order to be remotely attractive! This is really getting ridiculous now!


I don't remember saying that. Glad you're here to refresh my memory along with everyone else who is telling me what I am saying and/or what I mean by that.
Original post by Anonymous
Thank you! :smile:


I'm the same height as you, albeit male, but 12.5 stone and about 16% body fat, so pretty fat as far as people that work-out are concerned. Yet people still say I look really fit in clothing.

Granted you may not workout (dunno if you do or not and by that I mean lift weights, because if you are 10stone but mostly muscle you will look pretty small) and you're a girl (which naturally means more of your weight is fat than muscle relative to males), but at 8stone there is just no way you could be looked at and thought as of as unattractively fat. No way.

If you want to start eating more though and not look bad for it then lift weights at the same time. It's such a life hack. Especially when your young since it makes your metabolism stupid high.
reported for negativity
Original post by Anonymous
Get bigger? Really? So you think that I sound too small?


yess.

Meat on the bone is hot.
I'm a guy and tbh if doesn't matter what size as long as they look decent and care about appearance. Girls need to stop worrying about being chubby, none of you guys are
OP, has your height also increased since you left school? The main reason for your clothing size increasing might literally just be that you've grown. I've never even heard of an adult woman having a 22 inch waist. <<

Spoiler

Original post by Andy98
Relative to other girls how big are you?

I'm a large, about 5 foot 10 and stocky


I'm small but not extra small/extremely skinny. I'm small and petite but a bit curvy (not in the sense that basically means overweight though). I have an hourglass figure, I'm 5"3.5 and my measurements are: Bust: 36, Waist: 26, Hips: 35.
Original post by Jebedee
I don't remember saying that. Glad you're here to refresh my memory along with everyone else who is telling me what I am saying and/or what I mean by that.


It was implied in what you said. Lahmejacks said "if you're any kind of bloke who's not just seen porn and actually interacted with a woman, you'll know that we don't all have abs, thigh gaps" and you said "So attractive women are only in porn now?" implying that you have to have abs and thigh gaps in order to be attractive and that woman in real life who don't have abs and thigh gaps are unattractive.
Original post by TorpidPhil
I'm the same height as you, albeit male, but 12.5 stone and about 16% body fat, so pretty fat as far as people that work-out are concerned. Yet people still say I look really fit in clothing.

Granted you may not workout (dunno if you do or not and by that I mean lift weights, because if you are 10stone but mostly muscle you will look pretty small) and you're a girl (which naturally means more of your weight is fat than muscle relative to males), but at 8stone there is just no way you could be looked at and thought as of as unattractively fat. No way.

If you want to start eating more though and not look bad for it then lift weights at the same time. It's such a life hack. Especially when your young since it makes your metabolism stupid high.


No, I don't lift weights. I do usually do cardio though but maybe I should try weights in the future. Thank you, that's been helpful! :smile:
Original post by Proxenus
reported for negativity


Who did you report for negativity?
Woah not chubby at all its all good be happy with your body doesn't sound like theres anything wrong with it everyones different some people are slimmer and some people are slightly bigger as long as you're happy and healthy theres no problem:smile:
Original post by BlindingLight
yess.

Meat on the bone is hot.


Really? I always thought that guys liked girls to be really skinny.
Original post by Anonymous
Really? I always thought that guys liked girls to be really skinny.


Guys, just like girls have different preferences individually. You'll never be able to please everyone, so it's better to focus on just being happy with yourself.
Original post by slamtheworld
I'm a guy and tbh if doesn't matter what size as long as they look decent and care about appearance. Girls need to stop worrying about being chubby, none of you guys are


Well, I do take care with my appearance so hopefully that would be fine. Yes, you're probably right haha. :smile:
Original post by Maestosa
OP, has your height also increased since you left school? The main reason for your clothing size increasing might literally just be that you've grown. I've never even heard of an adult woman having a 22 inch waist. <<

Spoiler



A bit, yes. When I left school I was about 5"1.5 and now I'm 5"3.5. Can that affect that like that? Well, I did when I was 18; now I have a 26 inch waist (not 27 like I said in my original post, I measured it wrong originally). Hahaha well I haven't done that! :tongue:
Original post by Maestosa
OP, has your height also increased since you left school? The main reason for your clothing size increasing might literally just be that you've grown. I've never even heard of an adult woman having a 22 inch waist. <<

Spoiler



I was very underweight when I had the 22 inch waist though.
Original post by 1999_student
Woah not chubby at all its all good be happy with your body doesn't sound like theres anything wrong with it everyones different some people are slimmer and some people are slightly bigger as long as you're happy and healthy theres no problem:smile:


Thank you! :smile:

Quick Reply

Related discussions

Latest

Trending

Trending

Articles for you