The Student Room Group

Strongest argument yet from a remain voter

[video="youtube;aqFUEkOCOf4"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqFUEkOCOf4[/video]

Who cares about democracy? Who cares about sovereignty? Who cares about anything right? This plonker couldn't even name an MEP and openly admits to being uneducated on the subject, which is no surprise given most people I know who've looked into the EU in depth and researched it become strong leave voters, and she also gives her reason for staying in the EU as free movement, something that is entirely possible without being in the EU as you can still be a part of EFTA with bilateral trade agreements.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
[video="youtube;_RDOq70MYJY"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_RDOq70MYJY[/video]

They just haven't got a clue :rofl:
Reply 2
[video="youtube;LdpPHmRbLaw"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdpPHmRbLaw[/video]
Look at the confrontational and aggressive fascist.

Make the video black and white, give him a bit of a tidier hair cut and change the flag and you basically have a Nazi propaganda video.
Reply 3
[video="youtube;uQxcjrJ6FR8"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQxcjrJ6FR8[/video]

Compelling hypothesis. :rofl:
Lmao at this German trying to shame Brits for having a choice in how their own damn country is run

[video="youtube;LdpPHmRbLaw"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdpPHmRbLaw[/video]
Reply 5
[video="youtube;4L9GYbQTPm8"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4L9GYbQTPm8[/video]

The brainwashing is strong with this one. The level of stupidity here is incredible. How do these people manage to dress themselves?
Reply 6
[video="youtube;jJWCng3TuWU"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJWCng3TuWU[/video]

:rofl:
Reply 7
Well we're leaving so this is all redundant.
All terribly depressing stuff OP, particularly the first clip.

So how many of these mouth-breathers do we think added to the 'voters with degrees' statistic? I bet it was a couple.
Reply 9
Original post by vela1
Well we're leaving so this is all redundant.


No, its hilarious. Look at the brainwashed fascist sheep shouting and supporting something they have no clue about.
Reply 10
Original post by TimmonaPortella
All terribly depressing stuff OP, particularly the first clip.

So how many of these mouth-breathers do we think added to the 'voters with degrees' statistic? I bet it was a couple.


The more people study and learn about the EU the more likely they are to want to leave it. There's a reason a large proportion of the EU's activities are not transparent. Of course, the remain voters see leaving such an institution as being a backward step but the reality is we've left a fish tank for the big old sea.
This doesn't prove anything. I can post just as many (if not more) "interviews" of leave- voters that will make you laugh, face palm or frown.

it's bad enough the leave campaign and co made dumbfounded claims to win votes and now you people are going to pick out certain interviews that are deliberately meant to represent the remain voters' knowledge on the matter?

Now that is depressing!

Original post by TimmonaPortella
All terribly depressing stuff OP, particularly the first clip.

So how many of these mouth-breathers do we think added to the 'voters with degrees' statistic? I bet it was a couple.
there was a time when I used to regard your posts highly....👎🏼
Original post by TaintedLight


there was a time when I used to regard your posts highly....👎🏼


I'm wounded.

Obviously you can find stupid people supporting anything. Interviews like this are not a scientific tool. They do, however, help to remind us that the smart vs ignorant narrative that a lot of people seem to be buying into in relation to this might be a little on the superficial side.
Original post by TimmonaPortella
I'm wounded.

Obviously you can find stupid people supporting anything. Interviews like this are not a scientific tool. They do, however, help to remind us that the smart vs ignorant narrative that a lot of people seem to be buying into in relation to this might be a little on the superficial side.


But Welshie is pushing a counter-narrative which is just as false: that people who actually research the EU tend to vote Leave. I know all about it and I voted Remain - probably because, unlike the preponderance of Leave voters, I also have a healthy scepticism of our own government, democracy etc. For me, as every vote becomes when you actually look into both options properly, the vote to Remain was a least worst vote.
Truly horrifying that people can have different values and priorities.

Even though the EU is democratic and has served our interests better than the last 4 (at least) of our elected governments.
Both sides have got their share of plonkers.

[video="youtube;he9FQ2xTD9o"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=he9FQ2xTD9o[/video]
Original post by scrotgrot
But Welshie is pushing a counter-narrative which is just as false: that people who actually research the EU tend to vote Leave. I know all about it and I voted Remain - probably because, unlike the preponderance of Leave voters, I also have a healthy scepticism of our own government, democracy etc. For me, as every vote becomes when you actually look into both options properly, the vote to Remain was a least worst vote.


Oh, I'm sure there are lots of people with a reasonable understanding of the EU institutions who voted remain. I think one could maintain (and I do) that greater control for our domestic systems is preferable whilst conceding that our own systems are not perfect. In any event, I think it's still worthwhile to point out that at least some of the pro EU sentiment, especially amongst the youth vote, seems to have its basis more in empty virtue-signalling than serious consideration of the EU's institutions, history, and legal framework.
My main reasons/opinions that led me to vote Remain were

Democracy: The EU isn't undemocratic but not as democratic as it could be, but enough at present for a semi-integrated union.

Sovereignty: Yes we have been outvoted 72 times, but this is only 2% and selectively ignores the other 98%. The UK position on issues isn't unified so "we" is a very loose term anyway.

Turkey: Never going to fulfill the joining criteria so a non-issue. Would get vetoed anyway as no sane person wants the EU to border the Islamic State.

Single Market: EU membership not required but since full access requires contributing to the EU budget and accepting the four freedoms it seemed almost pointless to leave, since realistically we're going to stay part of it anyway to safeguard foreign investment into the UK and passporting for the city. However paying for access from outside the EU would still allow us the economic benefits but not be tied to the CFP(while not having much knowledge of it myself I get the impression that it's universally hated by fisherman).

Tories: The Tory right supporting Leave made me instinctively want to vote to remain, they're hardly the champions for the ordinary person. Rupert Murdoch supporting leave because he has more influence in the UK compared to Europe was another related factor to this(I know I'm a bit of a hypocrite as I have Sky but it pisses on the competition).

EU Migrants: Net contributors to the economy so not an issue for me, the strain on public services is due to Tory austerity policies.

Trade: The EU has 50+ free trade deals with non-EU countries in place so the idea that they block trade with the rest of the world is nonsense, however in hindsight if we joined EFTA there's less people to satisfy when making future deals so it may benefit us in the long run.

In short I don't think the EU is perfect by any means but I'm yet to be convinced that we'll be better off overall by leaving.
(edited 7 years ago)
Wow, their arguments are really simplistic.
Original post by welshiee
[video="youtube;aqFUEkOCOf4"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqFUEkOCOf4[/video]

Who cares about democracy? Who cares about sovereignty? Who cares about anything right? This plonker couldn't even name an MEP and openly admits to being uneducated on the subject, which is no surprise given most people I know who've looked into the EU in depth and researched it become strong leave voters, and she also gives her reason for staying in the EU as free movement, something that is entirely possible without being in the EU as you can still be a part of EFTA with bilateral trade agreements.


Sovereignty lies with Queen i.e. parliament. That means parliament can decide to not leave the EU if they wish. If there were a general election and say the lib dems promised to not invoke article 50 and they then formed a government or got enough MPs in power to block it from happening. That would be sovereignty in actions. Even though a majority of people voted to leave the EU.

If you care about democracy you shouldn't really care about sovereignty.
(edited 7 years ago)

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending