The Student Room Group

Were you ever banned from reading certain books/authors as a child?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 40
i am not allowed to read Harry Poter

it's not fair
Reply 41
Original post by Id and Ego seek
The Qur'an :teehee:

No joke. My mum is a strict Roman Catholic and she forbid me reading any other holy books. For RE, we were given a little Qur'an book (I think it was written by Oxford), and she pretty much 'confiscated' it. She's so silly, considering I read the Verdas at school.

Somehow I doubt that...:teehee:

On topic: I don't remember being told not to read certain books, but then again I was never all that keen on reading the kind of books that might have put my parents' tolerance to a test. Sometime during the late 90s, though, I was doing work experience at a library and at the time all the children's librarians were getting into a fluster about a new book called Junk (Melvyn Burgess, I think), about two teenagers who become drug addicts. Since I was much closer to the intended age group than they were, they asked me to read it and give them my honest opinion, so they'd be able to decide whether to put it on the open shelves or not. So I read it and subsequently told them that I didn't think their anxiety about that book was justified, because it was neither so shockingly graphic as to give children nighmares nor in any way encouraging them to take heroin, so I couldn't see any obvious danger in putting it on the open shelves. The head librarian gave me a look that said 'Well, what do YOU know, you corrupted child' and decided not to put it on the shelves anyway (although I think over-16s were allowed to borrow it provided they specifically asked for it and braved the librarian's withering looks).:sigh:
Original post by hobnob
Somehow I doubt that...:teehee:

It was something like this
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Quran-Oxford-Worlds-Classics/dp/0199535957/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1329851869&sr=8-1

:teehee:

Woops, I didn't mean written (facepalm on my part), I meant published by/in association with Oxford.
I read the Diary of Anne Frank when I was nine, I was depressed for months :cry2: I'm glad my parents let me read everything I wanted though, at least I could always talk to them about what I'd read if it upset me. I don't see the point in shielding children from what goes on in the world, one day they'll find out anyway from their friends or from reading things in secret or just seeing it on tv, and then they might feel like they can't talk to their parents about it.
When I was 12 I wanted to read Lucian of Samosata's "The Symposium" and I was forbidden. I understood why 2 years later.
You read about the horrors of Auschwitz at the age of 7 :redface:, I didn't even know what a concentration camp was at that age.
I read a lot of Jacqueline Wilson when I was younger but my mum wasn't keen on me reading her 'Girls In Love' mini series, so naturally I sought it out, read it and it was crap :colonhash: Judy Blume writes in a similar vein and is far, far superior.
Whatever I wanted. Anything inappropriate just went straight over my head.
Original post by syrettd
I remember when I was six and really into reading and took my mum's book because it was glossy and new (mostly she has old, dusty books). It had lots of murder and sex scenes in it. I still remember one where she was pregnant and he bit her nipple to get some of the milk during sex. I don't remember my mum ever saying I shouldn't read it; in fact, I kept I think she even gave it to me for a little while.


Six and sex??? :frown: Which book was that, by the way? :colondollar:
It was the opposite with me. My parents actually bought me books on sex/crime/etc. Didn't do me any harm (I think :ninja:).

Still, not quite as bad as my friend's parents who bought her an 18-rated game which was pretty much porn on a Playstation (or whatever it was back then).... when she was 10. :facepalm2:
Original post by KJane
My parent's are baffled by the fact I read, the rest of my family joke I'm not their biological child because of my interest in books and going to Uni for English Lit. My Dad only goes as far as reading the newspaper, never cover to cover though, and my mum confided in me that she hasn't read an entire novel in over 15 years.

They wouldn't know what authors wrote what or what was right for me to be reading. Beyond the colour coded children's books in primary school indicating what level I should have been at, my parents took little interest in what material I read from then on. :colone:


You naughty girl... :colone:
Original post by Lyde
When I was about nine, so years ago, a girl in our class got hold of the Judy Blume book Forever and lent it out for sweets, with the select pages turned over. It would be so tame now, but at nine years old reading about losing your virginity on a rug and then pursuing a ski instructor was the most taboo thing ever. One of the girls who borrowed it got busted by her mum, who apparently went orbital.

I moved schools but I reckon that girl must be an entrepeneur or something now, young adult porn in exchange for sweets, she knew how to make something of nothing.


What book was that one? lol At 9 years old I did not know what virginity meant lmao.
Reply 52
Original post by SoulfulBoy
Six and sex??? :frown: Which book was that, by the way? :colondollar:


Haha, yeah I probably had no clue what was going on! I can't remember, but it had something to do with Eldorado, the lost gold city. It confused the hell out of me, because this cartoon called Eldorado (I think) came out shortly after I read it and I was thinking how the trailer was nothing like the book!
Reply 53
Original post by Rascacielos
It was the opposite with me. My parents actually bought me books on sex/crime/etc. Didn't do me any harm (I think :ninja:).

Still, not quite as bad as my friend's parents who bought her an 18-rated game which was pretty much porn on a Playstation (or whatever it was back then).... when she was 10. :facepalm2:


When my brother got a Playstation aged 8 or so, my uncle gave him South Park the game. It is HEAVILY themed on sex, like embarassingly so (how many rounds you played was in different sex styles). We got few references, most of them came to me as I was older, just some "OHHHH!" moments. I'm so shocked my parents never thought to take the game away from us!
'Lady Chatterley's Lover' :facepalm2:
Reply 55
Original post by SilverArch
I was sorting through all my books, especially the ones I read when I was 7-9, and I noticed that actually many of the books I read at that age, were really written for adults or teenagers. Eg several holocaust memoirs with a lot of nasty details and so on. I must have been about 11 when I took 'Belle du Jour' off mum's shelf and read that (it was glossy new and looked interesting! Can't say my 11 year old self was that impressed by it though). From about that time, I was allowed to use Mum's library card to get books when she wasn't around

So my reading material was never censored. I was allowed to read anything I wanted, whenever I wanted. But my friends weren't. And I notice quite a few parents ban certain books, or authors (eg. someone banned their 8 yo from reading Jacqueline Wilson. By that age I had read much grittier things in adults books) altogether. Mostly they say 'kids need a childhood' as the reason for banning them

I don't think reading lots of adult books affected me that much. Certainly by the time I was 12 nothing I read would have shocked me any more, but I wasn't traumatised too much by reading those books (well, a few nightmares after reading about Auschwitz as a 7 yo, but nothing too bad). I also read classics and Harry Potter and all that, but if I saw an interesting adult book, I read it as well.

My questions to you guys - How much reading freedom did you have, and what was the most adult book you read as a child? Would you ban your kids from certain books? And is banning children from reading certain books/authors a good thing or a bad thing?


When I was in 2nd year a high school we got a new librarian who when though the books and removed all the books that had any mention of sex, drugs, radical ideas etc. She even had her own little "gestapo" who would check the books for her. I mentioned a book to one I thought was my friend and she had it removed from the school library stock.

Very Nazi-ish!
Original post by MASeeker
When I was in 2nd year a high school we got a new librarian who when though the books and removed all the books that had any mention of sex, drugs, radical ideas etc. She even had her own little "gestapo" who would check the books for her. I mentioned a book to one I thought was my friend and she had it removed from the school library stock.

Very Nazi-ish!


We had a "sixth form only" section, but this sounds pretty extreme!
Reply 57
no but i used to steal books from the library and burn them
Reply 58
Original post by Rascacielos
We had a "sixth form only" section, but this sounds pretty extreme!


It was my school was swept with a kind of religous hysteria while I was there for a while i.e. boys who where virgins becoming born again virgins, that sort of thing.

I'm not opposed to anyone having a faith but just don't mess with me supply of books!
Reply 59
no never. I read a load of books when I was little that I re read recently and realised that I never even noticed most of the sexual stuff in it when I was a child and the violence seemed much worse to me then than when I first read it. They were my mums and she had read them previously so she knew they were basically just sex and violence

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending