Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Playing with numbers and cooking the books.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Job Interview Questions: NEW RULE - PLEASE READ!   FadedJade
 
Old 4 Weeks Ago: 22nd October 2009 20:42 #1 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Hi guys,

Anyone else sitting their ACA advanced stage this November? How have you been finding college and what do you make of our case study?

Ted
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 4 Weeks Ago: 24th October 2009 22:37 #2 
Guru's Avatar
Guru Guru is offline
Full Member
Guru will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 103
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Case is a pretty interesting industry, alot to talk about with the strategy question! Focusing more on the TI though!
Old 4 Weeks Ago: 25th October 2009 01:59 #3 
Illusionary's Avatar
Illusionary Illusionary is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Illusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputation
United Kingdom
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Manchester
Posts: 3,675
My Societies
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Good luck guys - when's your exam? I've got my ICAS case study exam on Tuesday 3...
Old 4 Weeks Ago: 25th October 2009 08:47 #4 
Gohalath Gohalath is offline
Junior Member
Gohalath is just really niceGohalath is just really niceGohalath is just really niceGohalath is just really nice
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 66
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Sitting case on the 4th Nov. Looks a bit trickier than usual - it's about the pawnbroking and jewellery industry. The advance information has provided much less in the way of strategy, supply chain and objectives for the company than usual so it'll be anyone's guess what comes up in the actual exam.
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 26th October 2009 18:53 #5 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Illusionary - BR is Monday, BC is Tuesday and case is Wednesday. ICAS case... I heard that is an 8 hour exam with an hour lunch break in the middle during which you can share ideas?! Don't know how true that is though! Regardless, hope it goes well.

Gohalath - Agreed, case does look trickier than usual. I don't see many clues in the advance material, but we'll see what Kaplan have made of it. I've got case prep on Wed, Thu and Fri this week.
 
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 26th October 2009 18:54 #6 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Guru
Case is a pretty interesting industry, alot to talk about with the strategy question! Focusing more on the TI though!

Agreed - if I were to have to resit any of the papers I'd def go for case. Clearly hoping to pass them all, but really want to get through the technical papers once and for all!
 
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 27th October 2009 17:36 #7 
Illusionary's Avatar
Illusionary Illusionary is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Illusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputation
United Kingdom
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Manchester
Posts: 3,675
My Societies
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Tednol
Illusionary - BR is Monday, BC is Tuesday and case is Wednesday. ICAS case... I heard that is an 8 hour exam with an hour lunch break in the middle during which you can share ideas?! Don't know how true that is though! Regardless, hope it goes well.
5 hours 30 mins with a lunch break, and yes you can share ideas (I'm not sure that I could cope with 8 hours! ).

They tend to change it all around and give extra and/or more detailed requirements with the afternoon part though, so it's debatable how much any discussion can help. It can be dangerous to try to go back and change work from the morning, and risk running out of time!
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 27th October 2009 18:49 #8 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Illusionary
5 hours 30 mins with a lunch break, and yes you can share ideas (I'm not sure that I could cope with 8 hours! ).

They tend to change it all around and give extra and/or more detailed requirements with the afternoon part though, so it's debatable how much any discussion can help. It can be dangerous to try to go back and change work from the morning, and risk running out of time!

5 hours 30 mins?! Crikey, I'll stop complaining about my 4 hour case then! What is your case on?
 
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 27th October 2009 19:11 #9 
Illusionary's Avatar
Illusionary Illusionary is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Illusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputation
United Kingdom
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Manchester
Posts: 3,675
My Societies
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Tednol
5 hours 30 mins?! Crikey, I'll stop complaining about my 4 hour case then! What is your case on?
Unseen!
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 20:11 #10 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Well BR was a POS today.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 20:31 #11 
mikeyT mikeyT is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
mikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to all
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location:
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Tednol
Well BR was a POS today.
So agree with you there. What was with them asking for the same things twice in some of the questions?
Oh well, BC tomorrow....
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 20:36 #12 
theis theis is offline
Respected Member
theis will become famous soon enoughtheis will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Stockport
Posts: 171
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
glad that I'm not the only person who thought it was a shocker of an exam. have yet to speak to anyone who felt it went well/ok/not to bad.

Would have been nice for them to ask some stuff which I'd actually been expecting rather than just rehashing huge quantities of professional stage knowledge. The tax question completely threw me for example.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 20:42 #13 
mikeyT mikeyT is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
mikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to all
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location:
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
They probably wrote it thinking there's some incorporation relief and remittance basis in there but oops that's not enough marks - lets chuck some taxable/exempt benefits in there for the fun of it and let them calculate the liability.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 22:21 #14 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
One of our lot found the exam ok, but at far as accounting geeks go there are few bigger ones out there. With that one exception apart, everyone else I've spoken to found it to be pretty much a car crash of a paper. The tax question in particular - bloody hell. I mean all the days tuition in Kaplan looking at tax at they ended up testing us on professional stage *assumed* knowledge. Cars and CO2 emissions? Are you having a laugh?

Question 4 was dodge as well. A whole question on ethics pretty much save for a small bit of hedge accounting chat. It almost felt like there was a page missing.

Generally, I thought it was more time pressured by a considerable amount than the mocks and practise papers I've sat.

Let's hope for a nice big pension question tomorrow - it hasn't been tested for 3 consecutive TI papers now.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 2nd November 2009 22:36 #15 
theis theis is offline
Respected Member
theis will become famous soon enoughtheis will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Stockport
Posts: 171
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
yeah, although for the last question I only had about 30 minutes left so wouldn't have been able to cope with anything else. Was far more time pressured than any of the mocks which is rather annoying.

Not sure about you as well but the one major tax area we had to self study was international aspects of personal tax.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 20:24 #16 
Tednol's Avatar
Tednol Tednol is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Tednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud ofTednol has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: South East
Posts: 2,476
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
How did you find BC? It was far better received by the guys I was sitting it with today than BR. More like the stuff we'd actually covered in college. A few people didn't like the numbers part of question 1. Again, the exam was quite excessively time pressured, I've not spoken to anyone who attempted every part of every question.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 20:57 #17 
Illusionary's Avatar
Illusionary Illusionary is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Illusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputationIllusionary has a ridiculously high reputation
United Kingdom
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Manchester
Posts: 3,675
My Societies
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Just thought that I'd drop in to say good luck to all you guys with your case study tomorrow!
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 00:50 #18 
mikeyT mikeyT is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
mikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to allmikeyT is a name known to all
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location:
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
Originally Posted by Tednol
How did you find BC? It was far better received by the guys I was sitting it with today than BR. More like the stuff we'd actually covered in college. A few people didn't like the numbers part of question 1. Again, the exam was quite excessively time pressured, I've not spoken to anyone who attempted every part of every question.
I just about managed to get something down for every requirement. My strategy was to pick up the easy marks where possible when coming to the end of my allocated time.
The paper was a structured better than yesterday but the 40 mark question is always a killer when you open the paper.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 18:24 #19 
Guru's Avatar
Guru Guru is offline
Full Member
Guru will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 103
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
I thought BR was fine actually; BC was the bítch!

Not sure if I'm missing something with BR. The professional stage stuff with the taxation was stuff that could easily be found in Hardman's, and the income tax bands were in our notes - the rest was to be expected (incorp relief and gift relief; bit of dtr, IHT bit was almost a carbon copy of a mock question) - the rest was just auditing and financial reporting?

BC I found very very tricky though... especially the tax in that question! Panicked, and ended up producing a pretty bad loss relief computation (just took post entry losses from their associate, and ignored that other 35% company as I don't think it formed part of that loss group)... and my chat about the sale/purchase of shares was just blagging standard question bank answers without any computations! Don't think they'll be too impressed with that!

Case today I found pretty good going, overall I said - no to Oldham, no to upmarketness.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 5th November 2009 13:47 #20 
Samtheman1 Samtheman1 is offline
New Member
Samtheman1 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 14
Default Re: ACA Advanced Stage, TI and case
 
I thought the case was not bad with the questions asked, just not too sure I answered them in the best way. There seemed to be a lot to write in the time which was expected.

Think I was a bit too generall on the weaknesses and threats for the last requirement, hopefully they will take that to apply to being upmarket.

Really tough to call, hopefully the fact that I finished the exec summary might mean I scrape a pass.

How many appendicies did people do and what were they?

how did anyone else find it?
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search