Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Maths revision, coursework or discussion you will find help in here.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 29th October 2009 22:01 #1 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Stuck on question 1 of the following:

http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/examples/B9bm.pdf

I've done the first part, but I'm having trouble showing |A|² + |B|² = 1. Also, if |A|² + |B|² = 1 as required, what is the interpretation?

Help would be much appreciated !
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 30th October 2009 06:09 #2 
Coursework.info's Avatar
Coursework.info Coursework.info is offline
TSR Help Bot
Coursework.info has disabled reputation
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Vancouver
Lightbulb Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
It's been a while since you posted and nobody's replied yet...maybe you should check out Coursework.Info, TSR's sister site. It has the largest library of essays in the UK.

They've got over 160,000+ essays, projects, assignments, coursework etc.. all written by GCSE, A Level and Uni students. You get access either by publishing some of your own work, or paying £4.99 for a month's access. Both ways give you unlimited access to all of the essays.

All their documents are submitted to Turnitin anti-plagiarism software, so it can't be misused, and the site’s used by hundreds of thousands of UK teachers and students.

Hopefully you'll find it useful
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 30th October 2009 10:46 #3 
yusufu's Avatar
yusufu yusufu is online now Male
TSR Demigod
yusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 6,730
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
Stuck on question 1 of the following:

http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/examples/B9bm.pdf

I've done the first part, but I'm having trouble showing |A|² + |B|² = 1. Also, if |A|² + |B|² = 1 as required, what is the interpretation?

Help would be much appreciated !
 j = \Psi ^*\nabla\Psi - \Psi \nabla \Psi^*

Work out j at both asypmtotes and use the earlier part of the question.
 
Old 3 Weeks Ago: 30th October 2009 17:13 #4 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by yusufu
 j = \Psi ^*\nabla\Psi - \Psi \nabla \Psi^*

Work out j at both asypmtotes and use the earlier part of the question.

Thanks, got it *Reps*.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 14:50 #5 
MikeyF MikeyF is offline Male
New Member
MikeyF is an unknown quantity at this point
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 23
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
Stuck on question 1 of the following:

http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/examples/B9bm.pdf

I've done the first part, but I'm having trouble showing |A|² + |B|² = 1. Also, if |A|² + |B|² = 1 as required, what is the interpretation?

Help would be much appreciated !

Wait, does your Director of Studies know you're asking for example sheet help like this? This was covered in lectures anyway, it's trivial... some guy at Jesus who got a 3rd had no problems with that...
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 15:07 #6 
DFranklin DFranklin is offline
TSR Legend
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
DFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own good
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: London
Posts: 10,515
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by MikeyF
Wait, does your Director of Studies know you're asking for example sheet help like this?
I really doubt he would care if he did. I certainly wouldn't.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 17:37 #7 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by MikeyF
Wait, does your Director of Studies know you're asking for example sheet help like this? This was covered in lectures anyway, it's trivial... some guy at Jesus who got a 3rd had no problems with that...

Why on earth would he care? The point of an example sheet is to learn. For your information, I self-taught quantum mechanics for fun over the summer, and so I don't attend any of the lectures for it. If you hadn't been shown how to do it in lectures, you may well have had a lot more trouble with it too, not to mention the guy who got a 3rd. At the end of the day though, I've finished all of the questions on QM sheets 1 and 2, with only a little help, which is more than can be said of most people, even people who got firsts at Trinity. I was talking to a guy who got a middle first this morning, and he said to me he's just finished QM sheet 1, but couldn't do two of the questions at all.

I could talk about how a lot of things on the various example sheets (I'm 3½ sheets ahead in total at the moment) were 'trivial' to me, but that would just be asinine, since different people have trouble with different things. How would you like it if the lecturers took the attitude of "Ohhh, trivial, obvious, too easy, etc..." on things you were having trouble with?

Enough said .
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 17:46 #8 
DFranklin DFranklin is offline
TSR Legend
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
DFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own good
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: London
Posts: 10,515
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
How would you like it if the lecturers took the attitude of "Ohhh, trivial, obvious, too easy, etc..." on things you were having trouble with?
You mean the lecturers these days don't say that?

It's shocking to see the way standards have fallen. What ever happened to the good old days when Bela would put unsolved problems onto the example sheets, and the examiners would have to ring him up on holiday asking him how to answer this years' IA probability questions?

[For the uninitiated: Bela Bollobas's reputation for tough question setting was legendary during my time at Cambridge].
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 17:54 #9 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by DFranklin
You mean the lecturers these days don't say that?

It's shocking to see the way standards have fallen. What ever happened to the good old days when Bela would put unsolved problems onto the example sheets, and the examiners would have to ring him up on holiday asking him how to answer this years' IA probability questions?

[For the uninitiated: Bela Bollobas's reputation for tough question setting was legendary during my time at Cambridge].

Hahaha , they make a conscious point to try not to do that, and they tend to apologise in advance for if they do. We had one lecturer in part IA who did it all the time .

We had Tim Gowers for probability, he was a fantastic lecturer, and a student of Bela himself . Not quite as mean based on what you're saying, heheh!
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 17:57 #10 
DFranklin DFranklin is offline
TSR Legend
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
DFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own good
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: London
Posts: 10,515
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
We had Tim Gowers for probability, he was a fantastic lecturer, and a student of Bela himself . Not quite as mean based on what you're saying, heheh!
The stories are legendary - I wouldn't want to swear they are true...
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:02 #11 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by DFranklin
The stories are legendary - I wouldn't want to swear they are true...

How were the examinations structured when you were here ?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:12 #12 
DFranklin DFranklin is offline
TSR Legend
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
DFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own good
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: London
Posts: 10,515
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
How were the examinations structured when you were here ?
For IA: 10 questions per paper with marks for the best 7 answers. Four papers.
For IB: Something like 14 questions per paper, no limit on questions answered per paper. Four papers.
For II: 3 papers with something like 35 questions per paper, no limits. One paper with something like 25 questions, only 3 questions to be attempted, each question having double marks.

Other than that last paper, all questions had equal weight. The introduction of "half-weight" questions seems the biggest change between then and now.

For a *very* approximate rule of thumb, you would need something like 12-14 alphas for a first.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:19 #13 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by DFranklin
For IA: 10 questions per paper with marks for the best 7 answers. Four papers.
For IB: Something like 14 questions per paper, no limit on questions answered per paper. Four papers.
For II: 3 papers with something like 35 questions per paper, no limits. One paper with something like 25 questions, only 3 questions to be attempted, each question having double marks.

Other than that last paper, all questions had equal weight. The introduction of "half-weight" questions seems the biggest change between then and now.

For a *very* approximate rule of thumb, you would need something like 12-14 alphas for a first.

Wow, that does seem pretty different, IB especially. If you had a chance to choose now, would you personally prefer the format you did, or the new format?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:23 #14 
yusufu's Avatar
yusufu yusufu is online now Male
TSR Demigod
yusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 6,730
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
Why on earth would he care? The point of an example sheet is to learn. For your information, I self-taught quantum mechanics for fun over the summer, and so I don't attend any of the lectures for it.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:25 #15 
DFranklin DFranklin is offline
TSR Legend
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
DFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own goodDFranklin  has too much reputation for their own good
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: London
Posts: 10,515
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
Wow, that does seem pretty different, IB especially. If you had a chance to choose now, would you personally prefer the format you did, or the new format?
It's hard to say, not having done the new format. I think it would have given me a bit more breadth (as opposed to concentrating on the topics where I knew I'd get 3-4 questions out) which would have been good, but I think the "half-mark" questions would have been a bit tedious.

On a purely competitive front, since I was probably disproportionately good at "easy" questions, the new system would probably have bumped me a few places up the merit tables for IB and II.

Overall, I think the changes are clearly a good thing for the majority of undergraduates. I think it's more debatable for the top few getting 20+ alphas but they are a very small minority anyhow.

@Yusufu: as it happens, I also self-taught QM. Don't remember much of it now, however.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:26 #16 
Simba Simba is offline
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Simba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond reputeSimba has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,263
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by yusufu

Well, it was kind of a spontaneous thing - on the last day before I came home I was all like "I should do some work over the summer..." so I got a book out from our library on QM and studied some from there . I was debating whether to get a QM book or fluid dynamics, but QM seemed (and still does seem!) more interesting.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:28 #17 
yusufu's Avatar
yusufu yusufu is online now Male
TSR Demigod
yusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 6,730
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by DFranklin
You mean the lecturers these days don't say that?

It's shocking to see the way standards have fallen. What ever happened to the good old days when Bela would put unsolved problems onto the example sheets, and the examiners would have to ring him up on holiday asking him how to answer this years' IA probability questions?

[For the uninitiated: Bela Bollobas's reputation for tough question setting was legendary during my time at Cambridge].
I'm pretty sure my lecturers used trivial a lot.

That examiners ringing him up must be apocryphal though. The questions are set long before the exams actually happen!
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 18:34 #18 
yusufu's Avatar
yusufu yusufu is online now Male
TSR Demigod
yusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than senseyusufu has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 6,730
My Societies
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
Well, it was kind of a spontaneous thing - on the last day before I came home I was all like "I should do some work over the summer..." so I got a book out from our library on QM and studied some from there . I was debating whether to get a QM book or fluid dynamics, but QM seemed (and still does seem!) more interesting.


QM is pretty decent. I found Fluids IB to be a great course. Was very much my applied street.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 22:55 #19 
MikeyF MikeyF is offline Male
New Member
MikeyF is an unknown quantity at this point
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 23
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by Simba
At the end of the day though, I've finished all of the questions on QM sheets 1 and 2, with only a little help
You couldn't do question 1.

Enough said .
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 3rd November 2009 23:00 #20 
MikeyF MikeyF is offline Male
New Member
MikeyF is an unknown quantity at this point
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 23
Default Re: Quantum Mechanics - Asymptotic Behaviour
 
Originally Posted by DFranklin
I really doubt he would care if he did. I certainly wouldn't.
Our DoS told us it's okay to discuss with friends but we aren't allowed to go away and ask for answers. If someone flops the exam, they'll look at supervision reports etc. when deciding whether to keep you, and if someone else is giving you the solutions for questions...
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search