Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  TSR's model parliament.
Reply
Useful Resources:
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 17:54 #41 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03
They all come out soon because the election is very soon.

Ah ok, maybe ill just wait for a little while then

do you know how soon?
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 17:58 #42 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
Yea i think im very one way on some things and very the other on other things.

Im browsing currently. =] tar

Ima try and find thier stances on university education somewhere



Originally Posted by paddy__power
Ah ok, maybe ill just wait for a little while then

do you know how soon?

Have to be in for Midday on the 7th, so I guess by the 8th (November).

You are probably better off sending Dayne (the speaker) a PM about other stuff because this is getting off-topic :P

Anyway good luck with finding the party best suited to you.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:00 #43 
History-Boy's Avatar
History-Boy History-Boy is offline
Pemanently banned by request
History-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud of
International Brigades
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: N/A
Posts: 701
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
Ah ok, maybe ill just wait for a little while then

do you know how soon?

We stop legislative activity yesterday and the election starts on the 7th/8th so you'll be able to view all the Parties/ Independent Candidate's manifestos from the 7th/8th.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:05 #44 
Cardozo's Avatar
Cardozo Cardozo is online now Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Cardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond repute
United Kingdom
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Sofa
Posts: 1,784
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
Yea i think im very one way on some things and very the other on other things.

Im browsing currently. =] tar

Ima try and find thier stances on university education somewhere

You could look for the old election thread where the manifestos were posted in the search function. I'm Labour leader and I was almost exactly in the same place and also have wide and wierd views that do not fit in with Labour.

Feel free to PM me or ask in our sub forum.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:08 #45 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03





Have to be in for Midday on the 7th, so I guess by the 8th (November).

You are probably better off sending Dayne (the speaker) a PM about other stuff because this is getting off-topic :P

Anyway good luck with finding the party best suited to you.

thank =]

We stop legislative activity yesterday and the election starts on the 7th/8th so you'll be able to view all the Parties/ Independent Candidate's manifestos from the 7th/8th.

ah ok ,thanks

You could look for the old election thread where the manifestos were posted in the search function. I'm Labour leader and I was almost exactly in the same place and also have wide and wierd views that do not fit in with Labour.

Feel free to PM me or ask in our sub forum

oh ok will do =]
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:14 #46 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
thank =]



ah ok ,thanks



oh ok will do =]


Remember a couple of parties were not involved in the last election though, including the Centre Party ( ) and the Patriotic Conservative Party
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:16 #47 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03
Remember a couple of parties were not involved in the last election though, including the Centre Party ( ) and the Patriotic Conservative Party

Im assuming your a Centre mamber =D

Yea, but from what I have seen the patriotic conservatives are not quite the direction i want to go xd
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:19 #48 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
Im assuming your a Centre mamber =D

Yea, but from what I have seen the patriotic conservatives are not quite the direction i want to go xd

Yeah, it would be unfair not to mention them though.

And yep I won't shamelessly promote but Centre Party

Still, better not get off topic...
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:22 #49 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03
Yeah, it would be unfair not to mention them though.

And yep I won't shamelessly promote but Centre Party

Still, better not get off topic...


True, and thanks mate =]

So, what you reckon about these leader debates then? ;p
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:25 #50 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
True, and thanks mate =]

So, what you reckon about these leader debates then? ;p



And I think they're a good idea, they will of course expose Kolya (Centre Party leader) as the best leader in the House

It will be good for newcomers or people who want to vote to see exactly where each party stands without all the usual bickering (assuming that the leader is the best representative of a party).

So yep I think they would be good

Edit: Or was that a joke?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:27 #51 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03


And I think they're a good idea, they will of course expose Kolya (Centre Party leader) as the best leader in the House

It will be good for newcomers or people who want to vote to see exactly where each party stands without all the usual bickering (assuming that the leader is the best representative of a party).

So yep I think they would be good

Edit: Or was that a joke?

did he not run as an independant last time around?

Yea they should be good - as the peripheral comments from random users will be removed.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:30 #52 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
did he not run as an independant last time around?

Yea they should be good - as the peripheral comments from random users will be removed.


He did indeed, Centre Party is a new party. I've only been involved a couple of weeks.

And 'peripheral comments' is a good way of putting it (although it does imply that only the leader is important )
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:33 #53 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03
He did indeed, Centre Party is a new party. I've only been involved a couple of weeks.

And 'peripheral comments' is a good way of putting it (although it does imply that only the leader is important )

The implication i meant was that I could ignore the people I had no interest in listening too far easier when there was only one person from each party there as opposed to several all chipping in.

Plus, assumedly the leader should have the most exhastive knowledge of the party?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:33 #54 
Nothos's Avatar
Nothos Nothos is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Nothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their earsNothos has reputation coming out of their ears
England
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: London
Posts: 4,084
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by iwilson03


And I think they're a good idea, they will of course expose Kolya (Centre Party leader) as the best leader in the House

It will be good for newcomers or people who want to vote to see exactly where each party stands without all the usual bickering (assuming that the leader is the best representative of a party).

So yep I think they would be good

Edit: Or was that a joke?
Talk about convert's fervour!
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:34 #55 
Cardozo's Avatar
Cardozo Cardozo is online now Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Cardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond reputeCardozo has a reputation beyond repute
United Kingdom
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Sofa
Posts: 1,784
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
Yea they should be good - as the peripheral comments from random users will be removed.

To be honest as soon as the PCP say something it will end up like their Questions thread.

Dayne should PM all leaders with say 10 questions put forward by the members of the house. The leaders can discuss each with their party and provide responses accordingly which would then be posted as a sticky.

The 10 questions would be about important issues such as education, health care etc.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:36 #56 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by paddy__power
The implication i meant was that I could ignore the people I had no interest in listening too far easier when there was only one person from each party there as opposed to several all chipping in.

Plus, assumedly the leader should have the most exhastive knowledge of the party?

Yeah I know

And as a rule yes, not always though. I suppose its just the fairest way of choosing a capable representative without things getting complicated.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:37 #57 
DayneD89's Avatar
DayneD89 DayneD89 is offline Male
Speaker of the House of Commons
Forum Assistant
Wiki Support Team
DayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputationDayneD89 has a ridiculously high reputation
China
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Danesfield, Marlow
Posts: 10,185
Send a message via MSN to DayneD89
Default Re: Leader debates
 
This has gone off topic Move it to the commons bar. Actually it might be worth opening up that FAQ for newbie discussion and questions.

anyway, I like this idea, especially the Drogue version. I would say that anyone (mp or not) can PM me questions to ask of the parties and I select a few to ask them. After a week I take the answers of the parties (and independents) and post them up in a new thread where they can be discussed on mass. I don't think this would need an amendment, and pasing something into the guidance document should really only be formality, so I'd be happy to start this.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:37 #58 
iwilson03's Avatar
iwilson03 iwilson03 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
iwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud ofiwilson03 has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Dover
Posts: 1,338
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by Cardozo
To be honest as soon as the PCP say something it will end up like their Questions thread.

Dayne should PM all leaders with say 10 questions put forward by the members of the house. The leaders can discuss each with their party and provide responses accordingly which would then be posted as a sticky.

The 10 questions would be about important issues such as education, health care etc.

Yes this would be the best format! I hope it happens now (I don't see why it shouldn't?)
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:38 #59 
History-Boy's Avatar
History-Boy History-Boy is offline
Pemanently banned by request
History-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud ofHistory-Boy has much to be proud of
International Brigades
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: N/A
Posts: 701
My Societies
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by Cardozo
To be honest as soon as the PCP say something it will end up like their Questions thread.

Dayne should PM all leaders with say 10 questions put forward by the members of the house. The leaders can discuss each with their party and provide responses accordingly which would then be posted as a sticky.

The 10 questions would be about important issues such as education, health care etc.

I still don't know how the PCP got past the mods especially since they didn't let LIBERAL AL qaeda form, which would have been such an awesome party.

Last edited by History-Boy : 2 Weeks Ago at 18:43.

Old 2 Weeks Ago: 1st November 2009 18:39 #60 
paddy__power's Avatar
paddy__power paddy__power is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
paddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to beholdpaddy__power is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,821
Default Re: Leader debates
 
Originally Posted by Cardozo
To be honest as soon as the PCP say something it will end up like their Questions thread.

Dayne should PM all leaders with say 10 questions put forward by the members of the house. The leaders can discuss each with their party and provide responses accordingly which would then be posted as a sticky.

The 10 questions would be about important issues such as education, health care etc.

I think both should be done - this wouldbe good as a reference for new people like me!

The problem with the statement idea you propose is that, while someone could easily make thier own comparisons, this would dilute any 'debate' quality - which I think was the whole point.

I think your idea should be done first - then a week later the debate should happen when the leaders have had time to read other party stances?

Im new to HOC so excuse any ignorance.
 
 
Thread Tools