Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Debate issues related to the politics of the UK, such as the actions of any MP, any current or potential law, or any other factor affecting the British political system.
 
 
View Poll Results : Is this a good idea and would you read it?
I think it's a good idea; and I would read some/all of it 10 45.45%
I think it's a bad idea; but I I would read some/all of it 6 27.27%
I think it's a good idea; but I would not read most of it 4 18.18%
I think it's a bad idea; and I would not read most of it 2 9.09%
Voters: 22. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Rules and Guidelines to Posting in Debate & Discussion --- READ BEFORE POSTING   Magnum Opus
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 02:29 #1 
jammythedodger's Avatar
jammythedodger jammythedodger is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Thread Starter
jammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Essex
Posts: 1,093
My Societies
Default Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
I was thinking, many people actually have quite a vague idea of what goes on in Parliament, and a belief that it doesn't matter.

I think for a start, it might be a good idea if all leading newspapers reported accurately on what happened in the Commons & Lords (and other isntitutions if you want). As in whatquestions were asked, what the answers were. Important debates and what was said. Etc etc

Something like a whole page or a two page spread or more.

Effectively a slightly more detailed written down version of The Record (BBC Parliament's TV version).


Do you think this is a good idea? Do you think it would make any difference at all in people's beliefs about whether they're being well represented, if MPs are doing a good job etc etc
And also, would you read any of it?
 

Last edited by jammythedodger : 2 Weeks Ago at 02:32.

Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 02:37 #2 
Sam o0o Sam o0o is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Sam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really nice
United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2007
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
If people want to know that stuff, they'll go and find out. If they don't, they would probably turn the page over if it were in the paper..
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 02:39 #3 
Remarqable M Remarqable M is online now Male
Benevolent Member
Remarqable M will become famous soon enough
Netherlands
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: London
Posts: 715
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Agreed.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 02:50 #4 
Howard's Avatar
Howard Howard is offline
TSR Deity
Howard has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputationHoward has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 27,388
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
I think two pages of parliamentary reporting would be very useful indeed. Something to wipe my arse on after I've read the sports pages.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 03:28 #5 
jammythedodger's Avatar
jammythedodger jammythedodger is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Thread Starter
jammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Essex
Posts: 1,093
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by Sam o0o
If people want to know that stuff, they'll go and find out. If they don't, they would probably turn the page over if it were in the paper..

Not really: to properly understand what goes on atm, one has to trawl through Hansard.
there is very little proper reporting of the what goes in Parliament, and even less of it is very accessible.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 11:27 #6 
johnw1 johnw1 is offline
Exalted Member
PS Helper
johnw1 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 339
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Newspapers should report whatever they choose. Maybe the BBC could be made to do it. It is quite a good idea actually so people can see for themselves as things may go under the radar and not get picked up on by newspapers but obviously with freedom of the press they should have the choice not to...
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 12:07 #7 
jacketpotato jacketpotato is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
jacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputationjacketpotato has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Cambridge
Posts: 5,684
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Government shouldn't be telling private newspapers what to report: its a very slippery slope. The BBC is a great way to ensure that everyone has access to this kind of information.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 12:12 #8 
crazyspacemonkey crazyspacemonkey is offline Male
Adored and Respected Member
crazyspacemonkey has a spectacular aura aboutcrazyspacemonkey has a spectacular aura aboutcrazyspacemonkey has a spectacular aura about
England
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 568
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Doesn't BBC Parliament effectively do this already?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 13:52 #9 
Sam o0o Sam o0o is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Sam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really niceSam o0o is just really nice
United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2007
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by jammythedodger
Not really: to properly understand what goes on atm, one has to trawl through Hansard.
there is very little proper reporting of the what goes in Parliament, and even less of it is very accessible.
Or, switch on the tv and go to BBC Parliament?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 15:55 #10 
graffic graffic is offline Male
Exalted Member
graffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to beholdgraffic is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 360
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
They already do, they have "lobby" reporters/political editors.

What is the point of this thread? Do you mean you think papers should increase their political coverage? If so perhaps change the title
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 16:07 #11 
jammythedodger's Avatar
jammythedodger jammythedodger is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Thread Starter
jammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud ofjammythedodger has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Essex
Posts: 1,093
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by crazyspacemonkey
Doesn't BBC Parliament effectively do this already?

Not really, and hardly anyone actively choses to watch it.
If people come accross it (without actively having to find it) in their papers then people are probably more likely to read it and as it'll be less time consuming than wating hours worth of debates it means that the system will become much more open, IMO.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 16:08 #12 
amiparanoid's Avatar
amiparanoid amiparanoid is offline Male
Benevolent Member
amiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to behold
England
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 739
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Tbf, the newspapers will report what they like. Especially with topics such as immigration, certain newspapers will twist the events one way and some the other.

It's a lovely idea, but it will simply serve to entrench misguided and ignorant opinions rather than encouraging a genuine interest in factual and unbiased information.

Saying that, doesn't the Evening Standard do this?
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 16:21 #13 
EskimoJo's Avatar
EskimoJo EskimoJo is offline Female
TSR Idol
EskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputationEskimoJo has a ridiculously high reputation
Arsenal
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: London/Nottingham
Posts: 9,762
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by Sam o0o
If people want to know that stuff, they'll go and find out. If they don't, they would probably turn the page over if it were in the paper..

Not really. I want to know, but I'm just very lazy.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:20 #14 
The_Octopus The_Octopus is offline Male
Adored and Respected Member
The_Octopus is a name known to allThe_Octopus is a name known to allThe_Octopus is a name known to allThe_Octopus is a name known to allThe_Octopus is a name known to allThe_Octopus is a name known to all
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 548
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
I'd like it if the newspapers did, but I wouldn't like it if they were made to by the government.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:25 #15 
AlexSC AlexSC is offline
Junior Member
AlexSC will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 30
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
yes and they should be made to discuss EU agenda too. Perhaps a subsidy of 5p per paper sold for papers taking part would be a good idea. Of course an inpedendant body would have to make sure the government do not try to influence the press.
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:27 #16 
adamrules247 adamrules247 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
adamrules247 has a spectacular aura aboutadamrules247 has a spectacular aura aboutadamrules247 has a spectacular aura about
United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Sleaford, Lincolnshire
Posts: 1,112
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
No, the whole idea of the freedom of the press is that newspapers can report what they want. Would it sell well, no. You can read the hansard if you're desperate.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:33 #17 
Student2806's Avatar
Student2806 Student2806 is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Student2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond reputeStudent2806 has a reputation beyond repute
United Nations
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 5,780
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
No, I don't really see the point to be honest.
Look at the ways people already have of finding out about events in parliament:
- news websites stuffed full of articles, blogs, videos and opinions on the HoC
- a dedicated TV channel for parliamentary broadcasting
- 24 hour news channels
- politics sections already in newspapers
- programming such as The Daily Politics and This Week

If people aren't already interested in parliament with all these media, they aren't going to become so just because of a 2 page spread in a newspaper.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:37 #18 
amiparanoid's Avatar
amiparanoid amiparanoid is offline Male
Benevolent Member
amiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to beholdamiparanoid is a splendid one to behold
England
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 739
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by adamrules247
No, the whole idea of the freedom of the press is that newspapers can report what they want. Would it sell well, no. You can read the hansard if you're desperate.

Can you buy copies of Hansard outside of Parliament? Excuse my ignorance...
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:43 #19 
adamrules247 adamrules247 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
adamrules247 has a spectacular aura aboutadamrules247 has a spectacular aura aboutadamrules247 has a spectacular aura about
United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Sleaford, Lincolnshire
Posts: 1,112
My Societies
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
Originally Posted by amiparanoid
Can you buy copies of Hansard outside of Parliament? Excuse my ignorance...

I'm not sure, I have viewed records of debates on the net.
 
Old 2 Weeks Ago: 4th November 2009 17:48 #20 
Tefhel's Avatar
Tefhel Tefhel is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Tefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud ofTefhel has much to be proud of
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: England
Posts: 2,188
Default Re: Should newspapers have to report on daily business in Parliament?
 
I think it's a good idea, so that it'll be easier for people who want to find out about that kind of thing. I personally would never read it though.
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search