(Original post by cottonmouth)
the "adult" as you so call me, has been in dubai over the weekend.im assuming everyone wants me to apologise to nuheen?he didnt apologise to me, he stated he was sorry for arguing and ruining the tone of the thread.as i'm not the slightest bit sorry for anything, why apologise?or shall i make an empty apology?im typing on a computer for god's sake.its not like ive had a fight with him.nuheen, if you want me to falsely apologise to you, then so be it.
you know why i was repeaing evidence again and agaiun.because noone was gtting it.each time i had to try to make it more simple.you know why i printed out all the prophecy stuff?because if you look back through the debate, youll see hat people were making comments like "this can happen because the prophecy says..."- so i wanted to make it plain that the prophecy doesnt necessarily mean anything,nuheen or someone else said something along the lines of "but the prophecy says that one has to kill the opther"- if everyone knows this isnt the actual future, but what will happen if the two choose to live by it, then why use it in an argument?
right, dumbledore statemnets.i'll start by saying that dumbledore himself goes on and on about how it is all speculation- he doesnt know these things, he merely surmises, thinks, has opinions on these things.they are not act.but if we do take his word as fact, then who are we to say that harry wouldnt be a significant enough horcrux?he had heard the prophecy about how great and powerful harry was "powers dark lord knows not"- voldy doesnt know at this point that all that meant was love- so he thinks harry must be extremely powerful- powerful enough to kill him.soi that is why he could have made harry a horcrux- a horcrux that would actually be MORE significant to him than the others- as it stops him dying before harry does. i think ensuring harry cant kill him would be a bit more important to him than finding a horcrux with a good history.he already had the hogwarts four(supposedly) and so he wanted to make sure he stayed safe.
i kow we dnt know the horcrux charm or anything about it.if you look back, someone said something about ginny being possesed, and how harry cant have voldys soul because him and ginny reacted differently.i said that the horcrux is a spell that must require a charm or chant or something- dumbledore says it is a curse- curses need something,so an educated guess would be that i am right about that.i was merely showing a difference between harry and ginnys situations.
dark arts.dumbledore is alos amaze harry hasnt been tempted yet.what does that tell you?it tells me that he is amazed that even with voldys influence on him, he is still a good guy.simple as that.he is a good guy.why are you asking this question?state why you believe harry would be temptedd by evil when it is evil that has ruined his life.