The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Reply 60
CityOfMyHeart
I don't think all left-wing people are idealists, as you seem to think, that's all. Just a tip - don't go jumping to conclusions if you're trying to make a point.

yes well this thread is about the extreme left wing anti nationalists..
nofish4u
yes well this thread is about the extreme left wing anti nationalists..


Yet your post was aimed at all left-wing people :yy: Meh.
It depends on what type of left-wing students you are talking about. Socialists and liberals have different reasons for being anti-British or unpatriotic, but there is no question about it, that that is what they are.

One common reason is that they need pride in anything but leftist "heroes" (like the communist terrorist Mandela) to be destroyed, so that they can socially engineer our society, and create the hellish egalitarian multikult society that they want.
Tefhel
Yes. Right wing ones generally aren't. At least I've not seen a single right wing person here say anything like that. Loads of lefties do though. It's generally because they're very, very PC and like to take offense for other people.
Describe an libertarian right winger or an Anarcho Capitalist then. Because if you can't then you merely describe authoritarianism. Because you get left wing patriotic countries as well.
bestie
I admit I'm generalising but in my experience many libertarians are left wing and many left wingers do not have pride in our country.
Thats another sweeping statement!
Reply 64
If there is one thing i know Students don't really understand politics and other cults such as Feminism. They just want to call themselves something.
Don_Scott
It depends on what type of left-wing students you are talking about. Socialists and liberals have different reasons for being anti-British or unpatriotic, but there is no question about it, that that is what they are.

One common reason is that they need pride in anything but leftist "heroes" (like the communist terrorist Mandela) to be destroyed, so that they can socially engineer our society, and create the hellish egalitarian multikult society that they want.
Well I would argue that that it depends on the social outlook. Admiteddly more left wingers fit into a liberal or libertarian spectrum but you also get those from the right that hit that area as well.
Communist Mandela....I chuckle :p:
Reply 66
Stricof
Describe an libertarian right winger or an Anarcho Capitalist then. Because if you can't then you merely describe authoritarianism. Because you get left wing patriotic countries as well.

Ehh. This is getting far too confusing, especially abstracting it to an international level. All I'm saying is that on TSR it is only the left wing, readily-offended types who say it is "illogical" to be proud of things. I've not seen a right wing person say it. Not all left wing people say it either, but a large handful of people do.
Reply 67
Don_Scott
It depends on what type of left-wing students you are talking about. Socialists and liberals have different reasons for being anti-British or unpatriotic, but there is no question about it, that that is what they are.

One common reason is that they need pride in anything but leftist "heroes" (like the communist terrorist Mandela) to be destroyed, so that they can socially engineer our society, and create the hellish egalitarian multikult society that they want.


lmfao... :rofl:
Tefhel
It's generally naive, idealist, hippie types that spout that irritating view. The most irritating one being "You can't be proud of your country because you didn't choose it!" So you can't be proud of your intelligence, looks, abilities or family either then I suppose.

It is always a double standard though - because liking Britain is 'racist' but they consider being proud of your heritage etc important for other countries, and if you say people should integrate, that's also 'racist'.


It's just a bit weird to understand how people can be proud of something that's so far removed from their personal life. I really enjoy living here and I think this a great country, I don't see a reason feel any pride over this country's achievements, nor do I feel shame over it's failings; because I had no personal stake in any of them.

However, it's not that I object to such an ideology, but the modern definition of patriotism seems to refer to loud, boorish attitudes to your country's success; an obsession with national symbols; and a refusal to accept any shortcomings of your countries (when even the most proud parent will accept their children has flaws). Those don't really suggest genuine pride in your country, they're just very annoying behaviours.
The OP is absolutely correct.

The reasons are very complicated; such that left-wing people rarely step outside themselves and examine their basic assumptions.

Although this excellent post examines some of the reasons:

http://www.brusselsjournal.com/node/1126

The problem is that left-wing ideas dominate our society at every level, they are the status quo, and the problem is that ideas have a tendency to lodge themselves into impressionable minds that aren't equipped to properly question them. So we now have a generation of people who truly believe in the multicultural fairytale, that truly believe that there is nothing special about "Britain" (England is more or less dead and buried), that "Britain" is whatever you want it to be, and who don't really know anything about who they are or what their culture is. If you ask them what the essence of their culture is they'll probably just shrug their shoulders and say "tolerance". It's quite clear that such a situation cannot last for very long. The problem for these people is course of that they want to feel at home somewhere, belong somewhere and to something just as much as everyone else.
Tefhel
Ehh. This is getting far too confusing, especially abstracting it to an international level. All I'm saying is that on TSR it is only the left wing, readily-offended types who say it is "illogical" to be proud of things. I've not seen a right wing person say it. Not all left wing people say it either, but a large handful of people do.
I don't know if there is anything intrinsically British about ideology. On TSR I may agree as we are students. On a wider level, I differ.
Reply 71
innerhollow
It's just a bit weird to understand how people can be proud of something that's so far removed from their personal life. I really enjoy living here and I think this a great country, I don't see a reason feel any pride over this country's achievements, nor do I feel shame over it's failings; because I had no personal stake in any of them.

However, it's not that I object to such an ideology, but the modern definition of patriotism seems to refer to loud, boorish attitudes to your country's success; an obsession with national symbols; and a refusal to accept any shortcomings of your countries (when even the most proud parent will accept their children has flaws). Those don't really suggest genuine pride in your country, they're just very annoying behaviours.

I think this modern definition is erroneous - like the tards who in the "What is cultured?" thread said it was pretentious Rahs who wear loads of designer clothes. No that's not what the word means at all! Stick to traditional definitions.

Really? I think I would be a completely different person if I had been born in any different country. Your country has so much to do with you - your morals, attitudes, behaviour, even your personality all are affected by the country and society you live in. I think your country is an essential part of you. I mean there are national stereotypes for a reason. That's why I can't understand it when people think it's really racist to like your country...
Reply 72
missygeorgia
I'm a left wing British student and I'm not anti British- I'm just anti-patriotism.


This, although I suspect this thread was made entirely with the intention of trolling:

Patriotism is damaging to the intellectual growth of the individual as well as the species as a whole. Nationalism is an outdated concept that only exists to be exploited for the designs of the ruling class.
Stricof
Well I would argue that that it depends on the social outlook. Admiteddly more left wingers fit into a liberal or libertarian spectrum but you also get those from the right that hit that area as well.
Communist Mandela....I chuckle :p:



http://www.rhodesia.nl/goodcom.html
http://dienuwesuidafrika.wordpress.com/2008/08/24/nelson-mandela-the-puppet-of-communism/
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/2466167/posts
http://www.jbs.org/jbs-news-feed/5755-qinvictusq-and-the-truth-about-mandela-
Reply 74
I'm left, and I love Britain :biggrin:

I don't understand all the people saying there's nothing to be proud of about Britain...
As a nation we continually punch 100 times above our weight and we're such a tiny country!

And who cares if we have a shady past? What country doesn't?

I'm a patriot and that doesn't make me racist, I love Britain for it's culture and it's history and what it's achieved :biggrin:

And our flag is the best :p:

Theres no argument that the ANC used to be associated closely with communism. But nonetheless I don't see Mandela or the ANC as communists anymore. But of course you may think what you will :p:
Reply 76
Tefhel
I think this modern definition is erroneous - like the tards who in the "What is cultured?" thread said it was pretentious Rahs who wear loads of designer clothes. No that's not what the word means at all! Stick to traditional definitions.

Really? I think I would be a completely different person if I had been born in any different country. Your country has so much to do with you - your morals, attitudes, behaviour, even your personality all are affected by the country and society you live in. I think your country is an essential part of you. I mean there are national stereotypes for a reason. That's why I can't understand it when people think it's really racist to like your country...


this is absolute nonsense, and sounds worringly like the type of argument a liberal nationalist like Tamir would put forward in trying to reconcile liberalism and nationalism. the notion of a contextualized individual has been torn to shreds by numerous scholars (MacCormick, Charney, Buttle et al), and even if something did give you part of your identity, to then argue that one should automatically be proud of it is entirely illogical. would I be proud of my country if it was run by an authoritarian dictatorship, even though it helped form part of my identity? probably not.
missygeorgia
gosh, you really know how to persuade people to change their minds. I have completely rethought and changed my mind on my stance on patriotism because you called me an idiot.


Yet you are still unable to refute my arguement, nor justify your own :biggrin:
Holte Ender
Yet you are still unable to refute my arguement, nor justify your own :biggrin:


Why would I want to debate with someone who calls me an idiot in their first reply to me? No thanx. If you wanted a discussion you should have been more polite.
Reply 79
qwrty
this is absolute nonsense, and sounds worringly like the type of argument a liberal nationalist like Tamir would put forward in trying to reconcile liberalism and nationalism. the notion of a contextualized individual has been torn to shreds by numerous scholars (MacCormick, Charney, Buttle et al), and even if something did give you part of your identity, to then argue that one should automatically be proud of it is entirely illogical. would I be proud of my country if it was run by an authoritarian dictatorship, even though it helped form part of my identity? probably not.

It's not nonsense at all. Would you be the same person if you were born in Afghanistan, in China, in the USA? No. A lot of stuff is influenced by your environment, and denying that is not only wrong but makes you look incredibly stupid.

Latest

Trending

Trending