Will Snape redeem himself in Book 7?
Use this section to start a discussion about your favourite TV shows, films, music artists, books and video games.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Please change your TSR password | 23-05-2013 | |
-
- Reputation:
- Thread Starter
- Benevolent Member
- Location: United Kingdom
- Posts: 607
Will Snape redeem himself in Book 7?I think JK Rowling might do an about turn and have Snape kill Voldemort. This would show why Dumbledore trusted him and that the two had a plan that was to be carried out after Dumbledore's death.
OFF TOPIC!
Questions I want answered:
Will Ron Weasley have his chance to shine? We know he's Harry's side-kick but apart from humour he has never had a stand out contribution to Harry's adventures except in Book 1 with the chess game. Hermione's brain often gets Harry out of tough spots (basically shown throughout the books) and chides him when he's wrong (Harry's "saving people thing" book 5, prior to Sirius' death.) However Ron has yet to have a major contribution to Harry's exploits.
Will Harry (and thus readers) ever meet Aberforth Dumbledore?
What did Dudley see when attacked by Dementors?
Should Merope Gaunt have been made a stronger character? I personally think so, in previous books I had the idea she was an adept Dark Witch(?) especially being descended from Salazar Slytherin.
What was Rowena Ravenclaw's mascot? (Slytherin= ring, Gryffindor= sword, Hufflepuff= goblet) -
- Reputation:
- TSR Demigod
- Location: in the lab drinking coffee - so glad to see nothing has changed after graduation
- Posts: 5,387
I reckon Snape is going to die no question. It's a shame because I really like his character
Aberforth may make an appearance too in some shape or form because JKR doesn't put people in the books for no reason.
-
- Reputation:
- Overlord in Training
- Location: Washington DC
- Posts: 3,461
From a literary perspective Snapes allegiance will have to be revealed. That can be accomplished through only 2 means.
a) Snape does something to ulitmatley prove his loyalty to the OoP beyond any doubt- ie he dies for the cause.
b) Snape does something so bad as it shows he is loyal to the Death Eaters- killing dumbledore was a start, but this could be part of a plan.
In the end, Snape gets killed I bet, well just have to see how. -
- Reputation:
- TSR Legend
- Location: Monkey Island
- Posts: 12,818
double(Original post by Hashshashin)
I'm not touching the poll, simply because I believe every single one of them is realistically possible.
In a werid way though, it sort of makes sence that someone else will have to kill Voldemort. Because don't forget that Harry's and Voldemorts wands don't work against each other because they are related (in core terms). So unless Harry uses someone elses wand (I can't really see Voldemort on the floor without one), someone else will have to kill him. -
- Reputation:
- Junior Member
i personally think the barman of hog's head is aberfotrth... i think this beaucse dumbledore went to taht pub when he herd the profercy... and rem he said he was friends with the bar man... and teh bar man is mentioned many tiem sin the books, its like he is an important charcter himself.... i cant remember any quotes of the tops of my head, but i think aberforth is the barman. if u guys read through the books again... payign attention to the barattender, u may also think this, but so far i dont think anyone has thought of this, so i could be wrong ... oh my is snape could or evill..... i love snape... but i hope he doesnt die... i wouldnt mind hagrid dying ...but will harry make it himself?...the last sentence in book 6 'still one last golden day of peace to enjoy with ron and hermione' has made me think he may die :s ihope he doesnt....
-
- Reputation:
- TSR Demigod
- Location: in the lab drinking coffee - so glad to see nothing has changed after graduation
- Posts: 5,387
She thinks Aberforth is the barman in the Hogs Head as Dumbledore said he was good friends with the barman.
She loves Snape and hopes he doesn't die
She doesn't mind if Hagrid dies
She doesn't know if Harry is going to make it as JKR has sort of implied he may not.
She hopes Harry doesn't die
-
- Reputation:
- TSR Legend
- Location: Monkey Island
- Posts: 12,818
Aww, don't feel too bad. It was really good for someone to come up with something like that. It just happened to have been already answered.(Original post by Luna)
sorry for my typing..i'm really bad at it..cos i type really fast...
damn, i felt proud of my theory...but now i feel let down that it was already a known fact.... -
- Reputation:
- TSR Demigod
- Location: in the lab drinking coffee - so glad to see nothing has changed after graduation
- Posts: 5,387
likewise.(Original post by yokki_girl)
as thethings are right now is pretty difficult to know what is gonna happen, i think that most of them can be done, cant wait to read the seventh ...
It's a shame we're going to have to wait I want to see how it ends!!!
it's quite hard to judge really.
Aberforth may make an appearance too in some shape or form because JKR doesn't put people in the books for no reason.
)
