Help!!! Medicine or Maths

You've got questions about applying for uni, we've got the answers. Step inside...

Announcements Posted on
Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera 20-05-2013
IMPORTANT: You must wait until midnight (morning exams)/4.30AM (afternoon exams) to discuss Edexcel exams and until 1pm/6pm the following day for STEP and IB exams. Please read before posting, including for rules for practical and oral exams. 28-04-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. OmnipotentOmelette's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: england
    • Posts: 212
    Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Hi. Im currently studying for AS level (5 exams next week probably shouldn't be on here lol) which are Biology, Chemistry, Economics, Maths, Further Maths.

    Next year i am considering applying to study medicine or maths (with the intention to then work in the finance sector in accountancy or investment banking or an actuary.)

    But I don't know which is best because both careers seem appealing. If I wanted to could I earn a lot in medicine or would the financial sector be more financially rewarding? Also would taking medicine be better in terms of helping people, which I find very appealing.

    What combination of subjects would be good (I think next year I can cope with 4 if two of them are maths and further maths).

    Thanks. I know this is random but....... any help would be great

    Also if i work hard i know i can get A grades (A* in maths hopefully )
    Last edited by OmnipotentOmelette; 08-01-2011 at 20:27.
  2. Mask Of Sanity's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: Middle Earth
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Biology, Chemistry, Maths, and Further Maths is your best bet probably.
  3. Firaila's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: Leicester
    • Posts: 1,501
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    The two are vastly different career paths

    Don't pick medicine because you want "teh monies lulzz", I'm pretty sure you have to be dedicated to spend 6 years of your life studying a hard degree.
  4. Militantbuthopeful's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,427
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    I think you should do some work experience in both, see what you like, then choose medicine so you can become as awesome as this guy.

    drmcninja
  5. Vitamin D's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: Scotland
    • Posts: 2,171
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by Firaila)
    The two are vastly different career paths

    Don't pick medicine because you want "teh monies lulzz", I'm pretty sure you have to be dedicated to spend 6 years of your life studying a hard degree.
    What I was going to say in a more roundabout way.

    Medicine is a huge commitment, I've never really came across someone who was on the fence about doing it. You either want to, or you don't.
  6. manu7014's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 82
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    if you want money do something like dentistry...
    if you're not genuinely interested in medicine i think you'll find it hard to get in
    ditto with maths...
    what do you find more interesting??
    and which unis are you looking at?
  7. Vav123's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 108
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    I'm having the same problem too :rolleyes:
    doing the same subjects as you but hoping to get A2 bio and maths out of the way this year and finish the rest next year. I'm just going to try and get work exp in both and see which one interests me the most i guess. But since your going for a maths degree i would say drop econ.
  8. TheSownRose's Avatar
    • PS Helper
    • TSR Royalty
    • Location: Alone up on the hills and snow
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by OmnipotentOmelette)
    Hi. Im currently studying for AS level (5 exams next week probably shouldn't be on here lol) which are Biology, Chemistry, Economics, Maths, Further Maths.

    Next year i am considering applying to study medicine or maths (with the intention to then work in the finance sector in accountancy or investment banking or an actuary.)

    But I don't know which is best because both careers seem appealing. If I wanted to could I earn a lot in medicine or would the financial sector be more financially rewarding? Also would taking medicine be better in terms of helping people, which I find very appealing.

    What combination of subjects would be good (I think next year I can cope with 4 if two of them are maths and further maths).

    Thanks. I know this is random but....... any help would be great

    Also if i work hard i know i can get A grades (A* in maths hopefully )
    They are very different paths, and other people are better to advise on which one because of my bias. However, in terms of keeping your options open, chemistry, biology, maths and further maths would be best - leaves both medicine and maths open.
  9. amyy12321's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Location: Newcastle Upon Tyne
    • Posts: 21
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Your in the exact same situation I was in last year (apart from i did media instead of economics).

    If you do medicine you have to take a UKCAT test, which tests your personality, and if it is suited to the job, so not just your grades are taken into account. To do medicine you need to be really passionate about it, when I was considering doing it, I was told to volunteer with old people because the universities look for compassion in you, and that will look really good, as well as improving personal skills.
  10. the_prodigy's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Location: Dagenham
    • Posts: 103
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by OmnipotentOmelette)
    Hi. Im currently studying for AS level (5 exams next week probably shouldn't be on here lol) which are Biology, Chemistry, Economics, Maths, Further Maths.

    Next year i am considering applying to study medicine or maths (with the intention to then work in the finance sector in accountancy or investment banking or an actuary.)

    But I don't know which is best because both careers seem appealing. If I wanted to could I earn a lot in medicine or would the financial sector be more financially rewarding? Also would taking medicine be better in terms of helping people, which I find very appealing.

    What combination of subjects would be good (I think next year I can cope with 4 if two of them are maths and further maths).

    Thanks. I know this is random but....... any help would be great

    Also if i work hard i know i can get A grades (A* in maths hopefully )
    If you would like to work in the financial sector i would recommend maybe doing economics in Uni and choosing the combination Economics,Maths,Further maths.

    Thats if you find economics interesting at all :^_^:
  11. lekky's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Britland
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    You don't have to decide yet.

    Have you done any work experience? Try and set some up. Care home is good for your application but doesn't give you much of an idea as to what a doctor actually does, shadowing would be better.

    Medicine is not anywhere near financially rewarding in the way that banking is. Do bare that in mind.
  12. Melanie-v's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 937
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    If you want to do medicine, a lot of places ignore Further maths and look at Maths + FM as on A-level. Just a warning, before you decide on medicine but take FM anyway. If you enjoy maths and FM most, I'd say maths. Medicine is a long course and requires a lot of dedication and work. It doesn't help if you don't like the material. That's just imo though, and I'm going to be biased towards maths anyway.
  13. OmnipotentOmelette's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: england
    • Posts: 212
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by manu7014)
    if you want money do something like dentistry...
    if you're not genuinely interested in medicine i think you'll find it hard to get in
    ditto with maths...
    what do you find more interesting??
    and which unis are you looking at?
    I find maths very interesting and I'm very good at it . However I consider a medical career more worthwhile and well respected.
    Dentistry... that's definatly an option... WHY DO I HAVE SUCH BIG DECISIONS TO MAKE!!!! AAAARRRRRGGGHHHHHHHHH!

    For medicine I would go for a red brick uni probably with a mixture or problem based learning and traditional learning. I think which uni matters less because its a vocational course and they are all similar and there is less 'prestige'.
    For maths I would aim high i.e. Oxbridge, Imerial, Warwick etc. However wouldn't london be an expensive place to go to uni?
  14. Extricated's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 2,665
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Tbh, if you do a maths degree, you will in fact earn MORE than medicine if you go into investment banking. As others have said, Medicine requires a great deal of dedication, which (seemingly) you don't have. However, get the grades and you won't be restricted either way.
  15. OmnipotentOmelette's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: england
    • Posts: 212
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    But to work in the financial sector in the City wouldn't, for the best chances, I need to go to a top 5 uni for maths. And I thought that you had to work ridiculous hours when you are a graduate in the City. Surely you need to be dedicated to do that, especially considering the competition.

    One more thing. Which sector has the best future? What I mean by that is will doctors be as well-off in 15-20 years time, and will banking reforms reduce my chances of being successful financially if I worked in the City?

    I don't wish to sound obsessed with money. I just want to be successful.
  16. TheSownRose's Avatar
    • PS Helper
    • TSR Royalty
    • Location: Alone up on the hills and snow
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by OmnipotentOmelette)
    But to work in the financial sector in the City wouldn't, for the best chances, I need to go to a top 5 uni for maths. And I thought that you had to work ridiculous hours when you are a graduate in the City. Surely you need to be dedicated to do that, especially considering the competition.

    One more thing. Which sector has the best future? What I mean by that is will doctors be as well-off in 15-20 years time, and will banking reforms reduce my chances of being successful financially if I worked in the City?

    I don't wish to sound obsessed with money. I just want to be successful.
    Medicine is quite stable, where as banking seems to be a notoriously volatile field - good when it's good, but when it all falls to pieces... :no:
  17. manu7014's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 82
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by OmnipotentOmelette)
    I find maths very interesting and I'm very good at it . However I consider a medical career more worthwhile and well respected.
    Dentistry... that's definatly an option... WHY DO I HAVE SUCH BIG DECISIONS TO MAKE!!!! AAAARRRRRGGGHHHHHHHHH!

    For medicine I would go for a red brick uni probably with a mixture or problem based learning and traditional learning. I think which uni matters less because its a vocational course and they are all similar and there is less 'prestige'.
    For maths I would aim high i.e. Oxbridge, Imerial, Warwick etc. However wouldn't london be an expensive place to go to uni?
    Yeah it's true.
    I agree- aim for the top unis for maths, especially if you're very good at it. Also I'd look at the stuff you actually do at uni for maths, see if you like it or not. Imo i think you should go for maths, you're clearly very good at it and to me you seem more interested in it than medicine. Also you can do a lot with a maths degree like banking isn't the only thing which will get you a lot of money from a maths degree - you can go into accountancy or statistical stuff which is in money. Also another thing after a maths degree which is a Bsc by the way you can ALWAYS do a graduate course in medicine if that's what you want to do after it.
    As for unis, yeh I'd look at oxbridge, imperial, warwick, durham, bath, ucl... those sort of unis are excellent for maths and particularly well known in that area. Doing well with maths at a good top uni will open up so many opportunities for you.
    Also mathematicians are awesome.
  18. OmnipotentOmelette's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: england
    • Posts: 212
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Thanks people! Very helpful. I've still got a while to think about it but i'm going to do some volunteering and shadow a GP, so I have enough things to put on UCAS if I do want top do medicine.
  19. Beska's Avatar
    • Section Moderator
    • PS Helper
    • primum non nocere
    • Location: UK
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    (Original post by OmnipotentOmelette)
    Thanks people! Very helpful. I've still got a while to think about it but i'm going to do some volunteering and shadow a GP, so I have enough things to put on UCAS if I do want top do medicine.
    The main reason you should do the shadowing is to find out if you even want to study medicine.
  20. mkb230's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,178
    Re: Help!!! Medicine or Maths
    Do Math
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.