[Hype en Ecosse]

Dalek1099 won't be happy with that conclusion.

Bit miffed that the Doctor was on Skarro at the start, too. What happened to it and Gallifrey being time-locked?

Also lol'd at Rory's "eggs?" moment.

(Original post by SirMasterKey)
So how will Jenna-Louise Coleman come back now?

Surely it can't be a case of going back in time and then travelling with her?

I predict the Doctor crossing into her timeline pre-crash into the asylum, and he inevitably causes the crash of the Alaska. Cueing a massive David Tennant style guilt trip.

[drbluebox]

What Doctor Who was on tonight? Totally been swamped with college so didnt realise.

[spacepirate-James]

(Original post by Hype en Ecosse)
I predict the Doctor crossing into her timeline pre-crash into the asylum, and he inevitably causes the crash of the Alaska. Cueing a massive David Tennant style guilt trip.

It will totally be this!

(Original post by greeneyedgirl)
So agreed!

His hair.

[sleekchic]

(Original post by spacepirate-James)
Remember when we wondered who River Song was?

To be honest, I did see Miracle Day and still thought I was on some crazy drugs.

Ok I take that back. I'll just sit back and enjoy it. No more speculating.

(Original post by Miracle Day)
Thanks for ruining that Oswin is going to be the companion guys

Have you been living under a rock?

[Miracle Day]

(Original post by sleekchic)
Ok I take that back. I'll just sit back and enjoy it. No more speculating.



Have you been living under a rock?

Nah. Ever since Doctor Who turned **** I don't actively seek out spoilers

[Henna x]

(Original post by rhw)
That was Oswald Danes the paedophile who killed himself taking down that huge hole in China

People who haven't seen it must think I'm on some hallucinogen

Lol ahh right I remember now. Thanks for that

[alexlduffy]

The one thing that confuses me about Oswin (or I'm probably just confusing myself) is this -

Spoiler:

Show

if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Either way, I'm VERY excited for the new assistant to arrive now

Edit: Not sure if spoiler tags are needed X_X

[Aula]

(Original post by alexlduffy)
The one thing that confuses me about Oswin (or I'm probably just confusing myself) is this - if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Either way, I'm VERY excited for the new assistant to arrive now

Wibbley wobbley timey wimey stuff?

[getfunky!]

(Original post by drbluebox)
What Doctor Who was on tonight? Totally been swamped with college so didnt realise.

Series 7, episode 1.

It was amazingit'll be on iplayer so you can catch up.

[sleekchic]

Oh so her name is Clara Oswin?

FFS, I thought it was Oswin something and that for some reason and when she became the new companion, she would call herself Clara for some reason.

[Hype en Ecosse]

(Original post by alexlduffy)

Spoiler:

Show

if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Simples. The Dalek conversion ****s with your memories as the Doctor said. Hence why she couldn't remember she was converted, hence why Amy couldn't remember she had already had that conversation with the Doctor 4 times.

[TheHistoryStudent]

(Original post by alexlduffy)
The one thing that confuses me about Oswin (or I'm probably just confusing myself) is this -

Spoiler:

Show

if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Either way, I'm VERY excited for the new assistant to arrive now

Edit: Not sure if spoiler tags are needed X_X

Well....

Spoiler:

Show

she deleted the Doctor from the Dalek's memory didn't she?

- so perhaps that has something to do with it? Or perhaps the time-line will simply be re-written so that it doesn't happen?

If she is the new companion (which I'll be honest and say I don't really know because I don't follow spoilers very often), then as others have said, the only way I can really see her becoming the companion is if it is by some kind of time-travel... but doesn't it seem just a bit lazy to just repeat the whole kind of river song style of doing it? Especially since that was only a few series ago...

[Hype en Ecosse]

(Original post by TheHistoryStudent)
Well....

Spoiler:

Show

she deleted the Doctor from the Dalek's memory didn't she?

- so perhaps that has something to do with it?

Spoiler:

Show

She deleted him long after she first saw him on the planet.

I'm sticking with what I put in the other post.

[SirMasterKey]

(Original post by sleekchic)
It seems like it's the only way but it can't be that straightforward.

Well, other ways:

Identical twin

Emergency Temporal Shift and then she designed the technology to change herself back.

Emergency Temporal shift and The Doctor actually travels around with a Dalek, we just see her thoughts and in the cock-pit.

[greeneyedgirl]

(Original post by spacepirate-James)
It will totally be this!

His hair.

His clothes

(Original post by alexlduffy)
The one thing that confuses me about Oswin (or I'm probably just confusing myself) is this -

Spoiler:

Show

if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Either way, I'm VERY excited for the new assistant to arrive now

Edit: Not sure if spoiler tags are needed X_X

Dalek conversion messes with memory or they may not meet pre-conversion, he could save her somehow...that'd be epic!

[SirMasterKey]

(Original post by alexlduffy)
The one thing that confuses me about Oswin (or I'm probably just confusing myself) is this -

Spoiler:

Show

if Oswin is the same person as the new assistant, how does she not recognise the Doctor? After all, when we first saw River (before she died), she recognised the Doctor, so seeing as how Oswin has also met a tragic fate, how did she not recognise the Doctor? Maybe it's the fact that she was in a dream? Or it could even be that she DID know the Doctor and neglected to mention anything? Meh, maybe I'm confusing myself.

Either way, I'm VERY excited for the new assistant to arrive now

Edit: Not sure if spoiler tags are needed X_X

Response to a part of your spoiler

Spoiler:

Show

No. Or at least I really really hope not. That is too like River and the whole, 'Oooh I knew really but I just couldn't tell you ' which after several times just gets

[BP_Tranquility]

(Original post by SirMasterKey)
Well, other ways:

Identical twin

Emergency Temporal Shift and then she designed the technology to change herself back.

Emergency Temporal shift and The Doctor actually travels around with a Dalek, we just see her thoughts and in the cock-pit.

If they were identical twins, wouldn't that be quite similar to Martha Jones and her look-alike from Army of Ghosts?


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App

[syrettd]

(Original post by SirMasterKey)
Well, other ways:

Identical twin

Emergency Temporal Shift and then she designed the technology to change herself back.

Emergency Temporal shift and The Doctor actually travels around with a Dalek, we just see her thoughts and in the cock-pit.

Haha, I vote for this! The Doctor and his dalek companion!

[greeneyedgirl]

(Original post by syrettd)
Haha, I vote for this! The Doctor and his dalek companion!

it'd be like K9 but not quite

[SharkInTheWater]

Oswin acts a bit like the Doctor. Not basing this on any evidence, just throwing it out there. Maybe something to do with...

Spoiler:

Show

Jenny (a.k.a The Doctor's "daughter"). They have to explore that character eventually.