possible theories

Use this section to start a discussion about your favourite TV shows, films, music artists, books and video games.

Announcements Posted on
Please change your TSR password 23-05-2013
Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera 20-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. devilgirl999's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Nottm
    • Posts: 805
    possible theories
    sorry if some have been said already here ya go

    1) hermione is an animagus 'a werewolf only responds to the call of its own kind' then why the hell did lupin/werewolf follow hermiones howl??

    2) MALFOY IS DEAD yep thats right in the american version it says something like and im PARAPHRASING here:
    'he cannot kill you if you are already dead'

    3) Ron has some sort of psychic connection things like when Hermione suggests that (on their homework for trelawney think its OOTP) 'you seem to be drowning twice' well in HBP he 'drowns' because he is poisoned almost perhaps this will happen again maybe the giant squid grabs hold of him lol

    4) Dumbledore is not dead i repeat NOT DEAD his animagus is a Phoenix during the funeral harry saw something come from the ashes...

    5) I think sadly ron has to die the male best friend always sacrifices himself for the hero it happened in PS/SS with the wizard chess it could happen again

    please feel free to debate on my theories happy new year every one! xxx
  2. iceman_jondoe's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: London/Exeter/Leeds
    • Posts: 5,343
    theres too many harry potter threads
  3. devilgirl999's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Nottm
    • Posts: 805
    oh and to help with some of my ideas i got some from http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/introduction.html

    --------------

    no offence but dont look at them then duh
  4. fordeletionpurposesonly.'s Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: In a house
    • Posts: 1,850
    (Original post by devilgirl999)
    sorry if some have been said already here ya go

    1) hermione is an animagus 'a werewolf only responds to the call of its own kind' then why the hell did lupin/werewolf follow hermiones howl??
    Lupin's not an Animigus, he's a werewolf - I don't think that if Hermione was an Animagus she'd be a werewolf, she'd be something like an owl, I reckon. Much more wise.

    (Original post by devilgirl999)
    2) MALFOY IS DEAD yep thats right in the american version it says something like and im PARAPHRASING here:
    'he cannot kill you if you are already dead'
    Dumbledore was talking about Malfoy pretending to be killed in his attempt to kill Dumbledore - thus, he could be taken into the protection of the Order, he could reveal that he's really a goodie, and work against Voldemort without feat of him coming after him for failing to kill of Dumbledore. It wasn't meant literally.

    (Original post by devilgirl999)
    3) Ron has some sort of psychic connection things like when Hermione suggests that (on their homework for trelawney think its OOTP) 'you seem to be drowning twice' well in HBP he 'drowns' because he is poisoned almost perhaps this will happen again maybe the giant squid grabs hold of him lol
    Some sort of psychic connection thing to what? how is being poisoned drowning?!
  5. Nuheen's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: In the madding crowd...
    • Posts: 2,076
    No offence but I dont agree with any of your points.
  6. wottabout's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: not sure
    • Posts: 680
    (Original post by devilgirl999)
    sorry if some have been said already here ya go

    1) hermione is an animagus 'a werewolf only responds to the call of its own kind' then why the hell did lupin/werewolf follow hermiones howl??

    2) MALFOY IS DEAD yep thats right in the american version it says something like and im PARAPHRASING here:
    'he cannot kill you if you are already dead'

    3) Ron has some sort of psychic connection things like when Hermione suggests that (on their homework for trelawney think its OOTP) 'you seem to be drowning twice' well in HBP he 'drowns' because he is poisoned almost perhaps this will happen again maybe the giant squid grabs hold of him lol

    4) Dumbledore is not dead i repeat NOT DEAD his animagus is a Phoenix during the funeral harry saw something come from the ashes...

    5) I think sadly ron has to die the male best friend always sacrifices himself for the hero it happened in PS/SS with the wizard chess it could happen again

    please feel free to debate on my theories happy new year every one! xxx
    1) I don't think that was in the book; I was under the impression that he ran off just because he felt like it.
    2) I agree with red665.
    3) I agree with red665 on this one too.
    4) Was Dumbledore an animagus? Oh well, maybe I missed that.
    5) Maybe, but I'm putting my bets on Neville sacrificing himself.
  7. Sephrenia's Avatar
    • TSR Royalty
    • Location: Exeter
    (Original post by iceman_jondoe)
    theres too many harry potter threads
    Might be because there is a forum devoted to HP :p:
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.