If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?
Discuss issues related to past events, people, places, or old empires and civilisations.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Please change your TSR password | 23-05-2013 | |
| Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera | 20-05-2013 | |
-
- Reputation:
- Thread Starter
- Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
- Location: Askham
- Posts: 4,809
If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Just a question I was wondering this morning. Given Russia's vast Conventional Army, it would almost certainly be a clear victory in terms of a conventional war, surely? However, as the Cold War is famous for being minutes (?) away from global thermonuclear war, would Russia or America have come out victorious?
I thought it would depend on which hit the most crucial targets the fastest and first. Both sides had their early warning systems, and both had their own Nuclear Warheads in fairly close proximity to each other.
But, I was unsure about which would win and how it would play out. A Nuclear War followed by a massed invasion? Who do you think would've won? -
- Reputation:
- Benevolent Member
- Posts: 625
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?I doubt it would have happened because they would have just carpet bombed each other,
and if you think that radiation from Japans disaster has been recorded in Scotland we would all have died anyway. The invasion would probably not have happened.
Niether side would have backed down. -
- Reputation:
- Thread Starter
- Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
- Location: Askham
- Posts: 4,809
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Granted there was that. However, I don't think either were bluffing with their threats. Examples such as the Cuban Missile Crisis. If they hadn't meant war to happen, (however much they thought it was a last resort), the Russians surely wouldn't have dared American Response. Similarly, American Missiles in Turkey... No?
I quoted someone and its not there now... Odd...Last edited by DH-Biker; 28-07-2011 at 11:57. -
- Reputation:
- Supercilious Chicken
- Posts: 3,893
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Given that Russia had to pull out of the Cold War because it couldn't afford to keep up with America on its nuclear spending, I imagine the USA would win. They quickly mobilised the general population during WW2, and had far more spending power and resources that the USSR.
I think both sides realised that actual conflict would be catastrophic though, hence why there never was an actual war, so maybe both sides would have "lost" in the general meaning of the word. -
- Reputation:
- Peer Of The TSR Realm
- Location: Hogwarts
- Posts: 1,536
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Probably would've turned into an out and out world war 3 in which there would be no winner... Loads of nations would have joined, Iran, Iraq, Israel; France, UK, Spain and whatnot- total destruction.
I doubt it'd be over now tbf... -
- Reputation:
- Overlord in Training
- Location: Nawwth Posts: ∞
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?No one would have won, one would have launched first, the other would have FIRED EVERYTHING (I think that's from a film), and then both countries would have been nuked to ****, probably killing the whole planet.
But the moles will win when this happens/cockroaches. -
- Reputation:
- Peer Of The TSR Realm
- Location: Just there, no - there.
- Posts: 1,517
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?China or russia hasn't featured in a Fallout game, therefore I would say the US.
But on a serious note, had it went nuclear very few people would be living today, and I think even less would be caring about their nationality. -
- Reputation:
- Peer Of The TSR Realm
- Location: Just there, no - there.
- Posts: 1,517
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?(Original post by Circadian_Rhythm)
No one would have won, one would have launched first, the other would have FIRED EVERYTHING (I think that's from a film), and then both countries would have been nuked to ****, probably killing the whole planet.
But the moles will win when this happens/cockroaches.
That is from that New-ish Star Trek film. -
- Reputation:
- Adored and Respected Member
- Location: Bosnia
- Posts: 472
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Yes USSR had to pull out of the Cold War because they could not keep up with USA, but USSR has one advantage over USA which in conventional warfare is crucial. Russia has large territory and there is no way that conventional armies could get near factories in Siberia quick enough, thus USSR keep up production and lives of its citizens while in the same time if mobilized fully today numbers over 20 mill soldiers and machinery (it has nearly 20 mill reserve troops).(Original post by Nut.)
Given that Russia had to pull out of the Cold War because it couldn't afford to keep up with America on its nuclear spending, I imagine the USA would win. They quickly mobilised the general population during WW2, and had far more spending power and resources that the USSR.
I think both sides realised that actual conflict would be catastrophic though, hence why there never was an actual war, so maybe both sides would have "lost" in the general meaning of the word.
But looking onto the nature of the Cold War we cannot look at it as conventional war. If any of the nuclear bombs were to fire than either side had no chance. Proof to that can be seen in MAD (Mutually Assured Destruction). Since if USSR fires any of their missiles USA would notice it immediately and in a matter of minutes their high command would be in safe-house where there is no threat. Plus if they launched any missiles USA would launch all their arsenal (full retaliation) in which USA, USSR and parts of area around those countries would be destroyed completely and the rest of the world would follow due to radiation. -
- Reputation:
- Peer Of The TSR Realm
- Posts: 1,478
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?This /Thread
-
- Reputation:
- Overlord in Training
- Location: Nawwth Posts: ∞
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?Oh yeah Nero says it.. thanks(Original post by A.galloway)
That is from that New-ish Star Trek film.
-
- Reputation:
- Benevolent Member
- Posts: 847
Re: If the Cold War had turned 'Hot', would Russia or America have won?I doubt anyone would have won as millions would have died on both sides. But if I had to guess americia would have survived better as the UK and the rest of the more powerful countries would have allied with the USA.
