not really. he did crap in west indies 'cos he was new, and nervous and completely allowed to be crap. then he played the last test in india, and made two 50s or something, which almost won india the test, when they could have lost it.
then in aus, in completely foreign conditions, under high pressure, he hasn't done too badly. he's mastered the art of the shorter form, but he's only about 6 tests old! cut him some slack! hardly judge form/talent from 6 tests!
same with ashwin, he's only played 2 tests abroad. on aussie pitches not known for spin. at least man can bat!
exactly thaat