The Manchester United Thread IX

Football discussion forum.

Announcements Posted on
TSR launches Learn Together! - Our new subscription to help improve your learning 16-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. Solid_Snake7's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: Outer Haven
    • Posts: 164
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    Apparently we're also looking at signing the 'new' Cristiano Ronaldo:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/foo...uez-Porto.html

    Anybody seen him play? Could be an alternative to Hazard, but having never seen him play I couldn't say how he compares. We definitely need a DM though, all the talk at the moment seems to be off offensive players, and whilst I think we do need a true AM, which would allow us to play Rooney as a proper striker, a good DM would help us with controlling midfield in big games.
  2. SirMasterKey's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Where ever the wind takes me.
    • Posts: 6,290
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    I always hate it when the phrase "the 'new' XXXX YYYY" is used. As a player I'd get quite cheesed off as well, firstly for the expectations placed on me and secondly I want to be AAAA BBBB (myself) not someone else.
  3. rickjames's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 864
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by Solid_Snake7)
    Apparently we're also looking at signing the 'new' Cristiano Ronaldo:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/foo...uez-Porto.html

    Anybody seen him play? Could be an alternative to Hazard, but having never seen him play I couldn't say how he compares. We definitely need a DM though, all the talk at the moment seems to be off offensive players, and whilst I think we do need a true AM, which would allow us to play Rooney as a proper striker, a good DM would help us with controlling midfield in big games.
    No chance, £25mil for an unproven player whose only made 11 starts in the portugese league due to knee problems.

    I reckon we'l go for Kagawa and M'Villa as the main targets.
  4. WhatIsAUsername?'s Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,507
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by rickjames)
    No chance, £25mil for an unproven player whose only made 11 starts in the portugese league due to knee problems.

    I reckon we'l go for Kagawa and M'Villa as the main targets.
    That's a reference to Anderson.
  5. pinda.college's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: *Mount Olympus*
    • Posts: 6,971
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by rickjames)
    No chance, £25mil for an unproven player whose only made 11 starts in the portugese league due to knee problems.

    I reckon we'l go for Kagawa and M'Villa as the main targets.
    Ronaldo only scored like two or three goals during something like theirty appearances of Sporting, look at him now. I think any potential player who has the possibilty to become something special should be signed. Of course I am not saying 'sign this Rodriguez fella' because I have never seen him play.
  6. pinda.college's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: *Mount Olympus*
    • Posts: 6,971
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    I would like to get rid of Anderson if we can make some profit off him, I would much prefer a technically gifted DM so that we can have more control in midifield next season.
  7. WhatIsAUsername?'s Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,507
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by pinda.college)
    I would like to get rid of Anderson if we can make some profit off him, I would much prefer a technically gifted DM so that we can have more control in midifield next season.
    You think Anderson is worth ~20m? I wouldn't value him anything above 10m tbh.
  8. DaveSmith99's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by rickjames)
    No chance, £25mil for an unproven player whose only made 11 starts in the portugese league due to knee problems.

    I reckon we'l go for Kagawa and M'Villa as the main targets.
    M'Villa missed a match a few days ago because he got arrested for assault
  9. pinda.college's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: *Mount Olympus*
    • Posts: 6,971
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by WhatIsAUsername?)
    You think Anderson is worth ~20m? I wouldn't value him anything above 10m tbh.
    I don't think he is worth half of what we paid for him either however, you never know. We brought him for £20 mill so perhaps (hopefully) someone will buy him for that or more. Though I do doubt we'll make anything off him.
  10. Solid_Snake7's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: Outer Haven
    • Posts: 164
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by SirMasterKey)
    I always hate it when the phrase "the 'new' XXXX YYYY" is used. As a player I'd get quite cheesed off as well, firstly for the expectations placed on me and secondly I want to be AAAA BBBB (myself) not someone else.
    I know it pisses Nani off something terrible

    (Original post by DaveSmith99)
    M'Villa missed a match a few days ago because he got arrested for assault
    He sounds like the true heir to Roy Keane's throne
  11. rickjames's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 864
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by WhatIsAUsername?)
    That's a reference to Anderson.
    Who Fergie clearly regrets buying for such a large amount. His last interview regarding anderson showed some surprise at the injury prone nature of the player and he can only 'hope' Anderson puts injuries behind him (can't remember the exact wording but that was the jist). Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/foo...-Anderson.html

    I think this, if anything, will make Ferguson more cautious of buying players with knee problems such as Rodriguez, regardless of age.

    (Original post by pinda.college)
    Ronaldo only scored like two or three goals during something like theirty appearances of Sporting, look at him now. I think any potential player who has the possibilty to become something special should be signed. Of course I am not saying 'sign this Rodriguez fella' because I have never seen him play.
    Ronaldo wasn't £25mil, it was before the Glazers, and he was scouted for a while before that and I think he had more appearances to go by as well (..and he was younger, not that it matters much when this Rodriguez guy is 20 but still).
    Last edited by rickjames; 04-05-2012 at 08:10.
  12. AndersonsBentFoot's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: london
    • Posts: 3,630
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by rickjames)
    Who Fergie clearly regrets buying for such a large amount. His last interview regarding anderson showed some surprise at the injury prone nature of the player and he can only 'hope' Anderson puts injuries behind him (can't remember the exact wording but that was the jist). Source: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/foo...-Anderson.html

    I think this, if anything, will make Ferguson more cautious of buying players with knee problems such as Rodriguez, regardless of age.
    The only injury Ando had at Porto was a broken leg. In the same season he made 15 appearances, won a league medal and was playing CL football at the age of 18. He didnt have an injury record per se, you cant at the age of 18. In the same interview, he states how Ando is still young and has time to recover. He can still play a squad role and the quality of depth in the midfield has been lacking for a long time, so theres no need to offload him, just rotate to reduce chances of injury.

    If anything, Cleverley has a worse injury record and fans have been salivating over him all season

    He wasnt that cautious when buying Hargreaves
  13. rickjames's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 864
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by AndersonsBentFoot)
    The only injury Ando had at Porto was a broken leg. In the same season he made 15 appearances, won a league medal and was playing CL football at the age of 18. He didnt have an injury record per se, you cant at the age of 18. In the same interview, he states how Ando is still young and has time to recover. He can still play a squad role and the quality of depth in the midfield has been lacking for a long time, so theres no need to offload him, just rotate to reduce chances of injury.

    If anything, Cleverley has a worse injury record and fans have been salivating over him all season

    He wasnt that cautious when buying Hargreaves
    I was mentioning Ando's injuries since being at Man Utd, rather than his time at Porto. I don't think Cleverley has had a worse injury record at all, considering he was fit for most of last season at Wigan. Anderson has averaged 14 appearances a season in his last 3 seasons with us, that's quite worrying tbh. Yeah, Fergie will highlight his youth because its the only factor keeping him part of the club.

    Rodriguez is hardly comparable to Anderson of Porto anyway, given the former's acheivements, who was then was bought for less than £25mil.
  14. AndersonsBentFoot's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: london
    • Posts: 3,630
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by rickjames)
    I was mentioning Ando's injuries since being at Man Utd, rather than his time at Porto. I don't think Cleverley has had a worse injury record at all, considering he was fit for most of last season at Wigan. Anderson has averaged 14 appearances a season in his last 3 seasons with us, that's quite worrying tbh. Yeah, Fergie will highlight his youth because its the only factor keeping him part of the club.

    Rodriguez is hardly comparable to Anderson of Porto anyway, given the former's acheivements, who was then was bought for less than £25mil.
    Thats in the league. Forget about all the other competitions United are involved in and the fact squad rotation is such a huge part to SAFs success every season.
  15. Kevmeister's Avatar
    • Hardest Button to Button....
    • Location: Many Shades of Black
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    Missed the derby and all the crap afterwards.

    Here's hoping Newcastle do us a favour, they at least have something to play for besides pride.
  16. Colonel.'s Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: The Well of Lost Plots
    • Posts: 13,105
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by Kevmeister)
    Missed the derby and all the crap afterwards.

    Here's hoping Newcastle do us a favour, they at least have something to play for besides pride.
    It was nice not seeing you for a while tbh :bigsmile:
  17. Kevmeister's Avatar
    • Hardest Button to Button....
    • Location: Many Shades of Black
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    (Original post by Colonel.)
    It was nice not seeing you for a while tbh :bigsmile:
    Cheers, bbz. :kiss:
  18. wizkidy's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: England :D
    • Posts: 58
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    I had a dream last night that we won the premiership title............. hopefully it is gonna come true city r going down..........
  19. Louis.'s Avatar
    • TSR Idol
    • Posts: 8,547
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    http://thefalse9.blogspot.co.uk/2012...tion-into.html

    Nice read on Rooney if anyone has 5 minutes spare. Probably a bit over the top at times but it's good to see him getting credit for what has been an outstanding, and often underappreciated, season.

    The consensus with these Kagawa rumours has been that we'll be able to push Rooney forward into his supposedly better position...I can't help but think that could be a waste. Having someone who can score as much as Rooney while playing as deep as he can is rare and we should be wary of wasting that. We should also be wary of wasting Welbeck's potential. Maybe it's not Rooney who'll go through a transition in role, maybe it'd be Kagawa who'd undergo an Anderson-esque transformation. :dontknow: What's certain though is that Rooney's versatility gives us lots of options in incorporating new signings and rotating throughout the season.

    Spoiler:
    Show
    On a side note...still not believing these Kagawa rumours until I get them from a better source though, although many seem to be treating it as a done deal. The £7mil price seems very low, yes his contract is running out but you'd imagine other teams would be coming in and pushing the price up, unless he has pulled an Ozil and made it clear he only wants to go to one place but I haven't seen anything to suggest that.
  20. Kevmeister's Avatar
    • Hardest Button to Button....
    • Location: Many Shades of Black
    Re: The Manchester United Thread IX
    I imagine Kagawa, if he arrives, will provide more options for European nights. He can play on the wing, apparently, so could provide competition for the left side. It could see us move to a more fluent attack, with more players swapping positions. Still not convinced by the rumours either, mind.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources

Articles:

Click for live football commentary

Quick Link:

Unanswered Football Threads

Groups associated with this forum:

View associated groups
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.