[little_wizard123]

(Original post by Tommyjw)
Dont think it should have been a red.

Not sure if the fact it would (should) have been offside matters in calls like that. For example even if it was a definite red, because its offside, do they still get a red? Either way, very harsh.

No, only for a dangerous tackle as it's not relying on being in play. As it was offside, he's not the last man (not that he was in this case anyway).

[justinawe]

terrible decision, refereeing team have completely spoiled a good game

[Louis.]

Young is the biggest diver in our squad.

[KingMessi]

Offside wrong, the penalty wrong, and the red card wrong. Three incorrect decisions, all of which have now cost QPR any hope of a result. They were going to lose, in all likelihood, anyway, but the entire game's been taken away from them now.

[Tommyjw]

(Original post by little_wizard123)
No, only for a dangerous tackle as it's not relying on being in play. As it was offside, he's not the last man (not that he was in this case anyway).

True i guess.

Looked suspicious when i first saw it from 'behind' the incident, pretty clear from the replay angles though there was nothing real in it, nothing warranting that fall anyway.

Young seems to be the only guy in the squad who regularly (as regularly as you can) do stuff like that, its a shame.

[Deshi]

Very harsh on QPR. Any chance of a result gone pretty much.

[Tommyjw]

(Original post by KingMessi)
Offside wrong, the penalty wrong, and the red card wrong. Three incorrect decisions, all of which have now cost QPR any hope of a result. They were going to lose, in all likelihood, anyway, but the entire game's been taken away from them now.

You can hardly call one decision 'three wrong decisions' given they all follow eachother and are dependant on eachother lol

[KingMessi]

Decent chance. Great delivery.

[eugenius 8]

nice take by rooney

very harsh decision kinda feel for qpr

oh well good chance to build up that goal difference

[KingMessi]

(Original post by Tommyjw)
You can hardly call one decision 'three wrong decisions' given they all follow eachother and are dependant on eachother lol

Er...yes, they are three wrong decisions. One decision is whether to give offside or not; that's a decision got wrong. Once the officials have allowed the game to continue, you have the 'challenge', which gives the official the decision of whether or not to award a penalty; also wrong. Once the penalty has been given, the referee has the decision on whether to take any further action; hence, another wrong decision. Regardless, it's pretty inconsequential whether you see it as one or three; either way, it's still a goal that shouldn't have been allowed to happen.

[justinawe]

(Original post by Tommyjw)
You can hardly call one decision 'three wrong decisions' given they all follow eachother and are dependant on eachother lol

Not really, whether or not it was offside and whether or not it was a penalty were two separate decisions, though the red card was dependant on then penalty.

[hbk4894]

just found out this game was on , whats the score?

[Gob Bluth]

If Young was Suarez United fans would be out in number at this moment in time

[justinawe]

(Original post by KingMessi)
Er...yes, they are three wrong decisions. One decision is whether to give offside or not; that's a decision got wrong. Once the officials have allowed the game to continue, you have the 'challenge', which gives the official the decision of whether or not to award a penalty; also wrong. Once the penalty has been given, the referee has the decision on whether to take any further action; hence, another wrong decision. Regardless, it's pretty inconsequential whether you see it as one or three; either way, it's still a goal that shouldn't have been allowed to happen.

Not merely an unfair goal as well, since they're now a man down therefore have little to no chance of a comeback.

[doggyfizzel]

Scholes and Carrick will probably tear QPR a new one now, long time to play with 10 men. If Welbeck had a decent first touch he would score so many more goals.

[KingMessi]

(Original post by justinawe)
Not merely an unfair goal as well, since they're now a man down therefore have little to no chance of a comeback.

Precisely.

(Original post by hbk4894)
just found out this game was on , whats the score?

1-0 United.

[Tommyjw]

I wish Rooney would shoot more often

[ugk4life]

rafael is playing so far forward I forgot he was right back lol.

[doggyfizzel]

Brilliant from Evans, case and point from how he has improved, so composed there.

[Louis.]

We looked more dangerous against 11 men than 10.

Hopefully what Rafael just did will remind everyone that the only way we won't win this game is through complacency.