[Jim-Jam]

Hart, Walker, Kompany, Coloccini, Baines, Yaya Toure, Silva, Bale, Parker, Rooney, van Persie.

So just Man City with a LB who hasn't been at his best (IMO), Good old Scotty Parker, who's so good that nobody knew about him for the first ten years of his career and same old Bale/Rooney.

Van Persie got Player's player of the year and Kyle Walker (AKA best RB in history) young player.

Thoughts??

[Darth Vader 7]

Although I don't think Aguero should've been amongst the young players, it does astound me how he hasn't been picked. He is a class above most players in the league let alone the youngsters.

Van Persie did deserve the Player of the year as he has individually dragged Arsenal from the jaws of defeat to get us a result numerous times.

[checkolad]

I'm not sure about Bale and Parker

[TM94]

Walker isn't even the best young English RB

[Tommyjw]

Parker + Bale but no Valencia or Carrick? ... :/

Zero, zero idea how parker got there and Bale is only there because he was amongst all the hyper Spurs player even hes generally been crap compared to other wingers/CM's we could use.

+ Coloccini. Just luls

Thought Aguero would get Young award.

Not surprised by RVP getting it (even if he generally hasnt performed much better than Rooney, actually a bit worse, when everyone stated RVP is such an obvious choice)

[TM94]

Colo being there is COMPLETELY justified.

[Tommyjw]

Nah, multiple CBs performed better than him.

[Cll_ws]

Not sure about Bale, he's so on and off, he's been rubbish recently.
And Aguero should of been included, no idea how he hasn't been.

4-3-3, and replace Bale with Aguero.

[fnm]

I'd think about putting Cabaye in there

[Tommyjw]

I think they need to stop voting for this so early..

and give them reality checks before they put Parker in there...

[JJames]

I think Ba or Cisse should have been given a mention.
But, seriously. No Valencia? That's annoying.

[NR09]

Tim krul should be the keeper.

Scott Parker? **** off.

[NR09]

Also agree on Valencia, and Ba should definitely be there.

[Kenan and Kel]

Valencia for Bale, Modric for Parker and I'd be okay with it.

[pol pot noodles]

Paul Scholes anyone?
Obviously he's only played half the season but he does have an astonishing 86% win record in the league so far and has scored 3 goals (will be 17 after he's done at the Etihad). He's pretty much been the driving force in United's revival since those back to back defeats agasint Blackburn an Newcastle in December.

[Xotol]

(Original post by Tommyjw)
Not surprised by RVP getting it (even if he generally hasnt performed much better than Rooney, actually a bit worse, when everyone stated RVP is such an obvious choice)

Rooney did **** all after he scored 9 goals in his first 5 (?) games for a month or two, so he exactly hasn't been Mr Consistent every game. RVP could afford a blip somewhere in the season. Both players have had rough patches, and both will end up with a similar amount of goals.

Difference is that RVP has more assists on a terrible shooting team, and has single-handedly won games for Arsenal when the rest of the team was rubbish, i.e. Everton, Liverpool, Sunderland (?) and that game off the bench spring to mind.

RVP deserved it. Rooney made a late run, but RVP was always going to win and deserve it.

[Deep456]

(Original post by Tommyjw)
Parker + Bale but no Valencia or Carrick? ... :/

Zero, zero idea how parker got there and Bale is only there because he was amongst all the hyper Spurs player even hes generally been crap compared to other wingers/CM's we could use.

+ Coloccini. Just luls

Thought Aguero would get Young award.

Not surprised by RVP getting it (even if he generally hasnt performed much better than Rooney, actually a bit worse, when everyone stated RVP is such an obvious choice)

You clearly don't watch much football.

[Tommyjw]

(Original post by Deep456)
You clearly don't watch much football.

I clearly know the facts, i suggest you look them up.

(Original post by Xotol)
RVP deserved it. Rooney made a late run, but RVP was always going to win and deserve it.

Good job on completely ignoring what i actually said.

[tommm]

(Original post by Deep456)
You clearly don't watch much football.

Or, rather, he doesn't watch enough football that doesn't involve Manchester United.

[bluenose14]

The team is almost spot on IMO. The only change I'd make would be Valencia for Parker.
The young player of the year shouldn't have gone to Walker. Aguero should have had it.