Stereotypes
Discuss issues that have a social and cultural impact, including but not limited to issues such as racism, teenage pregnancies, the social impact of religion, and the state of the education system.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Please change your TSR password | 23-05-2013 | |
| Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera | 20-05-2013 | |
-
Stereotypes
Do all modern stereotypes come from the media hype of something that doesn't happen very often into something that is very common?
Were there stereotypes before news, film and tv?
What stereotypes have you never found to be true? This is TSR so I'm guessing the british teen stereotype of us going out and getting hammered every weekend and ending up getting (someone) pregnant and with STIs doesn't apply to many of us.
An what stereotypes have to found to be accurate?Last edited by Clare~Bear; 07-05-2012 at 14:25. -
Re: Stereotypes
I wouldn't say necessarily from the media, but it sure helps perpetuate them in copious amounts *cough*Hollywood*cough*, which leads to gullible people recycling them.
Course there were stereotypes before mass media, through word of mouth.
0 stereotypes are true or accurate, everybody is an individual first and foremost. Stereotypes arise from hasty generalisations from a small, tiny, significant, large etc portion of whichever group is being stereotyped, but never as a whole, why? Because its impossible, as no body is ever truly identical to another person, not even monozygotic twins raised by the same parents.
For e.g., I'm of Chinese descent, what do people expect me to be? Short, good at maths, I'm 6'1" and got a U in AS Maths.
But alas most people are dumb and can only see people through easy and simple mental catergorisations, so what can you do.
This is what I would do to stereotypes. -
Re: StereotypesChinese are typically short and on an average better at maths than other ethnicity. You can't blame people for having preconceived thoughts about you. You can attempt to act all enlightened but if someone asked you to describe the average American, your opinion would be based on stereotypes. We all have preconceived thoughts.(Original post by Aaron_xyz)
For e.g., I'm of Chinese descent, what do people expect me to be? Short, good at maths, I'm 6'1" and got a U in AS Maths.
Americans are fat = stereotype(Original post by No Man)
Depends what you classify as a 'stereotype'. I.e would the huge obesity problem in the USA and Polynesia be a stereotype or a fact?
There is a obesity problem in America = fact
X percentage of Americans are fat = fact . -
Re: StereotypesI'm talking about the stereotype that every Chinese/East Asian is short. And short compared to what? Indonesia? Japan? The Netherlands? The average height worldwide is around 5'7-5'8" for males. There is a wide variation of height across China, from the North where people are on average taller then the South, including variations from rural and urban population, plus diaspora overseas who have a different diet. The simplistic statement "Chinese are typically short" serves no purpose at all but to enforce stereotypes. The spread of height is represented as gaussian distribution, and whilst the population of Chinese in China is on average 5'7" as a whole that by doesn't mean all Chinese are that height and anyone who thinks so has no knowledge of demographics and holds stereotypical beliefs.(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
Chinese are typically short
We're talking about stereotypes here, and I'm talking about the stereotype that every Asian has to be good at math.(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
on an average better at maths than other ethnicity.
Lol, yes I can. If someone frankly believes that I'm somehow lying about my height even when its an objective fact and when I'm right in front of them or that they think I'm good at math just because of my race then they're an idiot and a bigot.(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
You can't blame people for having preconceived thoughts about you.
I'm the one whos trying to act enlighted? Just look at your arrogant and haughty post where you think you know what my beliefs are without even asking me.(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
You can attempt to act all enlightened but if someone asked you to describe the average American, your opinion would be based on stereotypes. We all have preconceived thoughts.
FYI I would say there is no average depiction of an American, as its one of the most diverse countries in the world.Last edited by Aaron_xyz; 07-05-2012 at 18:31. -
Re: StereotypesDefined by wikipedia as a popular belief regarding some individuals.(Original post by Aaron_xyz)
Do you know what a stereotype even is?
Short compared to what? Indonesia? Japan? The Netherlands? There is a wide variation of height across China, from the North where people are on average taller then the South, including variations from rural and urban population, plus diaspora overseas who have a different diet. The simplistic statement "Chinese are typically short" serves no purpose at all. The spread of height is represented as gaussian distribution, and whilst the population of Chinese in China is on average 5'7" that by doesn't mean all Chinese are that height and anyone who thinks so has no knowledge of demographics and holds stereotypical beliefs.
We're talking about stereotypes here, and I'm talking about the stereotype that every Asian has to be good at math.
Lol, yes I can. If someone frankly believes that I'm somehow lying about my height even when its an objective fact or that they think I'm good at math just because of my race then they're an idiot.
I'm the one whos trying to act enlighted? Just look at your arrogant and haughty post where you think you know what my beliefs are without even asking me.
FYI I would say there is no average depiction of an American, as its one of the most diverse countries in the world
.
Short compared to the average height of British men obviously considering it's British men who are going to hold this attitude to be true (you're British right?). Indonesian men will have the streotype that Chinese men are tall.
It depends. If someone told me that they're 6'5 on the internet, I wouldn't believe them. Same with having a 13" dick. It can be true but chances are it isn't. You can't blame people for being skeptical. They don't know it's a objective fact. I don't think anyone would doubt someone who says they're **** at maths though.
There you go again being pedantic. What's a human being? Someone with 2 arms and 2 legs? OMG what about phocomelia? Someone with 46 chromosomes? OMG what about those with chromosome abnormalities? -
Re: Stereotypes
There's a lot of stereotypes some are bad however some give negative imageslike if your Indian you eat curry 24/7, if your from Somalia you're a pirate,if you're from Kenya/Ethiopia you should be a marathon runner. Rarely there are a few positive ones like if your from Greece you should be some sort of Spartan warrior
-
Re: StereotypesWell seeing as you mostly skipped over my first paragraph I'm not going to repeat it, just that I'm talking about the stereotype which all Chinese/Asians must be short.(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
Defined by wikipedia as a popular belief regarding some individuals.
Short compared to the average height of British men obviously considering it's British men who are going to hold this attitude to be true (you're British right?). Indonesian men will have the streotype that Chinese men are tall.
It depends. If someone told me that they're 6'5 on the internet, I wouldn't believe them. Same with having a 13" dick. It can be true but chances are it isn't. You can't blame people for being skeptical. They don't know it's a objective fact. I don't think anyone would doubt someone who says they're **** at maths though.
There you go again being pedantic. What's a human being? Someone with 2 arms and 2 legs? OMG what about phocomelia? Someone with 46 chromosomes? OMG what about those with chromosome abnormalities?
Yes its entirely okay to be sceptical when a man of Chinese descent says they're 6'1" which is well within the standard height range, way too implausible
, I'm not talking even about telling someone on the internet, I'm talking about real life. Regardless I don't care whether you believe me or not, I just said it to back up my point. Where did I even mention 6'5"?
Nice reductio ad ridiculums as well.Last edited by Aaron_xyz; 08-05-2012 at 02:45. Reason: grammar -
Re: StereotypesThe stereotype that says you're very attractive if you're Scandinavian or Brazilian.(Original post by GrowingNinja)
Rarely there are a few positive ones like if your from Greece you should be some sort of Spartan warrior
Last edited by No Man; 07-05-2012 at 19:25. -
Re: Stereotypesthe 13 inch dick though fair enough(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
Defined by wikipedia as a popular belief regarding some individuals.
Short compared to the average height of British men obviously considering it's British men who are going to hold this attitude to be true (you're British right?). Indonesian men will have the streotype that Chinese men are tall.
It depends. If someone told me that they're 6'5 on the internet, why? I know plenty of people taller than this
I wouldn't believe them. Same with having a 13" dick. It can be true but chances are it isn't. You can't blame people for being skeptical. They don't know it's a objective fact. I don't think anyone would doubt someone who says they're **** at maths though.
There you go again being pedantic. What's a human being? Someone with 2 arms and 2 legs? OMG what about phocomelia? Someone with 46 chromosomes? OMG what about those with chromosome abnormalities?
-
Re: StereotypesI fit most except from being ginger(Original post by Nick100)
I fit far too many Scottish stereotypes. -
Re: StereotypesThere's no such thing. No one thinks that. Stereotypes talk about the average, generalised member of a group and never claim to accurately represt every member of the group.(Original post by Aaron_xyz)
I'm talking about the stereotype that every Chinese/East Asian is short.
.
I wouldn't believe them. Same with having a 13" dick. It can be true but chances are it isn't. You can't blame people for being skeptical. They don't know it's a objective fact. I don't think anyone would doubt someone who says they're **** at maths though.