(Original post by Mohamad_Muslim)
This is in reply to this Question
No, I would not get angry, for Allah (swt) Has commanded muslims not to react in such a way through the Qur'an and the Hadith.
Not the point, but many did as the example outlined. Other example, South Park/Mohhammed incident - if it was Jesus there would be nothing.
No, I would not kill anyone, for the same reasons above.
Good on you then
No, Islam is not immoral in backwards.
The majority of people no probably, I know many 'moral' muslims if that makes sense, but there's no denying some parts of the Quran/the religion, which a lot of people don't follow but some do, are backwards
No the english version of the Qur'an is not considered the Qur'an in Islam by Scholars.
No, the English language can not translate the meaning of verses of the Qur'an because of how complicated the Arabic language is, so it'd need whole sentences to describe one word so they use the closest word that changes the meaning of the verse entirely.
Yes it can and no it doesn't, other holy books are translated just fine. Irrelevant argument. And if it isn't considered why do people on TSR quote it to rebut people?
1. Murder is Haram/forbidden, Killing is murder unless it's an act of self-defense and only If you HAD TO defend yourself by killing the other person.
Agreed, murder is wrong.
This includes war, Women and Children are never to be killed unless it's a war and they are fighting, in that case you may defend yourself.
Again, I agree
War is never allowed unless it is to free an oppressed people (Black Slavery for instance) or to reclaim a land stolen from you (A.K.A Palestine)
and even so, None are to be killed, Islam is not to be forced on anyone.
Fair play, but as will all religions there are a lot of people who force it upon, and there are some who want 'Islam/Sharia domination.
All religions have their freedom of worship and practice all the way to having their own laws when dealing with Stealing/murder/rape etc
No, there is no such thing is moderate Islam/muslim No, The Qur'an does not need to be changed, and Islam is what brought Europe out of the Dark ages.
Some evidence for this outrageous claim.
And they adapted from our laws, and they took our technology, we gave them maths, Science, Search "Muslim Spain Dark Ages Europe" On Google
and you will understand how much you owe to Islam.
I owe ****e to Islam, and no you did not give Maths, Science etc. Some evidence would be nice though for your outrageous claim.
Muslims are constantly oppressed in foreign countries since the removal of the Caliphate.
Give over you're not oppressed, you're allowed to practice your religion. If anything others are oppressed in muslim countries like Saudi.
The Reason many cults move to propaganda and lies in order to sour the face of Muslims and Islam is because everything Islam supports and believes is against their own belief's.
Such as the Illuminati, Free masons etc.
They exist, they even make games (Dragon age Origins, and Dragon age 2) Bioware, Rihanna (or pretty much every rapper/ Hip hop Singer) that exists.
What the **** are you on about?
Your fools to believe that we as human beings are better in judgement then God/Allah (Subhana wa tala)
Is there any proof for this God though? You said Islam doesn't impose itself yet you're imposing to me that a diety I don't believe in is better than anyone else.
and the proof of this is the dark ages of Europe.
and even more hitler.
Their leaders and most of their people thought their actions were morally correct.
Irrelevant, move on.
Removal of the influence of Religion has not changed that. Because there can be only one Religion from God 100% clear of Man's Influence.
That means that you can not judge Islam under the same setting as Christianity.
Which has countless times been proven to be influenced by man, flawed.
Why can they not be compared? And you say there is only one religion, wouldn't that most likely be the 1st religion? Whatever it was.
and Contradicting to Science/Reality.
Then they Judge Islam under the same grounds.
What are you on about.
Using loose Translations, not studying for more then a mouth (It takes at least 5 years to memorize and then learn tafswir which means "Meaning" of each and every verse"
No-one is going to spend 5 years to make a judgement that when a book says kill the infidels that is wrong.
Tafswir is not given with opinion, the Prophet explained the verses (May peace be upon him) and when they came/sent down the meaning from word to word gives a different understanding then what you would get from just reading it and taking a confused translated understanding without knowing anything about what muslims believe the meaning of these verses are, what is the accurate Arabic meaning and How Muslims judge meaning of verses.
That being said, No non-muslim who has not had an equal Education to a scholar can denounce or even say anything about Islam because obviously he/she probably never even knew what "Tafswir" was or the difference between Arabic and English and thus why Allah ruled that The Qur'an is only in Arabic and no translated book can be considered the Qur'an.
Yes, someone who is a non-scholar can denounce it.
"This book without any doubt, is a Guidance for those who Al-muttqin [the pious and righteous persons who fear Allah much (abstain from all kinds of sins and evil deeds which He has forbidden)" Surah 2 verse 1
See? it took a whole sentence to describe one word.
The whole dictionary is a book that uses sentences to describe one word, its how definitions are formed. Move on
Where in a straight translation it would be translated to (who are Conscious of Allah)
That translation doesn't give the word justice because it does not give it it's proper meaning.
Yet non-muslims who take a few days to study Islam base all their understanding on this, afterwhich they quit and go everywhere they find Muslims and insult them and quote these verses when they don't even know what they mean!
Thus, we call the Non-Muslims on Youtube Ignorant/Arrogant Bigots.
There. I got that off my chest.
All I get from this is some unfounded incoherent ramblings, you're trying to show Islam is not what is shown on the media, all you've shown is you're an idiot. Move on.