Religion based purely on morality
Discuss the merits and deficiencies of political theories and philosophical questions.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
-
Re: Religion based purely on moralityAlmost just less abstract. But right on the lines of a religion without a creator or central deity figure.(Original post by justanotherposter)
Do you mean something similar to Buddhism, where there is no belief in God (although if a Buddhist chose to believe in a God, I don't think there would be much objection,) but at the same time the religion member's all share the same ideals and ways of life? -
Re: Religion based purely on morality
I don't think that would be a religion, what you said sounds more like a group of people abiding by the law.
re·li·gion/riˈlijən/
Noun:
1) The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God or gods.
2) Details of belief as taught or discussed. -
Re: Religion based purely on moralityAre you suggesting morality and law are the same thing???(Original post by LightninLew)
I don't think that would be a religion, what you said sounds more like a group of people abiding by the law.
re·li·gion/riˈlijən/
Noun:
1) The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God or gods.
2) Details of belief as taught or discussed.
-
Re: Religion based purely on morality
The closest thing we have in the Western world is Judaism. The religion does not require its adherents to believe in any supernatural event to be a good person - it merely asks that Jews adhere to a set of moral laws. A Jewish man who shuns spiritualism but who follows the law to the detail is still a morally good person according to the Jewish religion.
-
Re: Religion based purely on morality
Morality and religion are separate things.
You can have one without the other so why try to combine them?
Religion just means a belief in a deity or deities, its got nothing to do with morality. The only reason why most religions have a morality component is it allows those who are part of a religious organisation such as a priest to exercise increased social control over its followers.Last edited by Maker; 03-06-2012 at 08:21. -
Re: Religion based purely on morality
I can understand where OP is coming from in the fact that religions teach moral codes but these moral codes often don't make sense like Christianity says you shouldn't punish people who have done wrong or kill but yet God kills everyone in the flood because they have been evil.
Last edited by Dalek1099; 09-06-2012 at 12:59. -
Re: Religion based purely on morality
I used to be a Christian but I came to believe that the Bible wasn't a particularly good source for moral guidance, since its teachings could often be contradictory (or obviously incompatible with 21st century conceptions of moral behaviour), so last year I started attempting to establish an ethical system that I can put to practical use day-to-day for myself. I wouldn't exactly call it a religion, but it would function similarly.
I care about whether or not I'm living morally, so I hope that this system works for me. I also have a collection of 13 guidelines I use that help to direct me and remind me about the things I value. I believe that how I live is important, and so far making these things, or at least considering the questions about how I should live, have helped me to become a more conscientious person. -
Re: Religion based purely on moralityBuddhism has a very rich spiritual component.(Original post by justanotherposter)
Do you mean something similar to Buddhism, where there is no belief in God (although if a Buddhist chose to believe in a God, I don't think there would be much objection,) but at the same time the religion member's all share the same ideals and ways of life? -
Re: Religion based purely on moralityChristianity never says you should punish people. In fact, its teachings are of love and forgiveness. And there's not even ground for saying it's contradictory on that :"You have heard that it was said, 'Eye for eye, and tooth for tooth. But I tell you, Do not resist an evil person. If someone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also”, and etc.(Original post by Dalek1099)
I can understand where OP is coming from in the fact that religions teach moral codes but these moral codes often don't make sense like Christianity says you should punish people who have done wrong or kill but yet God kills everyone in the flood because they have been evil. -
Re: Religion based purely on moralityThat's not correct because even though he is a good man he is not Jewish because of that!(Original post by Rhadamanthus)
The closest thing we have in the Western world is Judaism. The religion does not require its adherents to believe in any supernatural event to be a good person - it merely asks that Jews adhere to a set of moral laws. A Jewish man who shuns spiritualism but who follows the law to the detail is still a morally good person according to the Jewish religion. -
Re: Religion based purely on morality
Morality and religion are not the same thing. We don't get our morality from religion, we get it from society and the shifting moral Zeitgeist.
If morality came from God, then surely all the barabaric practices once thought acceptable behaviour that the human race have carried out in the name of various gods throughout history would still be acceptable today. Just look at some of the stuff laid down in the holy books of many religions. Surely God doesn't suddenly come and tell people after a certain time that there is a new way to behave and to ignore what he said before?
In the early 19th century, you could pay to go into Bedlam hospital to laugh and stare at the freaks they had in there, and no one thought that this was unnaceptable behaviour.
Morality comes from the society that we live in, and we adhere to because of the fear of being cast out from that society. As I have just demonstrated, correct rules of behaviour change over time.Last edited by marcusfox; 08-06-2012 at 13:07. -
Re: Religion based purely on morality
You can't just ignore spirituality because you don't wish to comprehend it or can't just yet, it exists no matter what you do and religion is part of it.
And religions are moral if the people within it are moral, remember that.Last edited by blueray; 08-06-2012 at 13:14. -
Re: Religion based purely on moralityIt rejects the authority of religious dogma, not all spirituality.(Original post by JollyGreenAtheist)
Sounds a tad like secular humanism? It's a loose moral code, but rejects spirituality of any form.