If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?

Discuss religious, spiritual, and theological issues concerning Christianity, Judaism, Islam, or any other religion.

Announcements Posted on
Ask me ANYTHING - Andrew O'Neill - Buzzcocks comedian, amateur occultist, vegan... 22-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. Indian_Princess's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 727
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    well those who suffer in this world are more likely to get rewarded in the next.. the Prophet (pbuh) said that when he looked into paradise he saw that the majority were poor people.. so at the end of the day everyone will come to justice as God is Most Just.
  2. A Perfect Circle's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,042
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by Cake Faced Kid.)
    x
    God placed those contradictions in the Bible intentionally to create this beautiful pattern.

    It's further proof of intelligent design you see.
  3. someonesomewherexx's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 485
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    To test the faith of believers.

    Surely God must realise that in testing the faith of believers, unbelievers suffer along with them despite the fact they've got no faith in him (earthquakes, floods e.t.c). But he's God so he can do whatever he pleases :rolleyes:

    This has being going around facebook for a while now.It's something like:

    If you're going through a difficult time, remember that a teacher stays silent during a class test..
  4. LightofTruth7's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 20
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by RandZul'Zorander)
    That doesn't answer my question. How is it then that those who suffer all their lives and go to heaven get justice if those who lived a life of luxury and never suffered go to heaven as well?


    This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
    Sin seperates us from God

    God wants to save all of us

    He sometimes makes us suffer - To bring us closer to Him

    We can't tell, just by looking at someones lifestyle - Whether they are suffering or not

    We can't see into each others Hearts - Only Jesus can do that
  5. EonBlueApocalypse's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,228
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    The answer the you want is in the question that you state.
  6. concubine's Avatar
    • TSR Idol
    • Location: Udvada
    • Posts: 8,799
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by LightofTruth7)
    Sin seperates us from God

    God wants to save all of us

    He sometimes makes us suffer - To bring us closer to Him

    We can't tell, just by looking at someones lifestyle - Whether they are suffering or not

    We can't see into each others Hearts - Only Jesus can do that



    I hate that people believe this nonsense.



    If you believe in him, and believe that he's all powerful, he obviously doesn't want to save us. So he's a dick. Make up your ****ing mind.


    Either he's great and can do whatever he wants, or he's not. And if he's not, why worship him?
  7. Leon Trotsky's Avatar
    • TSR Idol
    • Location: Cheshire
    • Posts: 9,316
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    The argument that there's evil because we have free will is a bad way to counter the argument that if there's a God then he's evil. If God is omnipotent and can do literally anything, why can't he grant us free will and freedom from suffering?
  8. RandZul'Zorander's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 3,207
    (Original post by LightofTruth7)
    Sin seperates us from God

    God wants to save all of us

    He sometimes makes us suffer - To bring us closer to Him

    We can't tell, just by looking at someones lifestyle - Whether they are suffering or not

    We can't see into each others Hearts - Only Jesus can do that
    I see so god wants to save all of us but doesn't mind us suffering which can be said to be objectively bad. Right that makes sense

    I wasn't talking about lifestyle. I clarified luxury in this instance to mean someone who had never suffered.

    Now both this person and the one who suffered their entire life can get to heaven. Explain the justice in that and why that is ok.


    This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
    Last edited by RandZul'Zorander; 03-06-2012 at 14:21.
  9. Dominic101's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 332
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    lol some people need to do gcse r.e
  10. Cake Faced Kid.'s Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Location: S. Wales
    • Posts: 1,063
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by A Perfect Circle)
    God placed those contradictions in the Bible intentionally to create this beautiful pattern.

    It's further proof of intelligent design you see.
    Intelligent? They just seem like silly mistakes, not 'intelligent design.

    For example:

    3- Genesis 2:3 "God got tired so had a rest in the seventh day"
    Isahah 40:28 "God never get tired or sick"

    8- Exodus 33:11 "Moses talked to God, face to face"
    Exodus 33:20 "God told Moses that he can never see his face"

    9- Genesis 46-21 "Binyamin's sons were 10"
    Day's news 1-7:6 " Binyamin's sons were 3"
    Day's news 1:8:1-2 "Binyamin sons were 5"

    17- Double 3:14 "Ja'eir was the son of Manse"
    Days news 2:22 "Ja'eir was the son of Sejoub"

    Intelligent :rolleyes: In my opinion, it just proves that the bible was written by different people who did not know each other. Good story tellers, told by word of mouth, spread around and eventually written down.

    I just don't see how people can place so much faith in something of which they have no proof.

    And besides, the Bible is outdated, surpisingly enough.

    Eg, look at Leviticus, chapter 20
    If we are going to follow what God/the author says, we are supposed to kill everyone who has cursed his father or mother, everyone who has committed adultery, and every homosexual.
    You may argue that this is the old part, the old testament, which doesn't really apply. Are you saying that God, the all knowing, once wanted us to kill every adulterer and homosexual, but then changed his mind? That somehow makes it better?

    You may then want to turn to Exodus, chapter 21.
    I'm not going to write the whole thing down, you can look it up yourself, but it openly advocates the use of slaves, and states that you are free to beat slaves. How incredibly loving and fair of your God.

    I could go on, but i won't, as I have made my point.
  11. shyamshah's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,809
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by Dominic101)
    lol some people need to do gcse r.e
    I did GCSE RS but we didn't learn about this.
  12. LightofTruth7's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 20
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by Indian_Princess)
    well those who suffer in this world are more likely to get rewarded in the next.. the Prophet (pbuh) said that when he looked into paradise he saw that the majority were poor people.. so at the end of the day everyone will come to justice as God is Most Just.

    According to the Quran - Paradise will be full of beautiful, fair young virgins, ready to satisfy the rampant sexual desires of muslim men.

    What's in it for the Women?

    The teachings of Islam are Satans seduction, aimed specifically at MANS weak nature

    WAKE UP tO THE TRUTH
  13. A Perfect Circle's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,042
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by Cake Faced Kid.)
    Intelligent? They just seem like silly mistakes, not 'intelligent design.

    For example:

    3- Genesis 2:3 "God got tired so had a rest in the seventh day"
    Isahah 40:28 "God never get tired or sick"

    8- Exodus 33:11 "Moses talked to God, face to face"
    Exodus 33:20 "God told Moses that he can never see his face"

    9- Genesis 46-21 "Binyamin's sons were 10"
    Day's news 1-7:6 " Binyamin's sons were 3"
    Day's news 1:8:1-2 "Binyamin sons were 5"

    17- Double 3:14 "Ja'eir was the son of Manse"
    Days news 2:22 "Ja'eir was the son of Sejoub"

    Intelligent :rolleyes: In my opinion, it just proves that the bible was written by different people who did not know each other. Good story tellers, told by word of mouth, spread around and eventually written down.

    I just don't see how people can place so much faith in something of which they have no proof.

    And besides, the Bible is outdated, surpisingly enough.

    Eg, look at Leviticus, chapter 20
    If we are going to follow what God/the author says, we are supposed to kill everyone who has cursed his father or mother, everyone who has committed adultery, and every homosexual.
    You may argue that this is the old part, the old testament, which doesn't really apply. Are you saying that God, the all knowing, once wanted us to kill every adulterer and homosexual, but then changed his mind? That somehow makes it better?

    You may then want to turn to Exodus, chapter 21.
    I'm not going to write the whole thing down, you can look it up yourself, but it openly advocates the use of slaves, and states that you are free to beat slaves. How incredibly loving and fair of your God.

    I could go on, but i won't, as I have made my point.
    lol I'm an atheist dear - we're in agreement.

    My fault for attempting sarcasm on the internet to be fair. I feel both guilty and impressed at the lengths you went to in your response

    (Original post by rocco94)
    I'm sorry but the (endless) contradictions in the bible prove one thing: It is NOT the word of God - how can such a glorified and exalted being fall prone to such weakness? The answer is he doesn't he is above all weakness thus proving that the Bible is not the word of God.
    Muahaha another victim of my poor sarcasm
    Last edited by A Perfect Circle; 03-06-2012 at 15:16.
  14. Miss Trololol's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Location: Damavand Peak
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    If God really does exist then I don't like him at all. He's got a lot to answer for.
  15. Indian_Princess's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 727
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by LightofTruth7)
    According to the Quran - Paradise will be full of beautiful, fair young virgins, ready to satisfy the rampant sexual desires of muslim men.

    What's in it for the Women?

    The teachings of Islam are Satans seduction, aimed specifically at MANS weak nature

    WAKE UP tO THE TRUTH
    what's in it for women? they can get whatever they desire in heaven.. so there's a lot in it for women.
  16. E.Blackadder's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Location: Australia
    • Posts: 334
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    why i don't like these kinds of questions is because they are only asking for fictional answers. if the bible is internally consistent you might get an answer to the question, however the answer means nothing.

    if you read harry potter and then asked "if magic is real why aren't the good magicians using it to fix the worlds problems?" now there might be an answer to that question, but does it really mean magic exists? it only exists within the fictional universe of the book.

    even if you manage to get a believer to admit god allows evil to happen, it doesn't negate the existence of god. so you will always end back at square one.
  17. LightofTruth7's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 20
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by RandZul'Zorander)
    I see so god wants to save all of us but doesn't mind us suffering which can be said to be objectively bad. Right that makes sense

    I wasn't talking about lifestyle. I clarified luxury in this instance to mean someone who had never suffered.

    Now both this person and the one who suffered their entire life can get to heaven. Explain the justice in that and why that is ok.


    This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
    Yes - God wants to save us all and ...
    He doesn't mind us suffering. For instance a loving father who is trying to teach his stubborn son how to behave correctly - Has to chastise him

    That is how our "Loving Father" chastises us - ultimately for our own good
    Because He wants us to go to Heaven

    The path to Heaven is VERY narrow. In order to get there we have to suffer many trials and tribulations ( in joy).

    I don't believe that anyone that gets to Heaven has never suffered
  18. Cake Faced Kid.'s Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Location: S. Wales
    • Posts: 1,063
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by A Perfect Circle)
    lol I'm an atheist dear - we're in agreement.

    My fault for attempting sarcasm on the internet to be fair. I feel both guilty and impressed at the lengths you went to in your response
    Haa, it's cool, religion just makes me cross :')
  19. E.Blackadder's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Location: Australia
    • Posts: 334
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    (Original post by LightofTruth7)
    Yes - God wants to save us all and ...
    He doesn't mind us suffering. For instance a loving father who is trying to teach his stubborn son how to behave correctly - Has to chastise him

    That is how our "Loving Father" chastises us - ultimately for our own good
    Because He wants us to go to Heaven

    The path to Heaven is VERY narrow. In order to get there we have to suffer many trials and tribulations ( in joy).

    I don't believe that anyone that gets to Heaven has never suffered
    yeah about that. you might want to look into the disparity of living conditions across the world. punishing black babies is corrective behaviour for rich white people how?
  20. Above.The.Empyrean's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Location: Gloucester
    • Posts: 1,220
    Re: If there is a God then why is there suffering in this world?
    You'll be notified with a plethora of irrational and illogical answers. Any topic regarding God will NEVER be answered. Logic and rhetoric for these subject-matters are only tautological and pleonastic.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.