[DawnRaider]

(Original post by Spaz Man)
Cultural, not Islamic. Islam specifically banned honour killings. Evil people will be evil regardless.

How many times do I have to write this?

what culture, german
this guy was a muslim and chopped off someones head chanting islamic phrases -

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by prog2djent)
Hmmm, wonder why this "culture", happens in a lot of Islamic countries, seen as a culture is strictly confined to boarders of countries and regions?

To give you all more insight to this story in germany - what happened was this guy had other wifes) and other children as allowed under islamic law
This wife in germany was getting uset he was having sex with other wives/mistresses and confronted him, and during the arugment he cut her head off screaming "allu akbar"

So yes, nothing to do with islam then

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by SaharaDesert)
Someone has already posted this here

And if you had actually read the article without getting excited by the fact it had the word "Muslim" in it, then you would have noticed that it states the man was mentally ill.

My post is comporaing the stories form othersides of the world, where the same thing happende and the guy wasnt 'mentally ill' but the guy was also muslim and did exactly the same thing - so now your going to tell me that is coincidence now...

also i mad e this post aklong time ago but it was delayed appearing

[Novis]

These are both insane men. They killed their wives because they thought they could and they thought they had some sort of power over them. I hope both murders are bought to justice.

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by Georgiina_Tee)
Its kind of awkward to comment when the first article isn't in English

yeh , i used it becuase it was the first source article about the crime in germany

its in english here
-
http://www.thelocal.de/society/20120604-42931.html

[xXxiKillxXx]

(Original post by DawnRaider)
what culture, german
this guy was a muslim and chopped off someones head chanting islamic phrases -

http://www.wtsp.com/news/article/258...en-he-attacked

This dude was carrying a bible^ comment on his religion and criminal acts please.

Also he can't have been a good Muslim if he drank alcohol?

End of argument

[rawkus]

(Original post by DawnRaider)
what culture, german
this guy was a muslim and chopped off someones head chanting islamic phrases -

If I chop off someone's head and then chant "Come on you magpies", does that mean Newcastle FC is responsible, or does it mean im just ****ed up in the head?

[Dentistry:)]

(Original post by alex5455)
i would take you more seriously if you could spell op.
Basically youre another of these islam haters and because a mentally ill person shouted an islamic phrase you blame muslims well done sir well done.

perfectly said!

[Spaz Man]

(Original post by DawnRaider)
what culture, german
this guy was a muslim and chopped off someones head chanting islamic phrases -

Which so called "Islamic phrases" was he chanting?

[Perseveranze]

You spelled "killing" wrong.

This has no roots in religion (or honour for that matter?), and it's stated that the person had mental problems.

[Politricks]

I don't think this incident had much to do with religion, his chants were probably incidental.
I just read about a story where a cannibal was carrying a Bible, I doubt the Bible had anything to do with what he did.

[Rat_Bag]

(Original post by Perseveranze)
You spelled "killing" wrong.

People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. Your spelling and grammar is not without error.

(Original post by Perseveranze)
This has no roots in religion (or honour for that matter?), and it's stated that the person had mental problems.

This is what I wrote for another poster, but it is equally appropriate for you.

"It is true, that the current narrative is that he was mentally ill (though remember the same was said about Brevik and the July 6th London suicide bombers, when in fact they turned out to be sane; they were not mad, just bad).

However, even if he was mentally ill, you cannot necessarily detach Islam from the course of events. Mental illness, and in this man's case it was probably acute psychosis (schizophrenia), causes a detachment from reality. However, how this manifests depends on the pre-morbid personality (i.e how the person was before the onset of psychosis). Religion and other supernatural beliefs, especially religions like Islam and Christianity, nurture strong notions of paranoia, self-righteousness, and crusading zeal. While there isn't evidence that religion causes schizophrenia, it is true that pre-existing religious beliefs often become dominant in a psychotic episode, and this man may not have acted in the way that he did were it not for his Islamic upbringing."

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by Perseveranze)
You spelled "killing" wrong.

This has no roots in religion (or honour for that matter?), and it's stated that the person had mental problems.

Are you american?, we say 'spelt' outside america

The person in the 2nd article who mimicked the same islamic beheading on the otherside of the world had no mental problems.

and we are still awaiting any confirmation that the first guy had actual mental problems

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by Spaz Man)
Which so called "Islamic phrases" was he chanting?

allu hakbar

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by rawkus)
If I chop off someone's head and then chant "Come on you magpies", does that mean Newcastle FC is responsible, or does it mean im just ****ed up in the head?

Did anyone ever actually do that?

IN islam there is much precsedent for the chopping off of heads. Is there at Newcastle FC?

[rawkus]

(Original post by DawnRaider)
Did anyone ever actually do that?

IN islam there is much precsedent for the chopping off of heads. Is there at Newcastle FC?

criticising analogy illustrating your faulty logic with very superficial, if existent at at all, knowledge of the Islamic religion = fail

[Perseveranze]

(Original post by DawnRaider)
Are you american?, we say 'spelt' outside america

Well it can be "spelt" as "spelled", shocking isn't it.

(Original post by DawnRaider)
The person in the 2nd article who mimicked the same islamic beheading on the otherside of the world had no mental problems.

Well, that doesn't mean he was following scripture.

(Original post by DawnRaider)
and we are still awaiting any confirmation that the first guy had actual mental problems

I'm sure it will "never be confirmed" for you lol.

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by rawkus)
criticising analogy illustrating your faulty logic with very superficial, if existent at at all, knowledge of the Islamic religion = fail

good way of typing a lot of words without answering the question

[DawnRaider]

(Original post by Perseveranze)
Well it can be "spelt" as "spelled", shocking isn't it.



Well, that doesn't mean he was following scripture.



I'm sure it will "never be confirmed" for you lol.

Well it was "confirmed for you, wasnt it? Even though no doctor has released a medical review yet....