Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?
Discuss issues that have a social and cultural impact, including but not limited to issues such as racism, teenage pregnancies, the social impact of religion, and the state of the education system.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| TSR launches Learn Together! - Our new subscription to help improve your learning | 16-05-2013 | |
-
- Reputation:
- Thread Starter
- Exalted and Worshipped Member
- Posts: 979
Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?I have just downloaded the HMRC app on my Iphone and it shows that I am paying £1150 a year on welfare, and £600 a year on the NHS. This doesn't even include the rest of the tax that I am paying on my salary. Those figures make me feel physically sick as they are both things for which I do not give two hoots, yet I am having all of that money stopped out of my salary without having a say in the matter. I would not even mind as much if I could, for example, stop paying welfare and the NHS, and have it all go towards defence (I currently pay £200 a year in taxes for that). When I think that the government are just wasting £1750 a year on something that I do not want to contribute towards, it makes me upset. Should I be able to choose how my taxes are spent?
-
- Reputation:
- Full Member
- Posts: 115
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?No. What's the point of that? Lets say that many people want to invest more in defense than healthcare. How is that a good thing? Sure we have a stronger military but we wouldn't need it and thus would be all for show and kinda useless and reduce standards of healthcare. You need to even it out based on priority and health and welfare are a priority, defense not so much considering we aren't at risk of getting attacked. It's like me Robin Hood taking money from the rich then instead of giving it to the poor asks them what they want to spend it on? What the ****? Why take the money in the first place?
-
- Reputation:
- Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
- Posts: 3,561
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?The money evens out in the end probably as other people would want more of their money to go on welfare and the NHS and less on defence.
Plus, your money goes into a big pot like everyone elses, so if you actually tracked every pound you give in taxes, it probably doesn't work out like that, but that's just an average/ the proportions of x amount of money.
And have you considered how much money it would cost to make sure that the taxes from each individual go to where they want? The admin costs would be stupid. And like I said, it gets evened out and if you vote for a political party that wants to lower NHS and welfare funding and raise defence budgets, then go ahead my friend. -
- Reputation:
- Banned
- Posts: 814
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?That's like saying, we should rule ourselves, no need for governments or Prime Ministers to make decisions. Although it's not like they make good ones anyway so I really don't know where i'm going with this one
-
- Reputation:
- Banned
- Posts: 814
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?If it was up to rich money hoggers they wouldnt even pay taxes(Original post by TheLastOfUs)
I think we should. I don't care about lazy people who live off benefits so I don't want to give them my taxes.
come to think of it they evade them anyway so it wouldnt be much different
-
- Reputation:
- Exalted and Worshipped Member
- Location: Newcastle
- Posts: 939
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?what exactly do you think welfare is?(Original post by TheLastOfUs)
I think we should. I don't care about lazy people who live off benefits so I don't want to give them my taxes. -
- Reputation:
- Benevolent Member
- Location: Brighton and Hove
- Posts: 794
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?No, we have a representative democracy for 2 reasons:
1) Convenience.
2) The average person does not understand these things as well as the politicians do.
The first is neither here nor there, the second is the one that we're interested in.
If we were able to effectively vote to see who got more funding, it's obvious that some parts would be overfunded and some underfunded. I'd be surprised if MPs wages remained at even half their levels if we all got to choose who got what.
The chancellor of the exchequer (should) know more about this than the rest of us, be able to see the whole picture and make an informed decision.Last edited by A.J10; 06-06-2012 at 21:31. -
- Reputation:
- Banned
- Location: Nottingham
- Posts: 1,288
- Warning points: 15
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?yawn another otkem screw the poor mememememememe right wing nonsense thread. just because you are rich enough to pay privately doesnt mean everyone else is, try growing a sense of compassion or empathy money isnt the be all and end all
-
- Reputation:
- Overlord in Training
- Posts: 2,741
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?So it makes it OK for the state to take it? People earn money and I think it's acceptable for them to retain it.(Original post by alex5455)
yawn another otkem screw the poor mememememememe right wing nonsense thread. just because you are rich enough to pay privately doesnt mean everyone else is, try growing a sense of compassion or empathy money isnt the be all and end all
Abolish taxes.
-
- Reputation:
- Banned
- Location: Nottingham
- Posts: 1,288
- Warning points: 15
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?oh be quiet, just because you want to see us go back to victorian times, rich mill owners living the life and millions of poor people suffering and dying(Original post by Iron Lady)
So it makes it OK for the state to take it? People earn money and I think it's acceptable for them to retain it.
Abolish taxes.
-
- Reputation:
- Overlord in Training
- Posts: 2,741
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?Hardly. How DARE you speak to me in such a manner.(Original post by alex5455)
oh be quiet, just because you want to see us go back to victorian times, rich mill owners living the life and millions of poor people suffering and dying
I just want hard work to be rewarded, and laziness to be corrected.
That would be fair.
Rather than reckless spending and the impact taxation has on freedom. -
- Reputation:
- Exalted and Worshipped Member
- Posts: 1,199
Re: Should we have more of a say in how our taxes are spent?If the average person in this country were less of a moron then it might be a good idea.
Unfortunately Britain is mostly populated by greedy, selfish, childlike muppets who can only see an argument from their side.
What kind of person would actually have their username as 'The Iron Lady'? Thatcher was a c.unt and I'll be having a party when the witch is finally dead.
I actually laughed when I read the part about wanting hard work to be rewarded. I assume you would do things like abolish the minimum wage and allow employees to be sacked at will?
If all benefits were stopped tomorrow it would be interesting to see how long people like you would last.
and then the government should heavily subsidise it 
.
