[Snagprophet]

(Original post by tibbles209)
It is unfortunate when anyone dies

It's is, in fact, fortunate when problems are removed from society permanently.

[Rossagle]

I don't think the man should be punished. Hmm. so you see someone sexually abusing your 4 year old daughter, you're not just going to stand there and watch!
Like he said, he didn't realise the man would die, but even so for what he did he deserved it anyway.

Plus, although the little girl is traumatised and angry that it happened, she's probably grateful that her father stopped the sick man.

One could even argue that if this man were to be punished or put in prison it could even argue that sexual abuse is ok!! (since he would be being punished for stopping it).

[Alexandra's Box]

Who cares of the ****ing paedo dies? He deserves it a million times over.
I have a sister aged 4 and the thought is ****ing sickening.

[Kennedy7697]

Unless the victim was a horse,then the man should not be jailed for the murder.

[KlaireDelilah]

(Original post by Kennedy7697)
Unless the victim was a horse,then the man should not be jailed for the murder.

what?

[whyumadtho]

(Original post by Shabalala)
jesus wept a fair trial there is no need when you find someone with their dick inside a 4 year old little girl that's enough evidence and that guy lost all his human rights as soon as he started raping her.

The father is obviousley going to say that to give himself the best possible chance of escaping punishment if he starts saying he is glad he killed him then there is more chance of him being prosecuted and facing a potential jail sentence which would have made the impact even worse on his daughter.

'Sexual assault' doesn't necessarily mean penetrative sex. The way the girl was described—"OK besides the obvious mental trauma"—suggests it was molestation as opposed to physical penetration.

[james22]

What does "several times on the head" mean? If it was just a few times, like 5 or 6, or however many were needed to incapacitate him then dair play to him. If it means hit him until he was unconcious then repeatedly hit him untill he died the man should be prosecuted (for manslaughter given the circumstances). Naturally though it would have to be proven that he deliberatly went to far which is impossible without a confession.

[manchesterunited15]

(Original post by FrogInABog)
the guy didn't deserve to die like that, without a fair trial.

[Snagprophet]

The awkward moment where some morons tells this father to hang his head in shame for causing physical damage to his fellow man. I thought the liberals were quite fine when someone dies as long as the killer is treated fine, so yeah. Give this man a medal.

[Heavenly_Blues]

I'm not going to celebrate the death of a human being, but at the same time I wont pretend it's that much of a loss, really. Shame about the child's loss of innocence though, being sexually assaulted and then watching your dad beat a man to death.

[miser]

If he didn't mean to kill the man then I believe he should be released (and from the looks of it it looks like he will). I can't say I agree with OP's fervour that the man deserved death though, which even with people's views on child abuse seems extreme.

[CherryCherryBoomBoom]

What a sad, sad story . I guess it's good that the molester got "punished", even if it wasn't in the most lawful way, but I still feel sorry for the dad and the daughter having gone through all that trauma on top of the sexual assault. I really hope they both get all the help and support needed to deal with this.

[EatRainbows]

I don't think it was the fathers fault, he probably didn't realise what he was doing. If you walked in on someone molesting your 4 year old daughter you would go mental and try to protect your child as best you can. You wouldn't be able to think straight with rage.
I think it would have been better if he didn't die, his life would have been hell in prison, even prisoners hate child molesters. Dying is a cop out.

[chapman.]

This is why I envy America's law system. They respect individual rights much more than the UK. If I did that I'd pay a fine and be sent down for manslaughter over here!

[Existentialistic]

(Original post by chapman.)
This is why I envy America's law system.

Yeah, their barbaric ideas of justice are really worthy of envy.

[FrogInABog]

(Original post by Roaroaroar)


You don't need a trial to tell you that a guy is guilty of molesting you're daughter. This isn't a second-hand account, you can literally see the guy molesting your daughter. That father is a better man than me 'cause I would not be sorry one bit about killing a sick mother****a like that.

(Original post by Shabalala)
jesus wept a fair trial there is no need when you find someone with their dick inside a 4 year old little girl that's enough evidence and that guy lost all his human rights as soon as he started raping her.

The father is obviousley going to say that to give himself the best possible chance of escaping punishment if he starts saying he is glad he killed him then there is more chance of him being prosecuted and facing a potential jail sentence which would have made the impact even worse on his daughter.

(Original post by manchesterunited15)

I'm sorry, what?!

I can't believe that I'm reading people in the (supposedly) civilised world arguing against the system of no punishment without trial! His certain guilt is irrelevant; every man and woman should be allowed to have their punishment decided by an impartial court, it's one of the most basic rights in law that a human can posses. I'm all for self-defence, don't get me wrong, and the father is not guilty of any crime in my book. Nonetheless, it's disturbing to read people saying things along the lines of "I'm glad the sick **** died".

I never want to live in a country where people believe that the lynch-mob is better than a judge and jury.

[chapman.]

(Original post by Existentialistic)
Yeah, their barbaric ideas of justice are really worthy of envy.

You're either one of those Islamic types who despises America, or against capital punishment. I have no argument if you're against capital punishment, it's an opinion.

[Alexx53]

Wow. What is wrong with some people? I hope they let the guy off.

[Roaroaroar]

(Original post by FrogInABog)
I'm sorry, what?!

I can't believe that I'm reading people in the (supposedly) civilised world arguing against the system of no punishment without trial! His certain guilt is irrelevant; every man and woman should be allowed to have their punishment decided by an impartial court, it's one of the most basic rights in law that a human can posses. I'm all for self-defence, don't get me wrong, and the father is not guilty of any crime in my book. Nonetheless, it's disturbing to read people saying things along the lines of "I'm glad the sick **** died".

I never want to live in a country where people believe that the lynch-mob is better than a judge and jury.

Why wouldn't I be glad he died? You might want to go live on this utopia land outside of earth because our view is a reflection of society's general view. Ask pretty much anyone how they would feel about Hitler dieing than see their reaction. They don't want to see him tried in the ICC no one gives a ****, they'd rather he died if they had a choice. There is no society that won't rejoice in the death of a sick mother****a. Guaranteed safety from him + no paying for prison fees.

[EonBlueApocalypse]

To be honest I would of meant to kill the guy, not accidentally killed him.