What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
Discuss issues related to the politics of the UK, such as the actions of any MP, any current or potential law, or any other factor affecting the British political system.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
-
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?The wider public at the moment might not be that bothered about tuition fees, but in the future the wider public will be those "layabout students", the ones who he made a promise to abolish tuition fees to, then trebled them. That is going to hang over his head for the rest of his political career and beyond it.(Original post by L i b)
We're all sitting here pretending that tuition fees make a difference to the wider population. They don't. If anything, most of them want them to rise and to stop funding layabout students. I remember him saying before the election that far-left supporters would have to leave the Lib Dems eventually and that their assumption they could fit in with a Liberal party just because they were annoyed with Labour was nonsense.
I genuinely like him and I think he brings something useful to the coalition government. He's also far more reasonable and rational than the likes of Vince Cable. I hope the public come to judge him on his accomplishments rather than some silly notion that the Lib Dems were left-wing and would never go into coalition with the Tories.
What accomplishments? Failing to get any real liberal priorities passed? Enabling the tories to destroy the healthcare system and kill people while doing it? Enabling the tories to pass the most anti-liberal bill I have ever seen in this country (communications bill if it passes)?
That is what he will be remembered for by a lot of people, enabling Cameron and the tuition fees. -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
Never one to shrink from raising the literary tone, I offer this:
http://drmatthewashton.com/2011/05/1...e-lost-leader/ -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
I don't really think he'll be remembered very much at all. There have been approximately 71 prime ministers in British history, I doubt most people could name more than seven. Viscount Goderich, anyone? The second marquess of Rockingham? He hasn't done that much, really. We live monumentous times, what with Islamist terrorism, global warming, the shift of power from the West to the East, the digital revolution. But I don't really think Nick Clegg is particularly, erm, involved with anything in that regard. He'll get his name in a few textbooks of politicial history, sure, but I don't think that there will be much more than that.
-
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
As a member of the generation who first experienced the 9000 pound tuition fee prices, I certainly won't forget the broken promise made by Clegg about the tuition fees. Even though some argue its better because we won't pay as much back ect ect, its just the principal of what he did. It was the breakdown of trust between young students who were not even old enough to vote, being back stabbed by someone they believed was on their side. Him and his party will always represent broken trust for me, and I will find it extremely difficult to ever vote for them in the future. At the moment, I'd rather not vote than vote for the Liberal Democrats.
-
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
How he will be remembered will be entirely dependent on Lib Dem performance at the next election, the long-term effects (if any) of the tuition fee rise, how bad the Conservatives seem in comparison and how successful his Lib Dem leader-successor will be. I belive in virtually all of these categories he will actually be held in fairly high esteem, once the hate over fees dies down and people relise he would've liked to stop it but as a minority leader he had to acceed to Conservative pressure. He has also held back some far-right lunatic policies of the Tories and I think quietly done a pretty good job. Too bad he made one too many promises pre-election...
-
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
'The Great Betrayer'
And more importantly, the fact that he thinks that 'constitutional reform' is top of the agenda for all the electorate, whilst letting more important liberal policies be swept under the rug in the coalition compromise.Last edited by Cheese_Monster; 17-06-2012 at 17:18. -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
He'll be remembered by his actions; shamelessly selling out on his principles and promises for a taste of power in an attempt to capatalise on the gains he made for his party by being a very good politician and having the ear of the public.
He made promises, broke them and sent popular support for the Liberal Democrats back to neglible levels. In the months following the UK General Election, Scotland held its elections for parliament and punished the Liberal Democrats severely - to the extent that Tavish Scott was fired from his post as Lib Dem leader. I can't help but shake the feeling that they fired the wrong leader, there.
It's a shame, because the Liberal Democrats had a number of good policies and, had they stuck to their pre-election campaign promises, could have campaigned for some serious good to come about in the country. Now they're just a sad party that jumps up and down every now promising that while the Tory government is doing horrible things to the people, it would be so much worse if they weren't there to temper the policies going through.
So no, I don't think history will remember Nick Clegg very well. And I think his political career will essentially be over following this parliament. -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
I too agree that he will be viewed as the man who didn't keep his tuition fee's promise, purely because it's something people will remember, and students especially will have a hard time forgetting.
On a side note, I think they will crash and burn in the next general election -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
I'll make a prediction: History will say he was forced to take very difficult decisions (such as the tuition fees) but in the end he was redeemed.
I personally don't think the Liberal Democrats are going to collapse in 2015. If Labour continue as they are I think the Lib-Dems could probably take quite a few seats off them for the simple reason that they, unlike Labour, actually have a message and can talk about policies they've been able to influence. -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?Shamefull ignorance! Rockingham was brilliant!(Original post by geetar)
I don't really think he'll be remembered very much at all. There have been approximately 71 prime ministers in British history, I doubt most people could name more than seven. Viscount Goderich, anyone? The second marquess of Rockingham? He hasn't done that much, really. We live monumentous times, what with Islamist terrorism, global warming, the shift of power from the West to the East, the digital revolution. But I don't really think Nick Clegg is particularly, erm, involved with anything in that regard. He'll get his name in a few textbooks of politicial history, sure, but I don't think that there will be much more than that.
But seriously, this is far and away the best reponse to this thread. -
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?
He'll be remembered as the last leader of the dying Liberal Democrats, who drove his mish-mashed, shambles of a party into the ground - never to return to political credibility.
If he at least had some backbone, and tried to get some serious policies implemented. -
- Reputation:
- Community Assistant
- Wiki Support Team
- Secretary General of the Model UN
- Location: Leicester
- Posts: 5,302
Re: What do you think history will make of Nick Clegg?Spot on.(Original post by Stanley Baldwin)
I personally don't think the Liberal Democrats are going to collapse in 2015. If Labour continue as they are I think the Lib-Dems could probably take quite a few seats off them for the simple reason that they, unlike Labour, actually have a message and can talk about policies they've been able to influence.
