Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme

Physics exam discussion - share revision tips in preparation for GCSE, A Level and other physics exams and discuss how they went afterwards.

Announcements Posted on
Ask me ANYTHING - Andrew O'Neill - Buzzcocks comedian, amateur occultist, vegan... 22-05-2013
IMPORTANT: You must wait until midnight (morning exams)/4.30AM (afternoon exams) to discuss Edexcel exams and until 1pm/6pm the following day for STEP and IB exams. Please read before posting, including for rules for practical and oral exams. 28-04-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. stunnaman's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 141
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by teachercol)
    as i said
    guess I just have to live on hope. hated that A0 questions i used the right forumula and i said the osicllation of sand grane shud be in phase with osciallation of metal plate (also said it shud follow a smh ).
    then i used the sam forumula but i didnt put 9.81 for accelaraton becuz stupid me had to try find the acceleration using the forumula. would i get any marks?
  2. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    You may get some credit - but how much I just dont know. It comes down to exactly what you wrote and whether it hits any marks on the mark scheme.
  3. SJS101's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 318
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Teachercol, i know you have said that we have to wait for the grade boundaries but based on previous years grade boundaries do you think i will get an A*? Your opinion will be very much appreciated.

    I got 39/40 on the coursework
    Think i got 90/100 on G485
    Think i got 52/60 on G484


    tHANKSSS
    Last edited by SJS101; 19-06-2012 at 14:29.
  4. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    IF you indeed get those marks then you shoudl get an A*.

    But as I've written before

    you may not get 59/60 for your coursework. All marks are moderated. Some centres get pulled down a lot. Trust me. But some dont.

    90/100 on G485 will always score very highly and be close to 150 UMS.

    52/60 ? Dont know.

    Many of my students in Jan - and there are some pretty good ones - thought they'd only dropped 7/8 marks - but ended up with B's . The grade boundaries were brutal and the marking was nit-picking.

    Most students dont realise how tough the marking is. If its isnt exaclty right, it doesnt get the mark is the norm. if they cant quite read it, they wont. If it can be interprested wrongly, they do. The exact wording counts.
  5. SJS101's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 318
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by teachercol)
    IF you indeed get those marks then you shoudl get an A*.

    But as I've written before

    you may not get 59/60 for your coursework. All marks are moderated. Some centres get pulled down a lot. Trust me. But some dont.

    90/100 on G485 will always score very highly and be close to 150 UMS.

    52/60 ? Dont know.

    Many of my students in Jan - and there are some pretty good ones - thought they'd only dropped 7/8 marks - but ended up with B's . The grade boundaries were brutal and the marking was nit-picking.

    Most students dont realise how tough the marking is. If its isnt exaclty right, it doesnt get the mark is the norm. if they cant quite read it, they wont. If it can be interprested wrongly, they do. The exact wording counts.

    I appreciate that, as i did the Newtonian World exam in Jan aswell.

    I got 48/60 raw marks and that was because they were nit-picking indeed.

    Internal energy - i wrote in the system instead of in the atoms/molecules... did not get the mark

    Pressure - I did not have the world MANY before collisions... did not get the mark

    Pressure - I wrote momentum of the molecule after colliding with the wall is -2mv... did not get the mark (NBOD)

    and lots moreeee :/

    Also by giving myself 52/60 was being extremelly picky, there is no way i got under 51 for example.

    Anywayz thanks
  6. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Thanks for your comments. I got about a dozen of my students papers back and went through them. Their experience was much like yours - several didnt write many and didnt get the mark.

    There was v little if any BOD.
  7. Small123's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: Nowhere Posts: 24
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Reckon I got 51/60 minimum - any rough ideas on that UMS? I'm well aware it's nothing other than speculation
  8. Holby_fanatic's Avatar
    • The most beautiful squashed slug you've ever seen
    • Location: York
    • Posts: 2,492
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Around 50/60 marks according to your mark scheme! Much improved from the U in January I think!

    Thank you for posting your mark scheme, Teachercol. It is much appreciated.
  9. Mathlete 4 the win's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 178
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    I still can't believe I plotted F against v^2 wrong. I seem to have got the more challenging questions right and then just spooned all the easier ones. The swines
  10. ash356's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 75
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by teachercol)

    Q1 a) Accelerates in direction of net force/ changes velocity / changes momentum (1)
    b) i) Impulse = change in momentum (1)
    ii) Area under graph = impulse = change in momentum = mvf - mvi
    vi = 0 so vf = area / m (2)
    c) i) Mean force = change in momentum per unti time
    = mvf/t = 0.058 x 52/4.2E-3 = 7.18E2 N (2)
    ii) If momentum is conserved
    change in momentum of racket = - change in momentum of ball
    m(38-32) = 0.058 x 52 so m = 0.50 kg (2)
    I did it totally different
    I couldn't manage it using that method for some reason, so I stated Newtons third law (Stuck it in the extra space at the end), calculated how much the velocity changed in the time period given to get acceleration, and then used F=Ma to find the mass. Used the force as equal to the one given in ci due to the aforementioned third law.
    Radically different method, which makes me think I did it totally wrong, but I still got 0.5kg
  11. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Comes to the same thing. (thats where the conservation of momentum comes from!)
  12. ash356's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 75
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by teachercol)
    Comes to the same thing. (thats where the conservation of momentum comes from!)
    Oh, thank heavens for that! :P
    Thought I was waffling on about something totally irrelevant when doing it
    Thanks!
  13. Namod's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 274
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by teachercol)

    Q4 a) i) Shc = energy needed to raise temp of unit mass of substance by unit temp
    (note they stopped marking 1kg and 1K correct last year)
    ii) Fusion - heat needed to convert solid to liquid at melting point
    Vaporisation - heat needed to convert liquid to gas at boiling point (1)
    b) i) A to B KE increasing because temp is increasing
    (+ some small Increae in PE because most substabces expand when heated)
    B to C Temp is constant so Ke constant
    PE increases as bonds melt + substabce melts (2)
    ii) 4 x smaller since it takes 4 x less time for same increase in temp
    ie same temp rise needs 4x less energy (2)
    C) i) P = W/t = m/t x c x dT = (3.6E-3)/60 x 1000 x 4200 x (36.7-17.4)
    = 4.86kW which is approx 5kW (4)
    ii) Usual stuff - some heat lost to surrounding / heats up pipes etc
    so P will need to be higher than calculated. (2)
    Total 12
    if some heat is lost than energy will be less so power will be less? :rolleyes:
    Last edited by Namod; 10-01-2013 at 23:13.
  14. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Actually the question asks about RELIABILITY not accuracy so my answer here wasnt right.

    The examiners expect you to write about why if you did the experiment again you might not ge the same answers.

    eg - water pressure might change so that the flow rate changes.
  15. saltnpepper's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 15
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Thanks for putting the effort to make this MS
    Just a few mistakes I spotted. Never define impulse as the change in momentum, they don't accept it. You're expected to recall that it is the change in momentum. The definition is the 'Force x time in which the force acts/duration of collision'.
    4)a)i) is right, but they also accept c=Q/m x (delta t), with all symbols defined.
    Am I allowed to upload the MS? I have it but I haven't got the paper. Anyone got the paper?
  16. saltnpepper's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 15
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Actually, I found the paper, someone uploaded it:
    https://skydrive.live.com/?cid=518db...F043877A%21199
    MS:
    Attached Files
  17. File Type: pdf Unit 4 - Jun 12 markscheme.pdf (197.5 KB, 68 views)
  18. teachercol's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Scarborough
    • Posts: 3,868
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    (Original post by saltnpepper)
    Thanks for putting the effort to make this MS
    Just a few mistakes I spotted. Never define impulse as the change in momentum, they don't accept it. You're expected to recall that it is the change in momentum. The definition is the 'Force x time in which the force acts/duration of collision'.
    4)a)i) is right, but they also accept c=Q/m x (delta t), with all symbols defined.
    Am I allowed to upload the MS? I have it but I haven't got the paper. Anyone got the paper?
    Quite right - they used to accept change of momentum for impulse - they dont any more.

    You can use equation to define shc no prob.

    Its Ok to upload mark scheme and paper now.
  19. Davidbazzy's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 107
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    Anybody have the grade boundaries for this paper?
  20. ginister's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Location: Saddleworth
    • Posts: 285
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    When do you use pv=nrt and when pv=nkt?
  21. RobW1995's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 1
    Re: Physics A G484 Newtonian World 18/6/12 My answers and mark scheme
    is there any plans to make an unofficial mark scheme for Newtonian world 16/1/13? if so when will it be up?
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.