Favourite historian?
Discuss issues related to past events, people, places, or old empires and civilisations.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera | 21-05-2013 | |
-
Re: Favourite historian?
I've always found the enthusiasm of Neil Oliver very infectious, although I don't know if he technically qualifies. The preferred authors I can think of off the top of my head are Ian Mortimer and Else Roesdahl, I love their books! Tout is quite good fun too, I found a 1929 edition of his "Advanced History of Great Britain" which I'm enjoying at the moment.
-
Re: Favourite historian?Ah he's good- I had to use his two massive volumes of Hitler's biography for my coursework this year, and it was very easy to get along with(Original post by King Kebab)
I like Ian Kershaws work on Hitler and the Third Reich. Very accomplished historian.
-
Re: Favourite historian?Yeah but nemesis is DENSE! I needed serious will power to get through that.(Original post by King Kebab)
I like Ian Kershaws work on Hitler and the Third Reich. Very accomplished historian.
<3 x -
Re: Favourite historian?I was going to say him. His book on the Russian Revolution (A People's Tragedy) is quite something. On the other hand, he claims to use all these letters/personal stories within it without actually referencing them (maybe just academic snob?) and it has recently come out that his translations leave a lot to be desired, and some are merely fictitious in other books, primarily The Whisperers. As a story and basic facts it's very well written, but his real historical undertakings in primary sources is dubious.(Original post by Historophilia)
He appears to have gone off his trolley but some of my favourite books are by Orlando Figes. -
Re: Favourite historian?
I really don't like David Starkey - I find his manner rude, and his books are mediocre at best.

I really like Helen Rappaport, Simon Sebag Montefiore (who I've met - charming man!) and some Niall Ferguson (although, his attempt to say imperialism was justified because those colonies wouldn't have reached modernity without European influences, is hard to swallow and verging on racist. His Pity of War book is interesting though). -
Re: Favourite historian?I really enjoyed Montefiore's book on Stalin's court. He also has the coolest name of any historian I have come across.(Original post by Historiana)
I really don't like David Starkey - I find his manner rude, and his books are mediocre at best.
I really like Helen Rappaport, Simon Sebag Montefiore (who I've met - charming man!) and some Niall Ferguson (although, his attempt to say imperialism was justified because those colonies wouldn't have reached modernity without European influences, is hard to swallow and verging on racist. His Pity of War book is interesting though).
Detlev Peukert and Marc Bloch are undoubtedly the two most influential historians I have read. Thinking about it, Peukert's Weimar Republic is probably one of the most important books I have ever read. -
Re: Favourite historian?
Recently, I enjoyed Helen Castor's book on England's medieval queens. After that, for modern history, I find Richard Evans, John Lewis Gaddis, Martin Gilbert, and Saul Friedlander's works interesting.
I'm primarily an early modernist though, and I love Eamon Duffy, John Morrill, Tim Harris, Diarmaid MacCulloch, and Christopher Hill's (to name but a few!) works.Last edited by gutenberg; 04-07-2012 at 19:28.
I find him a little patronising, and his books I find tend to skimp on detail. I do quite like Maurice Keen and Christopher Dyer though- the both write really well and make quite good bed time reading!