Favourite historian?

Discuss issues related to past events, people, places, or old empires and civilisations.

Announcements Posted on
Sign in to Reply
  1. evantej's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Northumberland
    • Posts: 5,032
    Re: Favourite historian?
    I like Carl Becker and Roy Porter (Enlightenment), Linda Colley and Niall Ferguson (imperialism), and Marc Raeff and Franco Venturi (nineteenth-century Russia). The latter's work on Populism has never been surpassed.

    Eric Hobsbawm is just brilliant.
  2. meenu89's Avatar
    • I vow to thee my country....
    • Location: Leamington Spa/ Cheylesmore
    • Posts: 8,931
    Re: Favourite historian?
    David Starkey.
  3. evantej's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Northumberland
    • Posts: 5,032
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by foxes-are-ginger)
    Ronald Hutton's work is just brilliant. He just knows... everything [...]
    He is very odd mind! I did my masters degree at Bristol and spoke to him when he was giving a presentation on 'innovation in the arts'. I liked his honesty.
  4. foxes-are-ginger's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by evantej)
    He is very odd mind! I did my masters degree at Bristol and spoke to him when he was giving a presentation on 'innovation in the arts'. I liked his honesty.
    You only have to look at his velvet suits and hair to know he's a bit of an eccentric!
  5. SebCross's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Oxford
    • Posts: 771
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by meenu89)
    David Starkey.
    Though he does seem to have slightly disturbing, old-fashioned things to say about women...Still, his biographies of Elizabeth I (Elizabeth: Apprenticeship)and Henry VIII are fantastic.
  6. Vapour-Trail's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 11
    Re: Favourite historian?
    neil oliver
    Last edited by Vapour-Trail; 31-07-2012 at 18:53.
  7. Pensivedore's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,889
    Re: Favourite historian?
    Thucydides. We probably wouldn't a lot about the Peloponnesian war if it wasn't for him. Slight problem with the whole re-writing speeches thing, obviously.
  8. twinlensreflex's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: Edinburgh
    • Posts: 1,454
    Re: Favourite historian?
    Am I allowed to say Andrew Marr for amusement value? Watching him run in the sea in a woollen bathing suit really helped me remember about the BUF for my exam
  9. blueconstellation's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 144
    Re: Favourite historian?
    Niall Ferguson (imperialism)
    Ooh, yes, I've been watching his Ascent of Money.
  10. SebCross's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Oxford
    • Posts: 771
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by blueconstellation)
    Ooh, yes, I've been watching his Ascent of Money.
    @blueconstellation: Have you read the book? It's a fabulous study of the history of the financial world, particularly for someone (like myself, for instance) that lacks a background in economics.
  11. blueconstellation's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 144
    Re: Favourite historian?
    Have you read the book? It's a fabulous study of the history of the financial world, particularly for someone (like myself, for instance) that lacks a background in economics.
    No, but it looks good. I might have a look after I've done my reading for my personal statement at the moment (for economic history )
  12. SebCross's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Oxford
    • Posts: 771
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by blueconstellation)
    No, but it looks good. I might have a look after I've done my reading for my personal statement at the moment (for economic history )
    Nice. Is it specifically for an economic history course, then? That'd be pretty cool, though I'm surprised universities would specialise in terms of the kinds of histories they make available in undergraduate degrees so early. Still, I guess plenty of places offer Economic & Social History degrees alongside straight History degrees; indeed, my own institution (the University of Oxford) offers an Ancient & Modern History course as well as 'History' and the various Joint Honour degrees. So I suppose greater specialisation is kind of inevitable as universities seek to offer more distinctive courses to attract better quality applicants.
  13. calum66222's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Location: Scotland
    • Posts: 16
    Re: Favourite historian?
    I quite like reading the books of both Max Hastings and Dee Brown. Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee is essential reading for everyone!
    Last edited by calum66222; 14-08-2012 at 21:23.
  14. The Lyceum's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Posts: 4,949
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by calum66222)
    I quite like reading the boobs of both Max Hastings and Dee Brown. Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee is essential reading for everyone!
    As a Classical Scholar and Ancient Historian I very much can say that "reading" boobs is indeed essential.


    I'd like to add Moses Finley to the list since judging by previous entries (Sarkey, Gibbon, Holland etc) we're going for readably rather than actual academic weight, which is fair enough. Otherwise...probably Bosworth or Latacz tbh.
  15. calum66222's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Location: Scotland
    • Posts: 16
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by The Lyceum)
    As a Classical Scholar and Ancient Historian I very much can say that "reading" boobs is indeed essential.

    I have amended my error good sir, thank you for pointing it out.
  16. richiemayne's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 159
    Re: Favourite historian?
    (Original post by Hewitt)
    Neil Ferguson - He talk's a lot of sense.
    While Ferguson is easy to read and packs a lot of information into his books, I find them to lack the depth that makes me feel like I've been greatly informed on various topics. In Empire for example, he manages to go through the entire history of the British Empire in little under 400 pages in a medium sized font on small pages. Some of his arguments are also very weak and give me the impression that he's doing nothing more than trying to provoke a debate. For instance, in War of the World, he argues that the fact that the stock markets were booming right up until the July crisis in 1914 shows that there was literally no political tensions leading up the war.

    Also, one gets the impression that when Ferguson is writing about Empire and western civilisation, he is writing not to explain to the reader what happened in the past, but to further his own political cause in the present, i.e. to encourage the USA to take a more proactive role in building its own empire. He is often one sided - opening Empire by explaining very simplistic and obviously moronic arguments against the view that the British Empire was good in order to imply that anyone who holds such a view is an idiot, ignoring all of the more sophisticated arguments against his own view.

    In spite of his obvious intelligence, he also strikes me as very ignorant. He said in an interview with regards to the history of native American tribes that all we know is that 'they killed a hell of a lot of bison', and not a lot more, the implication being that their society is not worth studying and is certainly something that is inferior to the European culture that replaced it.
  17. DSWood's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 8
    Re: Favourite historian?
    Hobsbawm and AJP Taylor rank highly for me, and Simon Schama is often fun to listen to.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.