Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?
Discuss issues that have a social and cultural impact, including but not limited to issues such as racism, teenage pregnancies, the social impact of religion, and the state of the education system.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera | 21-05-2013 | |
-
View Poll Results: Do you agree with the following
I feel comfortable around anyone who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 167 86.98% I wouldn't feel comfortable around anyone who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 10 5.21% I would feel comfortable around a Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual Close Friend 73 38.02% I would not feel comfortable around a Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual Close Friend 9 4.69% I would feel comfortable around a close relative who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 66 34.38% I would not feel comfortable around a close relative who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 9 4.69% I would feel comfortable around a brother/sister who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 65 33.85% I would not feel comfortable around a brother/sister who is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 11 5.73% I would feel comfortable knowing my child is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 59 30.73% I would not feel comfortable knowing my child is Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual 23 11.98%
-
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?
Everything apart from the trans part. But then again I've never met a transvestite, or at least not realised I have so who knows?
Also the layout of the options kind of leads you too believe that just the first option suffices for your entire stance hence the large disparity in answers. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?I'm a tolerant, I didn't say I was. I'm not emotionally uncomfortable with trans people because I'm desperate to fit in the norm, I'm emotionally uncomfortable with trans people because they're out of the norm. There reasons for being out of the norm, as sad as it may be, are irrelevant to my emotionally comfortableness around them which I don't have control over. It's not like those bleach their faces, do it for the lulz, they do it because they have some psychological issues and some sort of racial dysphoria.(Original post by fallen_acorns)
right now, in many parts of the country, yes they would both be considered equaly wierd...
but that is by people who are largely un-aware of trans* issues...
if you are aware of the reasons why people are trans... and the agony, pain and often death, it can cause...
and then you still consider them 'wierd' and wouldnt hang aroudn with one because they are 'out of the norm'
then that says quite a bit about your priorties... and how you are more desperate to fit in with the norm, rather than be tolerant to a group of people who often have a very hard time in life... -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?Transsexual =/= Transvestite.(Original post by mucgoo)
Everything apart from the trans part. But then again I've never met a transvestite, or at least not realised I have so who knows?
Also the layout of the options kind of leads you too believe that just the first option suffices for your entire stance hence the large disparity in answers. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?Transvestite = Identifying as the sex you were born in but wearing clothes considering typical of the opposite sex.(Original post by mucgoo)
Everything apart from the trans part. But then again I've never met a transvestite, or at least not realised I have so who knows?
Also the layout of the options kind of leads you too believe that just the first option suffices for your entire stance hence the large disparity in answers.
Transsexual = Identifying differently to your birth sex.Last edited by Annoying-Mouse; 29-06-2012 at 19:00. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?dw, im not blaming you.. its not peoples individual fault that they find trans* people wierd/not normal etc... after all theyve lived 20 or so years in a society which will tell them this every day/use transwoman as a source of comedy, etc...(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
I'm a tolerant, I didn't say I was. I'm not emotionally uncomfortable with trans people because I'm desperate to fit in the norm, I'm emotionally uncomfortable with trans people because they're out of the norm. There reasons for being out of the norm, as sad as it may be, are irrelevant to my emotionally comfortableness around them which I don't have control over. It's not like those bleach their faces, do it for the lulz, they do it because they have some psychological issues and some sort of racial dysphoria.
however all i hope is that slowly more and more people realise that just because something isnt in the norm... that isnt a reason to be uncomfortable around them, and as that happens, ofcourse the norm will change
(+ the deabte about racial dysphoria/transethnicity etc.. is quite a large one, and not really for this thread... but neadless to say, i dont believe its the same as transgenderism, but thats for another time) -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?but this friend wouldnt change? they would still be the person you knew before - so why be uncomfortable?(Original post by ROYP)
I can't imagine I'd feel comfortable around a close friend/relative that was gay. And no, not because I'm scared they might bum me in the night. Just my initial reaction is no I wouldn't feel comfortable. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?I can't really rationalise it, I'd just feel like they were a different person.(Original post by fallen_acorns)
but this friend wouldnt change? they would still be the person you knew before - so why be uncomfortable? -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?That's not the reason because I find people people with many genetic disorders weird. It's nothing to do with society. It's just the very act of changing a part which typically isn't changed e.g. color of skin, height etc. Weird/not-normal aren't prejotive terms they merely describe when someone isn't typical. We're all atypical in one way or another. If I go to a part of England that's 99.9% white then I'd be not normal/weird (if they haven't been exposed to other black people).(Original post by fallen_acorns)
dw, im not blaming you.. its not peoples individual fault that they find trans* people wierd/not normal etc... after all theyve lived 20 or so years in a society which will tell them this every day/use transwoman as a source of comedy, etc...
It's more to do with the fact that humans aren't typically comfortable with abnormality, regardless of whether that abnormality is based on gender, race, height etc. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?There is a diference, however, between acknowledging and understanding that something isnt normal/is abnormal, (as all trans people will acknowledge (unless severly deluded) that they are not the norm).. and then how you treat them, knowing this. yes trans* isnt typical, however that is no reason not to treat them as you woudl treat a typical person...(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
That's not the reason because I find people people with many genetic disorders weird. It's nothing to do with society. It's just the very act of changing a part which typically isn't changed e.g. color of skin, height etc. Weird/not-normal aren't prejotive terms they merely describe when someone isn't typical. We're all atypical in one way or another. If I go to a part of England that's 99.9% white then I'd be not normal/weird (if they haven't been exposed to other black people).
It's more to do with the fact that humans aren't typically comfortable with abnormality, regardless of whether that abnormality is based on gender, race, height etc. -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?No doubt. You should treat people the same i.e. with respect. However, people should recognize that some people aren't emotionally comfortable with some people and there's nothing wrong with this as long as the person is treated with respect.(Original post by fallen_acorns)
There is a diference, however, between acknowledging and understanding that something isnt normal/is abnormal, (as all trans people will acknowledge (unless severly deluded) that they are not the norm).. and then how you treat them, knowing this. yes trans* isnt typical, however that is no reason not to treat them as you woudl treat a typical person... -
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?yes,(Original post by Annoying-Mouse)
No doubt. You should treat people the same i.e. with respect. However, people should recognize that some people aren't emotionally comfortable with some people and there's nothing wrong with this as long as the person is treated with respect.
and this is basically how it stands with LGB people these days, quite a number of people arent comfortable with the idea, but still treat them with respect... hopefully one day it will be the same with the T
-
Re: Would you feel comfortable with a LGBT friend/relative?
I have a lesbian relative, I have a good lesbian friend and a couple of gay friends, I think both of my siblings are straight, but it wouldn't bother me if they weren't. Homosexuality is pretty prominent in modern day society, most people I know are perfectly comfortable around people of any sexuality.