Why is this allowed?
Discuss issues related to the politics of the UK, such as the actions of any MP, any current or potential law, or any other factor affecting the British political system.
| Announcements | Posted on | |
|---|---|---|
| Please change your TSR password | 23-05-2013 | |
| Enter our travel-writing competition for the chance to win a Nikon 1 J3 camera | 20-05-2013 | |
-
Re: Why is this allowed?
Because people are stupid enough to believe a political manifesto is anything like some kind of contract. It isn't.
Fact is: coalitions make manifestoes pointless. At best, coalitions are statements of intent, but in no way is it even possible to make them binding.
Imagine if they were: say, for example, if in 1987 the Tories' manifesto pledge to bring in the poll tax had been legally binding. If Parliament had turned it down, could the Tories say they can make it law anyway, because it was in the manifesto? And again, if the people opposed it (which they did), would the government be able to ignore the people, by saying they are legally bound to enforce the poll tax as it was in the manifesto? -
Re: Why is this allowed?For the same reason that the captain of a ship might be against swimming in the sea, but when someone sets the boat on fire, has a sudden change of heart.(Original post by Nullusion)
Why are parties allowed to promise things pre-election and change their mind on it after. Isn't this literally like fraud, by getting our consent for something they're going to do the complete opposite of really?
http://liberalconspiracy.org/2011/01...ot-to-cut-ema/
For example all the promises david cameron made about stuff, that hes doing the complete opposite of.
Why is this allowed? Am I not reading through the lines and looking at it black and white? Im no fan or expert in politics but what the hell is going on.
P.S. David cameron is a ****
There are lots of things people would have liked to have done in government, but sadly there is no money with which to do them. We could have kept EMA, but then we would have had to sack a load of nurses or stop repairing roads. They are having to save money where they can. EMA was riddled with fraud and abuse so it was an obvious target. -
Re: Why is this allowed?It doesn't stop people voting for them. We get the government we deserve I think.(Original post by Nullusion)
Why are parties allowed to promise things pre-election and change their mind on it after. Isn't this literally like fraud, by getting our consent for something they're going to do the complete opposite of really?
http://liberalconspiracy.org/2011/01...ot-to-cut-ema/
For example all the promises david cameron made about stuff, that hes doing the complete opposite of.
Why is this allowed? Am I not reading through the lines and looking at it black and white? Im no fan or expert in politics but what the hell is going on.
P.S. David cameron is a ****