Circumcision ban is the 'worst attack on Jews since Holocaust'

You can't abort a child. You can abort an embryo - but if you are going to go down the route of that counting because it will turn into a child, then why stop there? Why not blast anyone using contraception (artificial or otherwise) for denying the sperm and egg the chance to make a child?

Please show me a case where someone has died due to not having his foreskin removed. It doesn't seem to be a problem for the millions of other male teenagers that have one and stay clean.

Its more diffult in childhoos to clean under the foreskin though and circumscision if done properly decreases risk of non sexual infections as well.


Proper education of sexual health should lead to no problems for a child with a foreskin, as shown by the majority of healthy young males.

Circumcised men do not ahve any health problems either, infatc they tend to live longer as research shows, possibly due to lower risk of infection.



People can feel terrible when they think their penis is smaller than other lads', some children may get incredibly depressed and self conscious at a circumcised penis.

circumcision does not decrease the length of a penis, anyways we must move it on, since you are childish I will move the conversation on, it just removes the foreskin not the actual penile muscle

Would you support female circumcision, hypothetically? Let's say a religion now wants to cut parts off a baby girl's genitals, any problem? It improves hygiene after all.

Certainly not, such a procedure would increase risk of infection given the nature of the female genitals. And no it would not improve hygeine as there is no foreskin restricting any access for a thorough clean.

Stop being silly please

You can get foreskin restoration. And doctors cannot overule a jehovahs witness who does nto allowed blood transfusion for their child

Lets say it is banned in this country as well.

Well people can go abroad and get their children circumcised, they can go to any muslim country or even Israel and have it done there.

SO how will you enforce it, will you go house to house checking up on babies?

It may be harder when young to clean under the foreskin, but it's not a problem for most young males? Like I said, proper sexual health awareness should sort this, you don't need circumcision. If circumcision does so much good for genital hygiene, why don't males with a foreskin have problems?

I know circumcision doesn't affect penis length, that was an example of how problems relating to their genitalia can make lads depressed and self concious.

Also, you keep mentioning all these studies linked to health and hygiene, care to provide any? As a male, I'm interested to see the results of these studies myself. Also, I doubt foreskin restoration is provided by the NHS, or a simple procedure, so don't try and pass circumcision off as some minor alteration.

Yes, the doctor can overrule the parent. It has happened before.

sorry I apologise, I checked and you are right, but this exa,ple is useless as child circumcision if done rightly does not kill people like a refusal for child blood transfusion may

So what if they can do it in another country? You write laws for your own country. Lead by example rather than using "but they don't do it" as an excuse.

Well if people can go abroad for a couple fo days or whatever, have circumcision done and come back, well it is a pointless law then isn't it?

The fact that a restoration is possible does not make it better. Broken bones can also be fixed, should we allow parents to break babies arms?

You didnlt exactly provide any sources for your depression and self conscious claims, nor did you provide any research for males regretting their parents circumcising them.

I have google, so do you, use it please.

the similiraty is that if kids have a choice they will reject both school and circumsition
so yes i am comparing the 2

It does not seem very sensitive of the Germans after what they did to the Jews in the Shoah

A child has no say in whether he/she wants a vaccination should we stop them too because the child cannot give consent?

Again, loving the bold.

Circumcisions can and do go wrong. If they go wrong, they can cause a lot of problems (like any operation going wrong).

And why was I being erratic? I know I jumped from point to point, but that was because I was countering each of yours in turn.

You can't abort a child. You can abort an embryo - but if you are going to go down the route of that counting because it will turn into a child, then why stop there? Why not blast anyone using contraception (artificial or otherwise) for denying the sperm and egg the chance to make a child?

You are erratic becuase you are comparing breaking bones for no reason to circumcision for hygeine reasons, one causes death or major possiblility of death in babies whilst circumcison does not such thing

Why not go even further? How irresponsible is it of people to avoid having children by not having sex constantly with every fertile person they see!

http://ezinearticles.com/?Why-Many-Men-Are-Interested-In-Penis-Enlargement&id=7145257

http://brook.org.uk/my-body/boys-and-young-men/penises-and-testicles

These aren't studies but highlight the point I was making about lads being self conscious of their penis.

http://in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090124135032AA4IrY1

Again, not a study, but shows somebody who is uncomfortable with their circumcised penis.

Plus, you completely ignored my points about the lack of problems suffered by most males with a foreskin. Care to address that at any point?

Why does a broken bone constitute more of a risk to life than a cut apart penis? I also question your use of the word erratic, and I hadn't made that comparison when I asked that question.

Well if you were given the option of having the option of being properly circumcised or having your bones broken, i doubt you would choose the latter.

Well you need to read up on circumcision, it does not involve cutting the actual penis so do not persist with that line, it involves cutting the foreskin and does nto cause disbaility in any bodily function in urinating nor sex if circumcision is done properly.