Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?

Discuss health issues related to fitness, exercise, sport etc. and other relevant topics.

Announcements Posted on
TSR launches Learn Together! - Our new subscription to help improve your learning 16-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. ON A GOOD DAY's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Posts: 46
    Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    If I am training for gaining muscle and not just strength?
  2. HFerguson's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: Milton Keynes
    • Posts: 3,208
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    it is generally accepted that 8-12 reps is a better stimulus for muscular hypertrophy as opposed to neural adaptation, yes.
  3. Jonnyy's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 99
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    8-12 reps is widely recommended to stimulate hypertrophy and build muscle. If training for muscle, more focus is on the stretch and contraction of the exercise (form), which will usually require a lower weight (thus higher reps to failure) in comparison to a person training for strength, who is just trying to shift the weight.
  4. EonBlueApocalypse's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,227
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    8-12 reps is better for muscle gains. I prefer to do 1-5 rep range for the big compound lifts (bench press, deadlift, squat) and do 8-12 for more isolated exercises e.g. skullcrusher or incline chest flies. That way I get the strength benefits and the muscle growth as well.

    1-5 range builds increases the number of contractile proteins and 8-12 increases the amount of fluid the muscle cells can hold.
  5. superman17's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Posts: 32
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    If you want to improve your muscular strength, and build bulk, it's best to do heavy weights and not as many repetitions, and have the weight so your last rep - I do 6 - is almost impossible.

    If it's tone you're interested in, lower the weight a little bit and up the repetitions
  6. ChaoticMaster's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 2,000
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by ON A GOOD DAY)
    If I am training for gaining muscle and not just strength?
    You want to stimulate as many muscle fibres as you can and you want it to be deep stimulation. You want a small number of reps and you want it to be heavy. If you can lift it more than 5 times then it's too light.
  7. Shawshank's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: Cambridge
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by superman17)
    If you want to improve your muscular strength, and build bulk, it's best to do heavy weights and not as many repetitions, and have the weight so your last rep - I do 6 - is almost impossible.

    If it's tone you're interested in, lower the weight a little bit and up the repetitions
    You should listen to this guy, he really knows what he's talking about :awesome:
  8. silent ninja's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: in the shadows
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    Depends on the exercise as well. 8-12 reps squatting or deadlifting is challenging and tiring to say the least.
  9. jmlkey's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: Macclesfield, NW
    • Posts: 61
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    Personally, i tend to do 3-6 reps on the compound movements, and then 8-12 on the more isolated exercises.
    In truth, rep ranges matter very little in terms of how much mass you'll build.
  10. commandant's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    I'd argue that time under tension and mind muscle connection are more important to consider
  11. major_mishap's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Posts: 90
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    If you're living heavy weights, 5/6 reps is perfect, i'd argue if you can do 8/10 reps with little effort you can lift heavier.
    For mass/strength, 5/6 reps
    For muscular endurance, 8/10 reps

    Also, like what has already been said, it's much harder to do 8/10 reps in one set of a heavy compound movement, like a deadlift, I only do 5 of them with strict form.
  12. The_Blade's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 270
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    gaining muscle is gaining strength though and vice versa?
  13. sachinisgod's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 923
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    i think its all about progression. Say for bicep curls, when i started i did 10 reps with 10kgs dumbells. Now i can do 6 reps with the 16kg. As you get used to heavier weights gradually decrease the reps to stretch yourself to the point where u cant do another rep. thats your max point.
  14. blueray's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: United States of Nippon
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    You can all try and get steroid induced muscles, but you can't utilise it for ****.
    I did a press up comp against a guy who has huge arms, compared to my lean ones, and I owned him. Real USEFUL muscles are much better.

    brb_gone_gym
    and commandant

    Are 2 examples of the above who can't utilise their muscles.
    Last edited by blueray; 18-07-2012 at 14:16.
  15. ON A GOOD DAY's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Posts: 46
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    never found press ups useful though
  16. commandant's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    what a stupid post blueray
  17. blueray's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: United States of Nippon
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by commandant)
    what a stupid post blueray
    How is stupid. Go on explain. You have huge arms yet you can't use them for ****. That is stupid, not my post and until you get over that, you will never learn.
  18. blueray's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: United States of Nippon
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by ON A GOOD DAY)
    never found press ups useful though
    How long have you done them for? Build them up slowly then do loads, it takes time, doesn't happen overnight instantly and it builds overall strength.
  19. silent ninja's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: in the shadows
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by blueray)
    How long have you done them for? Build them up slowly then do loads, it takes time, doesn't happen overnight instantly and it builds overall strength.
    Doing loads of press ups simply builds your endurance. Even if you could do 100 consecutive press ups do you really think you'd bench 100kg?

    You're never gonna see a power lifter doing one arm pull ups but they still possess a hell of a lot more power and strength than say a gymnast. It's all about identifying your goals which unfortunately a lot of people aren't clear about. What you are saying is almost like comparing a Marathon runner to a sprinter. It's totally different kettle of fish.
    Last edited by silent ninja; 18-07-2012 at 14:34.
  20. blueray's Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: United States of Nippon
    Re: Is doing 5 rep per set worse than doing ~12 reps per set?
    (Original post by silent ninja)
    Doing loads of press ups simply builds your endurance. Even if you could do 100 consecutive press ups do you really think you'd bench 100kg?

    You're never gonna see a power lifter doing one arm pull ups but they still possess a hell of a lot more power and strength than say a gymnast. It's all about identifying your goals which unfortunately a lot of people aren't clear about. What you are saying is almost like comparing a Marathon runner to a sprinter. It's totally different kettle of fish.
    Tell me what is fitness? And what will you achieve from just lifting 100kg. You want to be able to apply this RAW strength.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources

Articles:

Exercise TipsNutrition Advice

Quick Link:

Unanswered Fitness Threads

Groups associated with this forum:

View associated groups
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.