Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?

Discussion about all the financial aspects of life - from bank accounts, overdrafts and budgeting to tax, savings and investments. For discussion about student loans, grants, and bursaries please use the Student Financial Support subforum.

Announcements Posted on
Please change your TSR password 23-05-2013
Sign in to Reply
  1. coopsyy's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 687
    Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    There are a lot of people here on TSR that seem to be very against benefits. They moan that their 'hard earned money' goes on taxes which goes to 'lazy ****ers' sitting around at home all day on benefits. Taxes are spent on a lot more than benefits, and not everyone on benefits is lazy.

    The main benefit people seem to think about is JSA. And they seem to assume everyone on JSA get given many other handouts, which a lot of the time isn't the case.

    These are just some of the benefits out there...
    Attendance Allowance
    Bereavement benefits
    Blue Badge Scheme
    Carer's Allowance
    Carer's assessment
    Child Benefit
    Child Tax Credit
    Community care services
    Community transport
    Concessionary Fares
    Constant Attendance Allowance
    Direct Payments
    Disability Living Allowance
    Statutory Maternity Pay
    Maternity Allowance
    Statutory Sick Pay
    Income Support
    JSA
    Housing Benefit
    War Widow's or Widower's Pension
    State Pension
    Cold Weather Payment
    ESA

    The list goes on.

    But the point of this thread is to hear your view on benefits, why you are so against them or why you are for them?

    Discuss.
  2. almosttrue's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 180
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    Child benefit should be reduced it annoys me since people shouldnt have children/be a lot more cautious if they cant afford them
  3. xoxAngel_Kxox's Avatar
    • Section Moderator
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    Nothing against people who are on benefits because they need it, which are the majority. However I have plenty against people who are on them because they're the easy option, and because they can't be bothered to get a job so therefore think that living off the state with a shed load of kids is the easy option. But it's a shame that the minority have very much tainted the reputation of the majority. Such is life, I suppose.
  4. Carrby's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 315
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    I'm only against people who are claiming benefits that they shouldn't be getting.

    EDIT: Why would anyone neg this? Who is pro unfair benefits?
    Last edited by Carrby; 19-07-2012 at 07:45.
  5. coopsyy's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 687
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by Carrby)
    I'm only against people who are claiming benefits that they shouldn't be getting.
    I agree, when someone puts in a false claim, that's wrong.

    Another thing that annoys me is when people come over from abroad and claim benefits straight away, when they haven't paid in to the system. (I know you see many extream cases in the papers, but this happens a lot more than people realise) Especially if they're from the EU, come over here for a better life. But just because they can do this doesn't mean its right.

    As long as you're a UK citizen, you need the help, then I don't see anything wrong with benefits. People in need is the reason there is a welfare state.
  6. coopsyy's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 687
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by almosttrue)
    Child benefit should be reduced it annoys me since people shouldnt have children/be a lot more cautious if they cant afford them
    I don't agree entirely, but i'm happy they've finally stopped Child Benefit being a universal benefit. As you say people should be more cautious if they can't afford them, but on the other end of the scale, why should someone earning £60,000 a year get Child benefit?
  7. RastaMannn's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 613
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    If someone generally and truthfully needs benefits, I have no problem, but for those who can work and dont need benefits, I have a problem with them
  8. poony's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Location: London, Canada Water
    • Posts: 328
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    No problem with people claiming JSA benefits as long as they don't complain that's not enough.
  9. Nickw73's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Posts: 59
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    Personally I don't think there is anything wrong with some benefits, for example Child benefits unless the person recieving the benefits starts to abuse the system by having x amount of kids. This was the case for multiple families who I used to live down the same street ith (Thankfully I moved).

    It all comes down to how they treat the system, like some who claim Job Seekers allowance and aren't actually seeking a job but rather milking the system.

    I'm not sure if I got my point across but if you use the benefit to actually benefit you rather than spend it on whatever (like spending child benefits on yourself, not your child), then there's no problem with it.
  10. coopsyy's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 687
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by poony)
    No problem with people claiming JSA benefits as long as they don't complain that's not enough.
    To be honest though, £50 (under 25) or £70 (over 25) isn't that much to survive on.
  11. Afradeetee's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 218
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by coopsyy)
    To be honest though, £50 (under 25) or £70 (over 25) isn't that much to survive on.
    No it is not :P
  12. coopsyy's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Posts: 687
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by Afradeetee)
    No it is not :P
    Thank you, someone agrees!
  13. glelin96's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 278
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by coopsyy)
    To be honest though, £50 (under 25) or £70 (over 25) isn't that much to survive on.
    Exactly! They will generally have entitlement to other benefits as well. Too right it isn't much to survive on! Why should anyone receive money that they are able to earn by getting a job and going to work?
  14. Sean9001's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 506
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by almosttrue)
    Child benefit should be reduced it annoys me since people shouldnt have children/be a lot more cautious if they cant afford them
    I completely agree that people are careless to have children when they can't afford them. I've said the same to my own parents. But don't punish the child by reducing [even more] the standard of its life, which they have involuntarily been born into.

    Currently, the legal compromise between my view and yours, is that child benefit decreases for every child after the first. That rightfully aims to deter persistent carelessness, but it is ineffective because few know of the decrease.
    Last edited by Sean9001; 20-07-2012 at 16:32.
  15. emthedrummer's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: Notts
    • Posts: 167
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    I believe EVERY parent should get child benefit, then there's absolutely NO excuse for mistreating a child.
  16. johnaulich's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 271
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by coopsyy)
    There are a lot of people here on TSR that seem to be very against benefits. They moan that their 'hard earned money' goes on taxes which goes to 'lazy ****ers' sitting around at home all day on benefits. Taxes are spent on a lot more than benefits, and not everyone on benefits is lazy.

    The main benefit people seem to think about is JSA. And they seem to assume everyone on JSA get given many other handouts, which a lot of the time isn't the case.

    These are just some of the benefits out there...
    Attendance Allowance
    Bereavement benefits
    Blue Badge Scheme
    Carer's Allowance
    Carer's assessment
    Child Benefit
    Child Tax Credit
    Community care services
    Community transport
    Concessionary Fares
    Constant Attendance Allowance
    Direct Payments
    Disability Living Allowance
    Statutory Maternity Pay
    Maternity Allowance
    Statutory Sick Pay
    Income Support
    JSA
    Housing Benefit
    War Widow's or Widower's Pension
    State Pension
    Cold Weather Payment
    ESA

    The list goes on.

    But the point of this thread is to hear your view on benefits, why you are so against them or why you are for them?

    Discuss.
    I'm for them. I think a lot of the 'benefit scroungers' stories are accentuated by the media and in most cases that isn't what's happening. Jobs aren't so easy to come by any more and that's the wholesale truth of it. Especially if you've been down on your luck for six months plus, employers are much less likely to take you on. DWP's Workfare program has been proven statistically to have no effect, mainly because they used to employ people to do the jobs they have the unemployed now doing for their benefit. I don't pay my taxes for tesco to have their shelves stacked for free.
  17. glelin96's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 278
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by emthedrummer)
    I believe EVERY parent should get child benefit, then there's absolutely NO excuse for mistreating a child.
    You could single-handedly be responsible for the bankruptcy of England. :yy:
  18. OU Student's Avatar
    • Section Moderator
    • Indie Kid
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by glelin96)
    Exactly! They will generally have entitlement to other benefits as well. Too right it isn't much to survive on! Why should anyone receive money that they are able to earn by getting a job and going to work?
    Unless you pay a stupid amount of rent, you won't get more on benefits. Some people have to use their benefits to top up their rent.

    Not everyone on benefits is able to work.
  19. glelin96's Avatar
    • Exalted Member
    • Posts: 278
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by OU Student)
    Unless you pay a stupid amount of rent, you won't get more on benefits. Some people have to use their benefits to top up their rent.

    Not everyone on benefits is able to work.
    He quoted Jobseekers Allowance, that is what I was referring to. I must admit however, the term jobseeker is one used in an extremely loose term.
  20. emthedrummer's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: Notts
    • Posts: 167
    Re: Seriously, what do you have against people on benefits?
    (Original post by glelin96)
    You could single-handedly be responsible for the bankruptcy of England. :yy:
    Sorry, yep, it's totally my fault.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.