Who would win a fight: Shearer or Keane?

Shearer. Imagine some of the balls he headed on a cold rainy evening at the dell in his early career, Keane's head is a peanut in comparison.

With keane it wasn't over till he'd crippled you in a cold blooded foul.
Just ask haland.

Evil mentalcase to finish his playing career with his legs still intact.

Big Dunc vs Keane would be a better fight.



Haaland retired because of a long term injury to his other knee, nothing to do with Keane tackle.

looks to me like keane kicked the leg that was up and free to move into the leg that was planted and therefore vulnerable. Admittedely the cameras back them didn't record the same level of footage.

3 things though.

You don't tackle someone by jumping onto their knee like that if you're bothered about ending their career or not.
2. The tackle was the result of a psycho grudge keane had been nursing for 3 years (since he tried a similar foul on haland which went wrong and busted keane's own knee up.)
3. Haland never finished another game after that foul.

Yeah, Keane went into the tackle aiming to hurt him, but there is nothing to suggest that Keane ended his career, a different injury did. After that Haaland's tackle on Keane, a much worse tackle that put Keane out for a year and lost us the title, Haaland stood over Keane mocking him, he sounds like a bit of a ****.