You are Here: Home

# C2 Question on Differentiation Tweet

Maths and statistics discussion, revision, exam and homework help.

Announcements Posted on
TSR launches Learn Together! - Our new subscription to help improve your learning 16-05-2013
IMPORTANT: You must wait until midnight (morning exams)/4.30AM (afternoon exams) to discuss Edexcel exams and until 1pm/6pm the following day for STEP and IB exams. Please read before posting, including for rules for practical and oral exams. 28-04-2013
1. C2 Question on Differentiation
Hi All,
I'm studying C2 differentiation and think I've just about cracked it, but I just can't work out the 'maximum' bit at the end.
Basis of question is that Perimeter of shape of rectangle with semicircular top is 40cm, and that area = 40r-2r^2-1/2Pir^2. I've worked it all out and have found that r =40/4+Pi.
When I now put this back into the original formula substituting r for 40/4+Pi, I get A = 40 x 40/4+Pi - 2 x (40/4+Pi)^2 - 1/2 Pi (40/4+Pi)^2. And then I can't get any further. The next bit SHOULD be A = 1600/4+Pi - (2 + 1/2 Pi) (40/4+Pi)^2, but I have no idea how you get there. I'm teaching myself A Level Maths and I think I've missed out on some basic adding and multiplication of fractions and powers. Please can someone show me the steps one by one, and advise me on what I can study further to get to grips with these formulas?
Many thanks
J
2. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
(Original post by jrowe)
Hi All,
I'm studying C2 differentiation and think I've just about cracked it, but I just can't work out the 'maximum' bit at the end.
Basis of question is that Perimeter of shape of rectangle with semicircular top is 40cm, and that area = 40r-2r^2-1/2Pir^2. I've worked it all out and have found that r =40/4+Pi.
When I now put this back into the original formula substituting r for 40/4+Pi, I get A = 40 x 40/4+Pi - 2 x (40/4+Pi)^2 - 1/2 Pi (40/4+Pi)^2. And then I can't get any further. The next bit SHOULD be A = 1600/4+Pi - (2 + 1/2 Pi) (40/4+Pi)^2, but I have no idea how you get there. I'm teaching myself A Level Maths and I think I've missed out on some basic adding and multiplication of fractions and powers. Please can someone show me the steps one by one, and advise me on what I can study further to get to grips with these formulas?
Many thanks
J
ill give you the general gist, when working a maximum. differentiate the equation and then make it equal to zero. If you have 2 solutioins differentiate the equation again to get the second derivative and plug in the solutions one at a time, if its less than zero it is a maximum. If it is more than zero it is a minimum. Hope that helps.. are you yr 11?
Last edited by Theafricanlegend; 20-07-2012 at 12:47.
3. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
(Original post by jrowe)
Hi All,
I'm studying C2 differentiation and think I've just about cracked it, but I just can't work out the 'maximum' bit at the end.
Basis of question is that Perimeter of shape of rectangle with semicircular top is 40cm, and that area = 40r-2r^2-1/2Pir^2. I've worked it all out and have found that r =40/4+Pi.
When I now put this back into the original formula substituting r for 40/4+Pi, I get A = 40 x 40/4+Pi - 2 x (40/4+Pi)^2 - 1/2 Pi (40/4+Pi)^2. And then I can't get any further. The next bit SHOULD be A = 1600/4+Pi - (2 + 1/2 Pi) (40/4+Pi)^2, but I have no idea how you get there. I'm teaching myself A Level Maths and I think I've missed out on some basic adding and multiplication of fractions and powers. Please can someone show me the steps one by one, and advise me on what I can study further to get to grips with these formulas?
Many thanks
J
Start by factoring . Also, you should simplify all the fractions.
4. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
My knowledge of some of the basics is so bad, especially when it comes to division. So (40/4+Pi) can be changed to (40/4) + Pi and still be the same equation? If so, then ((40/4) + Pi)^2 works out as Pi^2 + 20Pi + 100. Is that right?? What should the next step be?
5. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
Just looked at my last reply and have worked out that 40/(4+pi) is not the same as (40/4) + pi so please ignore last post! I think I've got some way towards an answer. I realised that the common factor of the equation is (40/(4+pi)) so the equation then becomes 40/(4+pi) [40 - 80/(4+pi) -20pi/(4+pi) ] but how do I then simplify [40 - 80/(4+pi) - 20pi/(4+pi)] ???
6. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
(Original post by jrowe)
Just looked at my last reply and have worked out that 40/(4+pi) is not the same as (40/4) + pi so please ignore last post! I think I've got some way towards an answer. I realised that the common factor of the equation is (40/(4+pi)) so the equation then becomes 40/(4+pi) [40 - 80/(4+pi) -20pi/(4+pi) ] but how do I then simplify [40 - 80/(4+pi) - 20pi/(4+pi)] ???

7. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
Ok, this is the bit I don't understand. If you have -2 x (40/(4+pi)^2 - 1/2pi x (40/(4+pi)^2 because there are two brackets the same you can then do ( -2 x - 1/2 pi ) and multiply it by one of the (40/(4+pi)^2. Can someone give me an example of this with much simpler formulas? Why can you get rid of one of the squared brackets? I can see what is happening but I can't understand why. Thank you everyone for your help, I'm starting to get there!
8. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
(Original post by jrowe)
If you have -2 x (40/(4+pi)^2 - 1/2pi x (40/(4+pi)^2 because there are two brackets the same you can then do ( -2 x - 1/2 pi ) and multiply it by one of the (40/(4+pi)^2.
Yes except for one thing: it would be a + sign where the x sign is. So (- 2 - 1/2 pi) multiplied by (40/(4 + pi))^2.

(Original post by jrowe)
Can someone give me an example of this with much simpler formulas?
It is a simple technique called factorisation. In simple terms:

Where can be anything.

You are basically transforming a sum into a product.

(Original post by jrowe)
Why can you get rid of one of the squared brackets? I can see what is happening but I can't understand why.
You are not exactly getting rid of them, you are simplifying the expression. Here's an example: say I have three apples and three oranges (mathematically: 3 apples + 3 oranges). Factoring would be to say, I have three "apples and oranges" (mathematically: 3 x (apples + oranges)). In the end, it is the same thing. But most often the second expression (the factored one) will be simpler. Clear?

Not to raise an eyebrow but I don't see how you're getting through differentiation without knowing how factorisation works...?
9. Re: C2 Question on Differentiation
Not to raise an eyebrow but I don't see how you're getting through differentiation without knowing how factorisation works...?[/QUOTE]

Hi, thank you for your reply - raising an eyebrow would be the least expression I'd expect!! I do know basically how to factorise but it doesn't come naturally to me and I sometimes find it difficult to spot the factors if that makes sense?! I think I haven't really understood how important it is to factorise and simplify to obtain an answer.
So... A = 1600/(4+Pi) - (2 + 1/2 Pi) (40/(4+Pi)^2.
A = 1600/(4+Pi) - ((4+Pi)/2) (1600/(4+Pi)^2)
A = 1600/(4+Pi) - 800/(4+Pi)
A = 800/(4+Pi) which is the right answer according to my book!!
My problem is that I don't automatically realise that I need to simplify examples such as (2 + 1/2 Pi) into ((4+Pi)/2) but I suppose it's because I need to always try and reduce down to (4+Pi) to match with the other (4+Pi) so that I can break down the equation even further. It's starting to all make sense now - I think I need to just keep on practising and practising!!! Many thanks for your patience.