The Student Room Group

Maths degree useless?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by punkski
a degree in maths is pretty ****ing useless. don't listen to the arithmeticians or whatever who try to tell you otherwise. do something with practical application and some social value, like accounting or economics. why would you study pure maths? :frown:


The thing with pure mathematics is that you may discover things that have no practical use right now. But many maths discoveries that have been made go on later to find themselves to be useful in an unexpected way. Without the discoveries made in pure mathematics literally none of our modern technologies would be possible.
Reply 21
I think anyone taking a degree in such a broad subject asks this question at some point. I do languages, people assume I want to be a teacher/translator/interpreter after university, but in honesty I really don't know. Sometimes I feel I'm wasting me time with it...
Reply 22
Original post by M2k13
Is there evidence to show this?

Original post by jordanosborn
The thing with pure mathematics is that you may discover things that have no practical use right now. But many maths discoveries that have been made go on later to find themselves to be useful in an unexpected way.
this fellow's asking for advice, and he's concerned about ending up unemployed. saving humanity with a few equations that may or may not prosper in the long run isn't what he's looking for, so i was being practical.
Original post by jordanosborn
Without the discoveries made in pure mathematics literally none of our modern technologies would be possible.
that's quite debatable tbh :rolleyes:
Reply 23
In my opinion attempting to go into the financial sector currently, is foolish. Don't get me wrong I loved studying economics, but the simple truth is that there aren't that many jobs out there what with the recession. Only the best candidates would be sure of a job- even then what's there to say there would be job security.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 24
Original post by punkski
this fellow's asking for advice, and he's concerned about ending up unemployed. saving humanity with a few equations that may or may not prosper in the long run isn't what he's looking for, so i was being practical.

that's quite debatable tbh :rolleyes:


Ye I was very concerned on the unemployed part. Wasting years of education to be unemployed isn't a good thing to have... >.<

Original post by ihatepoems
In my opinion attempting to go into the financial sector currently, is foolish. Don't get me wrong I loved studying economics, but the simple truth is that there aren't that many jobs out there what with the recession. Only the best candidates would be sure of a job- even then what's there to say there would be job security.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


You nailed the part on the recession reason...
So what degree that's math-related is best suited for me and would be easier to get a job with if the recession continues for another 4-5 years? :rolleyes:
Compared to the Maths if broad subjects dont stand out well >.>


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
(edited 11 years ago)
Reply 25
...
Original post by punkski
this fellow's asking for advice, and he's concerned about ending up unemployed. saving humanity with a few equations that may or may not prosper in the long run isn't what he's looking for, so i was being practical.
that's quite debatable tbh :rolleyes:


Pure mathematics encompasses geometry, algebra and calculus etc.

Geometry useful for building bridges, buildings almost anything. Good luck getting your bridge to stay up without some mathematics. Calculus used in physics, chemistry. Cleaning products, pharmaceuticals all developed by chemists guess what with the help of pure mathematics. Aircraft, cars all made better due to good understanding of pure mathematics. Without pure mathematics lets face it you wouldn't even be able to contact me right now.
Original post by M2k13
I'm going to apply to Uni this year and my degree choices is a nightmare.

I love Maths and wish to pursue it at degree level. But I get complaints from my family that I will not get a job besides being a teacher/lecturer, as the degree is useless and the uni's exaggerate about the job prospects for a Maths graduate.

If its actually true then should I study Accountancy or Economics?
Even though I would expect myself to do better in a Maths degree compared to an accountancy or economics degree, as i'd have more motivation.

P.S. I study double Maths and economics at A level.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


Mathematics graduates are the second highest earners after graduates of medicine.
Original post by M2k13
I'm going to apply to Uni this year and my degree choices is a nightmare.

I love Maths and wish to pursue it at degree level. But I get complaints from my family that I will not get a job besides being a teacher/lecturer, as the degree is useless and the uni's exaggerate about the job prospects for a Maths graduate.

If its actually true then should I study Accountancy or Economics?
Even though I would expect myself to do better in a Maths degree compared to an accountancy or economics degree, as i'd have more motivation.

P.S. I study double Maths and economics at A level.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


A Maths degree will lead you straight into becoming a:

Computer Programmer/Developer/Scientist
Statistician, Analyst, Actuary etc.
Engineer

Maths is absolutely loved by employers:

One person I know did maths at leeds, she worked at IBM, then became a teacher, headteacher and is now a PhD student.
Another did engineering mathematics at bristol, worked in defence, software engineering, IT and is now a senior director in the IT sector.

Original post by DonJuan
Your family is just so so wrong. The opportunity's for a maths graduate are endless, it is one of the best ways to prove your intelligence and problem solving capability to employers. Even starting at university there are tons of schemes run by the top banks to offer internships to physics and maths students and you are then fast-tracked into their graduate programmes with outrageous starting salaries of £50k plus. Obviously not everyone can manage to get onto these schemes, they are quite competitive, but finance is only one of a number of fields you can go into. Doing a more specialised graduate degree on top of a BA in maths is a great way to get into fields like actuarial science, computer programming, and many more.


^ This.
Original post by Mr M
Mathematics graduates are the second highest earners after graduates of medicine.


Gonna have to do the cliche correlation =/= causation here. There are very few jobs in which a maths degree offers material advantages over engineering, CS or physics, for example, and those jobs that are highly paid tend to be city work or software development - not degree-specific.

I suspect the reason why maths grads earn the most is actually just because they are smarter on average than the other grads. No one cares about topology or whatever in the real world.
Original post by M2k13
Ye I was very concerned on the unemployed part. Wasting years of education to be unemployed isn't a good thing to have... >.<



You nailed the part on the recession reason...
So what degree that's math-related is best suited for me and would be easier to get a job with if the recession continues for another 4-5 years? :rolleyes:
Compared to the Maths if broad subjects dont stand out well >.>


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


You will almost certainly get employed if you do maths - banks and city firms will snap you up in an instant, or you'll be able to get internships and fasttrack stuff with IT and software giants.


Although I think maths is a great subject and a fantastic degree, I personally wanted to start applying it to something at degree-level, and so I'm looking at doing Economics instead, focusing on areas like decision and game theory, behavioural economics etc.

Original post by jordanosborn
Pure mathematics encompasses geometry, algebra and calculus etc.

Geometry useful for building bridges, buildings almost anything. Good luck getting your bridge to stay up without some mathematics. Calculus used in physics, chemistry. Cleaning products, pharmaceuticals all developed by chemists guess what with the help of pure mathematics. Aircraft, cars all made better due to good understanding of pure mathematics. Without pure mathematics lets face it you wouldn't even be able to contact me right now.


This is also very true.
Reply 31
Original post by M2k13
I'm going to apply to Uni this year and my degree choices is a nightmare.

I love Maths and wish to pursue it at degree level. But I get complaints from my family that I will not get a job besides being a teacher/lecturer, as the degree is useless and the uni's exaggerate about the job prospects for a Maths graduate.

If its actually true then should I study Accountancy or Economics?
Even though I would expect myself to do better in a Maths degree compared to an accountancy or economics degree, as i'd have more motivation.

P.S. I study double Maths and economics at A level.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


I've heard from pretty reliable sources that companies actually prefer taking people with maths degrees rather than economics/accounting graduates :smile: A maths degree doesn't necessarily lead to a mathematical career in the same way that a degree in medicine usually means a career in medicine for example. It is just a degree that will show that you are pretty intelligent and are willing to work hard. It also gives you all the transferable skills you need in all jobs, problem-solving, logic etc. etc. I say if you have an interest in maths then go for it! It has the potential to lead to great things and at the end of the day it'll be you studying it for 3/4 years so it should be something you enjoy!
Original post by Dirac Delta Function
Gonna have to do the cliche correlation =/= causation here. There are very few jobs in which a maths degree offers material advantages over engineering, CS or physics, for example, and those jobs that are highly paid tend to be city work or software development - not degree-specific.

I suspect the reason why maths grads earn the most is actually just because they are smarter on average than the other grads. No one cares about topology or whatever in the real world.


I seem to remember that the actual report groups engineers with mathematicians anyway.

I was only trying to demonstrate that from a £££ point of view, a numerate degree is far from "useless".

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/maths-reform/9168744/Make-Britain-Count-reward-maths-with-more-cash.html
Reply 33
Id have personally thought that a maths degree would be highly regarded among employers especially those in the financial sector, i mean its not exactly an easy degree to study by any means is it?
But having droped maths years ago i could be talking tripe :biggrin:
Reply 34
Original post by M2k13
I'm going to apply to Uni this year and my degree choices is a nightmare.

I love Maths and wish to pursue it at degree level. But I get complaints from my family that I will not get a job besides being a teacher/lecturer, as the degree is useless and the uni's exaggerate about the job prospects for a Maths graduate.

If its actually true then should I study Accountancy or Economics?
Even though I would expect myself to do better in a Maths degree compared to an accountancy or economics degree, as i'd have more motivation.

P.S. I study double Maths and economics at A level.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


I had the same problem as you, except my careers adviser at school kept telling me not to do maths but instead to do engineering. She told me I would most likely become a teacher with maths, but now I wish I had chosen maths as it has always been the one subject I like, and I am continuously finding out that maths graduates have unlimited opportunities in any field, from engineering, business, research to even medicine.

All I am saying is you must do maths if you want to.
Reply 35
If you like maths then that's what you should do.
Reply 36
Original post by thedifferentiator
Whats wrong with being a teacher?

It's not glorious but it's certainly not bad.

Working hours are generally not that long 9-3, granted there can be alot to do outside of school. But my maths teacher told me he did little to none outside of school as he didn't need to and he got it all done in school hours. This can't be said for other subjects.

13 weeks paid holiday.

People say there are high amounts of stress because you're trying to get kids to pass, but there is high amount of stress in most jobs.

Start on usually around the 25-28k a year range. Often rises quickly, my teacher was on 35k after a couple of years work, now he is head of department and on 50k. This is in an average school too. Better schools will pay slightly higher.

The job security is pretty decent as is the pension.

I'd personally consider it myself after my degree.


This sounds a little misinformed

Starting salary is 21k

Working hours are generally 8am - 10pm (SOOOOO much work outside of school, your source was either lying or not a very good teacher)

Stress is high because you need to get those D/E kids to get a C grade, OFSTED inspections etc.

Plus, kids just stress you out by misbehaving.

I did a maths degree, then a PGCE, I dont regret doing it because now I know that its not for me, Im now a software developer. You can only be a teacher if you 100% know you want to and have enough experience within a school to make that decision.


On subject I would say that a maths degree is definitly one of the best degrees out there, for example when at interview for my job I was up against someone with a Computer Science Degree (Software developer job). I got the job over him with a combination of personality and having the weight of a highly respected, difficult degree behind me even though this other guy had a much mroe relevant qualification.

Maths degree carry a lot of clout with employers and are much more highly respected than most.
Reply 37
Original post by dom99
This sounds a little misinformed

Starting salary is 21k

Working hours are generally 8am - 10pm (SOOOOO much work outside of school, your source was either lying or not a very good teacher)

Stress is high because you need to get those D/E kids to get a C grade, OFSTED inspections etc.

Plus, kids just stress you out by misbehaving.

I did a maths degree, then a PGCE, I dont regret doing it because now I know that its not for me, Im now a software developer. You can only be a teacher if you 100% know you want to and have enough experience within a school to make that decision.


On subject I would say that a maths degree is definitly one of the best degrees out there, for example when at interview for my job I was up against someone with a Computer Science Degree (Software developer job). I got the job over him with a combination of personality and having the weight of a highly respected, difficult degree behind me even though this other guy had a much mroe relevant qualification.

Maths degree carry a lot of clout with employers and are much more highly respected than most.


Very true on the teacher side.. Stress isn't helpful.

I want evidence from employers to show they want math degree students compared to other degrees >.<, doesn't help when everyone just says its highly respected.

Also how long after graduating would you even get a job with a Maths degree?

It's recession and unemployment is increasing... I wanna have a degree that doesn't put me in an unemployed situation for years...


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
You can still be an accountant with a maths degree if that's what you want. The maths in accountancy is laughably easy anyway. On the other hand, you probably can't be a maths teacher with an accountancy degree for that very reason.
I studied Maths and now have a job as a trainee actuary.
It isn't just that "employers like mathematicians because they're clever" - you'd be surprised how much the very abstract pure maths which is often thought of as "useless" actually does get used in the real world - and is actually considered very valuable since so few people can understand it or use it.
(edited 11 years ago)

Quick Reply

Latest