The Student Room Group

Good enough for Cambridge?!

Scroll to see replies

Original post by AwkwardLemur
He's only trying to say she lacked any extra-curricular activities. Cambridge look for well-rounded people which can help their university in many ways, rather than just being smart. Cambridge themselves even say they see E.C as a way of "having more time to sacrifice for studies".


Original post by JodiieK
From my friend who had the interview, she literally didn't do anything out of school. Therefore not sociable.


Original post by Lord of the Flies
Of course EC's can be good, but they won't save or kill an application. Cambridge don't reject people because the don't do enough EC's - they reject people when they don't see enough academic potential in them. My point is: this girl wasn't rejected due to lack of EC's or "being sociable" or whatever you want to call it.


As someone who got into Cambridge, I can confîrm what Lord of the Flies said.
Reply 41
Original post by TimmonaPortella
Well, if you made specious assumptions like that in your personal statement or submitted essays I can provide an alternative theory of why you were rejected.

So many people repeating the 5A*s nonsense without thinking about it in here...

OP, you're fine. (For everything but medicine. On that, see the med forum.)

At the people saying that ECs are important: they aren't. If they're not relevant to your course, they're utterly irrelevant to your application.


Any view on why I was rejected pre-interview would be very advantageous, I still wonder to this day okay maybe I was to hasty to presume that it was a 5A* cut off but this was information I was getting from other sources.

In terms of my preparation on the personal statment and SAQ I had wanted to attend Cambridge to do Physics ever since I was 12 or so. I had it all planned out I put down all my strengths, I mentioned why the tripos course was the best way to learn. Due to the fact that no one before my year had ever got more than an A*AAA my school said they would not predict higher so that was what I was predicted. and my references were all sound. As a Cambridge student I would like to hear your views on why my application was not well recieved?
Original post by mrppaulo
Any view on why I was rejected pre-interview would be very advantageous, I still wonder to this day okay maybe I was to hasty to presume that it was a 5A* cut off but this was information I was getting from other sources.

In terms of my preparation on the personal statment and SAQ I had wanted to attend Cambridge to do Physics ever since I was 12 or so. I had it all planned out I put down all my strengths, I mentioned why the tripos course was the best way to learn. Due to the fact that no one before my year had ever got more than an A*AAA my school said they would not predict higher so that was what I was predicted. and my references were all sound. As a Cambridge student I would like to hear your views on why my application was not well recieved?


It is absolutely impossible for us to tell why you were rejected. There are so many factors...
You could always try asking the admissions office where you applied (don't just ask "why did you reject me?", obviously) but they probably won't tell you anything (at least that's what I would expect)
Reply 43
Original post by DamoclesAustria
It is absolutely impossible for us to tell why you were rejected. There are so many factors...
You could always try asking the admissions office where you applied (don't just ask "why did you reject me?", obviously) but they probably won't tell you anything (at least that's what I would expect)


It's just so annoying how they couldn't even give me a chance to prove myself, oh well :s-smilie:
Original post by StudentAT
Hey, I know this question sounds a little stupid but realistically on average what is the minimum number of A*s a candidate is required to have to be accepted to study Medicine at Cambridge, would 5 A*s and 5 As be enough or would there be no point in applying with those grades because on the stalking page nearly all the people applying for Medicine seem to have above 7 A*s and of course very good A levels. Thank you :smile:



Original post by TheNoobyPotato
Cambridge mostly care about the UMS averages.



Original post by StudentAT
Ok, so GCSEs aren't a major deciding factor as long as you have high UMS scores? I'm just a little worried my GCSEs will hold me back if I were to apply to study Medicine at Cambridge. Thanks for your help :smile:


GCSE's will be quite a large factor for competitive courses like Medicine, but as long as you have a healthy number of A*s and As it shouldn't hold you back. Do you mind me asking if you went to a Private, Grammar or Comprehensive school?

And TheNoobyPotato is right in saying they care a lot about UMS averages.
Original post by mrppaulo
Any view on why I was rejected pre-interview would be very advantageous, I still wonder to this day okay maybe I was to hasty to presume that it was a 5A* cut off but this was information I was getting from other sources.

In terms of my preparation on the personal statment and SAQ I had wanted to attend Cambridge to do Physics ever since I was 12 or so. I had it all planned out I put down all my strengths, I mentioned why the tripos course was the best way to learn. Due to the fact that no one before my year had ever got more than an A*AAA my school said they would not predict higher so that was what I was predicted. and my references were all sound. As a Cambridge student I would like to hear your views on why my application was not well recieved?


As above, we couldn't possibly say why you were rejected. To be honest, talking about your strengths and the way the course is taught doesn't sound like an ideal Oxbridge PS, but again I can't say for sure. Suffice it to say that your GCSEs would certainly not have prevented you from getting an offer if your application was strong enough otherwise.
Reply 46
Original post by mrppaulo
Any view on why I was rejected pre-interview would be very advantageous, I still wonder to this day okay maybe I was to hasty to presume that it was a 5A* cut off but this was information I was getting from other sources.

In terms of my preparation on the personal statment and SAQ I had wanted to attend Cambridge to do Physics ever since I was 12 or so. I had it all planned out I put down all my strengths, I mentioned why the tripos course was the best way to learn. Due to the fact that no one before my year had ever got more than an A*AAA my school said they would not predict higher so that was what I was predicted. and my references were all sound. As a Cambridge student I would like to hear your views on why my application was not well recieved?


The most likely thing would be low average UMS at AS for your relevant subjects. They would have wanted to see interest in your subject more than interest in Cambridge in your PS. Other than that unless there was a pre-test (as in Medicine) it is difficult to know.
Reply 47
Original post by StudentAT
Ok, so GCSEs aren't a major deciding factor as long as you have high UMS scores? I'm just a little worried my GCSEs will hold me back if I were to apply to study Medicine at Cambridge. Thanks for your help :smile:


I keep quoting this presentation because it is the most objective evidence we have. We don't know how these people interviewed or anything else about their application and we can assume some of the low scorers had extenuating circumstances.
Not many offer holders had less than 5 or 6 GCSE A* but some certainly did.

http://www.study.cam.ac.uk/undergraduate/teachers/presentations/teachersforum2010.pdf
Reply 48
Original post by AwkwardLemur
GCSE's will be quite a large factor for competitive courses like Medicine, but as long as you have a healthy number of A*s and As it shouldn't hold you back. Do you mind me asking if you went to a Private, Grammar or Comprehensive school?

And TheNoobyPotato is right in saying they care a lot about UMS averages.


I went to a comprehensive school where the percentage of A*-C grades was around 50% this year, do you think that could have any effect on my application? Thanks


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 49
Hey if you don't mind me asking, did your friend get in through the CSAS?


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Original post by StudentAT
I went to a comprehensive school where the percentage of A*-C grades was around 50% this year, do you think that could have any effect on my application? Thanks


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


In which case they'll be expecting a mixture of A*s, As and Bs so you'll be fine
Reply 51
Original post by lilelle
Hi,

I've been thinking about applying to Cambridge, but I don't know what my chances are because of my GCSEs. I got five A*s, three As and two Bs. How important are GCSEs? I've done some research but all of the answers are pretty vague.




I've only got 4 A*'s, 4 A's, and 2 Bs, and only predicted 3 A's at A Level, but I'm applying anyway (though I probably won't get an interview). Sometimes you've got to take a risk. Even so, Cambridge isn't the be all and end all.
Reply 52
Original post by StudentAT
I went to a comprehensive school where the percentage of A*-C grades was around 50% this year, do you think that could have any effect on my application? Thanks


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App


The evidence they have is that high GCSEs from poor schools are good predictors of success. Poor AS UMS marks are not. So if you have done well at AS your school will help to explain less good GCSEs.

There is much more info in the Cambridge forum.
Reply 53
Just a random point I'd like to make with regards to my Cambridge experience and GCSEs...

I applied for Maths last year and got a pre-interview rejection.

My GCSEs were 2A*, 6A, 5B and 2C and my school only got 33% A*-C. When I got feedback, I was told that "my stats modules weren't close enough to 90%" (I got 83% and 68%; the latter being my only blip from all my exams) and that "they would have liked to have seen more A*s at GCSE".

From my experience, I would say that, whilst Cambridge doesn't particularly value GCSEs when compared to your AS Levels, they can be used as a way of judging candidates who are on the borderline of getting an offer, or even an interview.
Reply 54
Original post by JoshC.
Just a random point I'd like to make with regards to my Cambridge experience and GCSEs...

I applied for Maths last year and got a pre-interview rejection.

My GCSEs were 2A*, 6A, 5B and 2C and my school only got 33% A*-C. When I got feedback, I was told that "my stats modules weren't close enough to 90%" (I got 83% and 68%; the latter being my only blip from all my exams) and that "they would have liked to have seen more A*s at GCSE".

From my experience, I would say that, whilst Cambridge doesn't particularly value GCSEs when compared to your AS Levels, they can be used as a way of judging candidates who are on the borderline of getting an offer, or even an interview.


I agree, but at the same time, you did do 15 GCSEs.
For someone who did 10 GCSEs, 2A*s would be considered slightly higher.
Original post by Coke1
True- but at the same time, don't forget that it will depend on the course.
If you want to apply for Law or Medicine, they will be harsher with GCSE standards. Also, they evaluate each student differently. E.g If student X has 5A*s and went to a top private school, but student Y has 4A*s and went to an average school, student Y will look better....


FWIW I'm one of the guys listed (2 A*s at GCSE) and I went to a good private school.
(edited 11 years ago)
Reply 56
Original post by Eleanorclareh
Am I likely to get an interview for Architecture BA?
AS grades
Sculpture - A
English Lit - A
History - A
Physics - A (Dropping :frown: )
A2 Predictions
Sculpture - A*
English Lit - A*
History - A*

Help!! xxx

This is a pretty silly question if we are solely talking about your grades. Those are all top grades, I don't see the problem...

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending