Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?

Got a breaking news topic or want to post the most recent issues for sensible, on-topic discussion? This is the forum for you.

Announcements Posted on
Sign in to Reply
  1. Iso Herrk's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 90
    • Warning points: 1000
    Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Why don't we just extradite journalists, editors and photographers responsible for the pictures. They may well have broken British law, Public Order Act at the least or you could argue it's Incitement or Sedition/Endangering State Security or if you had to charge them under the Terrorism Act.

    Most of our extradition treaties with the countries concentrating don't even require us to prove a case to the country concerned just request the extradition and they've to fulfill it. Get them here and remand them to Belmarsh Prison straight away.

    Justice must be served. William represents the Queen at times who represents the UK which means these pictures are disrespectful to Britain. They only appear in the media on official duties, they don't flaunt their private life all over it and so are entitled to not be harassed.
    Last edited by Iso Herrk; 15-09-2012 at 17:25.
  2. Panda Bear's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: London
    • Posts: 2,977
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Terrorism Act? Seriously?
  3. psychojonas's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Great Britain
    • Posts: 653
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    You can't extradite them if they're not in Britain, as it stands the photos were taken in France for a French magazine, probably by some anti-monarchist Frenchman.
  4. und's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    There are so many journalists living in exile because they would be arrested if they went back to their original countries. My father was one of them for a while - he risked being arrested and tortured. What an absolutely terrible idea to extend extradition to journalism, risking limiting freedom of press even further.

    EDIT: I take it people support like Turkey that imprison their journalists for opposing the government. Wouldn't it be ****ing great if the UK followed suit by requesting that journalists from other countries are put on trial over here? The UK would officially become one of the worst countries for freedom of press, and many countries would be forced to sever relations with the UK.
    Last edited by und; 15-09-2012 at 21:24.
  5. Jordan_1's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Posts: 1,774
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Just, shut up.
  6. alexmagpie's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,329
    • Warning points: 2
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    How do Kate Middleton's boobs endanger state security, exactly?
  7. Darth Stewie's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    They are already suing the magazine through the French courts and please endangering state security? are the taliban going to build a teet seeking missile?

    It's a woman sunbathing with her top off, frankly the most distressing thing about this whole pantomime is that the story has been on the front pages of news papers for 3 days.
    Last edited by Darth Stewie; 15-09-2012 at 17:39.
  8. Martyn*'s Avatar
    • TSR Legend
    • Location: Wigan
    • Posts: 11,867
    • Warning points: 5
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    (Original post by Iso Herrk)
    Why don't we just extradite journalists, editors and photographers responsible for the pictures. They may well have broken British law, Public Order Act at the least or you could argue it's Incitement or Sedition/Endangering State Security or if you had to charge them under the Terrorism Act.

    Most of our extradition treaties with the countries concentrating don't even require us to prove a case to the country concerned just request the extradition and they've to fulfill it. Get them here and remand them to Belmarsh Prison straight away.

    Justice must be served. William represents the Queen at times who represents the UK which means these pictures are disrespectful to Britain. They only appear in the media on official duties, they don't flaunt their private life all over it and so are entitled to not be harassed.
    You don't understand. The Royals are just constitutional. Remember? :rolleyes:
  9. zara55's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Location: Cheshire / Edinburgh
    • Posts: 953
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    (Original post by alexmagpie)
    How do Kate Middleton's boobs endanger state security, exactly?
    We always need to keep abreast of potential threats.
  10. alexmagpie's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,329
    • Warning points: 2
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    (Original post by zara55)
    We always need to keep abreast of potential threats.
    I suppose you're right, we can't let these things rack up.
  11. Joel95's Avatar
    • Full Member
    • Location: Herefordshire
    • Posts: 135
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    If it's not a crime in France then there really aren't any grounds to extradite them. But the terrorism act? For a photo of some boobs.... She's in the royal family but it would be completely ridiculous to argue that this is somehow putting Britain at risk. This is a breach of privacy, which is a huge shame but few complain (at least this much) when it happens to other celebrities. Sure they can go and sue whoever's responsible, as it shouldn't be allowed to take unauthorised pictures of people in private property, but the fact that she's married into a well known genes shouldn't change anything.
  12. cl_steele's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Location: Wellington
    • Warning points: 15
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    correct me if im wrong but since when can you extradite someone who isnt british and hasnt committed a crime in britain to britain ?
  13. That Bearded Man's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Location: A glass case of emotion
    • Posts: 2,487
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Who really cares?

    Surely those photos will help boost trade with Italy?
  14. RedDevilThing's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,745
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    (Original post by alexmagpie)
    I suppose you're right, we can't let these things rack up.
    If we're not careful the next thing you know everything has gone tits up. And then we'd be busted.

    OP, you're being a melon. People publishing pictures of breasts are not terrorists. I don't agree with what they did, but as far as I'm aware they did nothing wrong under French law so there's nothing we can do. So can it.
  15. Superunknown17's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Wales
    • Posts: 888
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Though I'm certainly not a royalist, I don't believe that their privacy should have been invaded like that. Though I would have expected more from the future Queen.
  16. alexmagpie's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,329
    • Warning points: 2
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    (Original post by RedDevilThing)
    If we're not careful the next thing you know everything has gone tits up. And then we'd be busted.

    OP, you're being a melon. People publishing pictures of breasts are not terrorists. I don't agree with what they did, but as far as I'm aware they did nothing wrong under French law so there's nothing we can do. So can it.
    You're so right, got to nip these things in the bud. At least in a few weeks it'll all just be a mammary.
  17. f1mad's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Posts: 5,423
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Yawn.
  18. The Gentle Giant's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 463
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    Nah, it'd just be quicker and easier to just declare war on France to uphold the Princesses honour. We can also get Calais back, and send a message not to mess with the royals.

    Everybody wins
  19. Beebumble's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 2,816
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    because only the American government can pluck people out of their countries for breaking a law that doesn't exist in that persons country.
  20. Joshalos's Avatar
    • Benevolent Member
    • Location: Devon
    • Posts: 863
    Re: Can we extradite those responsible for the Kate topless photos?
    This whole topless photo thing has gone completely tits up. Wow, she was bathing topless, maybe she did think it was in private but she should have expected a chance to be seen like that considering her high profile.


    ...:teehee:

    Edit: Aw, damn. Beaten to the pun. Erm... Don't know how longer the papers are going to milk this story for. :colonhash:
    Last edited by Joshalos; 15-09-2012 at 18:15.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.